Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che ha fatto detransition: ho vissuto come uomo e preso testosterone, e a fine dicembre 2023 era passato circa un anno dall'interruzione. Mi presento ancora in modo mascolino, ma in modo da rendere chiaro che sono una donna, e lo trovo liberatorio. Credo che gran parte di ciò che mi ha spinta verso la transizione fosse fantasia, resa contorta dal mio essere nello spettro autistico, e ora penso che essere donna non sia un costume. Sto cercando modi per invertire gli effetti del testosterone, compresi la depilazione laser e una procedura per la voce, e porto cicatrici che un tempo credevo mascoline. Sono critica verso la transizione per come viene inquadrata oggi, mettendo in discussione la terminologia FtM e temendo che le persone non conformi al genere vengano spinte verso identità trans o non binarie.
Storia completa
I am a detransitioned female who lived as a man and took testosterone, and I have been off T for about a year as of late December 2023. I was born female. I still present masculine, but in a way that makes it clear to people I am a woman, and I find that freeing — accepting myself and acting as I please instead of conforming to what I now see as trans stereotypes of gender.
I came to detransition through a mix of self-reflection and realizing how much of what I felt was fantasy. I have said that a lot of what I felt was tied up in fantasy, and that being on the autism spectrum made it all convoluted for me. I now think being a woman is not a costume, and that you can already dress however you want without medical transition. I told someone asking me for advice to think hard about whether their desire to transition is fantasy and sexually tied, or some need worth pursuing even if they never reach their imagined self.
I have been researching options to reverse some of the effects of testosterone. I asked about whether rubbing extra estrogen might help shrink something and suggested seeing a doctor, noting there are surgeries with their own risks. I mentioned that laser hair removal seems permanent as long as you stay off T outside female ranges, with possible electrolysis touch-ups for lighter hair. I also discussed voice — I said I was researching a voice procedure on the west coast, mentioning one in California, because I did not want a 'dumb clocky ftm voice which seems to be the norm,' and because voice felt important with fewer do-overs than face work. I have scars I described as 'ugly' that I once thought were masculine; I said the good thing was they hide my scars. I also noted that at a certain age you would still need HRT post-menopause, so that part is manageable.
I have reflected a lot on how women versus men are treated. I often felt women are treated more like humans and men are treated as dangerous, and I have realized it is a lot better being a woman than a man in terms of perception. I believe being a man is worse than being a female and that female passing is harder and in many ways better. I think people can assume whatever, but gender is not appearance — like me, you are a female and will always be female, not a man. I have said I had to learn that if you have a vulva you are a woman, and that you cannot opt out of being a man or a woman.
I am critical of transition as it is currently framed. I questioned why it is called FtM when no female becomes male, wondering if it actually means feminine to masculine. I think the terminology causes people to take medication and reinforces stereotypes instead of just being themselves in the body they have. I do not understand how non-binary is not just gender nonconforming, and I worry that gender-nonconforming people get pushed into non-binary or trans identities when they could just be, for example, a straight masculine woman who likes men and wears masculine clothes. I wonder how many people fall into the trap and realize how impossible it is after trying. I have also said that I think people did not mind trans people until it became a place where you cannot talk negatively at all, and that it has become a hotbed of mental illness.
I have been active in online detrans and gender-critical discussion, though I noted one site where 'a smidgen of criticism and you get blocked or message removed' is not a place to share freely. I admitted my flair was wrong and that I am actually detrans. I have been harassed online about my sex, including someone questioning whether I am female in a post where I shared how I look now, one year off T, wearing a wig. I also noted that testosterone can make women interested in men, but that did not happen for me. I have shared photos of myself and received comments on my appearance; in one exchange I encouraged someone that they can incorporate any style they want and still be themselves.
I have not described specific diagnoses, surgeries by name, dates of starting or stopping hormones beyond being one year off T as of December 2023, or detailed mental health history in this transcript. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm. My attitude toward other people's transition is critical and cautionary, and I have offered advice to others questioning transition while being supportive of their autonomy.