Tutte le storie

Il problema era l'eterosessualità, non l'essere donna

Femmina · Desistito/a104
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna lesbica che ha fatto detransition (desistito) e non ha mai fatto una transizione medica. Ho desistito accettando che non sarei mai stata conforme al genere come donna e arrivando a vedere il genere come sinonimo del sesso. I miei problemi di genere erano legati alle aspettative eteronormative e alla convinzione che essere un uomo sarebbe stato più facile che essere lesbica. Sono convinta che le donne trans che si identificano come lesbiche si approprino e feticizzino il lesbismo sulla base della socializzazione maschile e di aspettative informate dal porno. Sono critica verso il modello del consenso informato dell'assistenza sanitaria trans e sostengo attivamente nei forum le preoccupazioni di chi fa detransition.

Storia completa

I am a lesbian woman who desisted from a cross-sex identification before ever undergoing any medical intervention. My gender identity struggles were, I now understand, largely tied to heteronormative expectations — for reasons I couldn't fully articulate at the time, I believed it would be easier to be a man than to be a lesbian. I never medically transitioned, but I now think that if I had gone through with it, seeing male-to-female transitions would have been upsetting to me. My desisting process was about arriving at self-acceptance: accepting that I would never be gender conforming in the rigid sense of what that means for a woman — not in who I love, how I want to be represented in a relationship, the clothes I feel comfortable wearing (boys' clothes about 95% of the time), how I interact with the world, or how the world interacts with me. I came to view gender as synonymous with sex, since that is what it effectively was to 99% of people until recently. I feel that rejecting my womanhood because I don't conform to feminine stereotypes would be a disservice to the women who fought hard, with great consequence, for my freedom not to conform while still having a place in this world. I have never been medically detransitioned, so I can't speak to that experience directly, but I try to encourage others who are further along in their detransition journey that they can live a normal, even wonderful, life. I have significant resentment toward trans women who identify as lesbians. I knew one 'trans lesbian' whom I met before transition; we ended up living together as flatmates, and that's when they came out. I was supportive at first, but it quickly became uncomfortable — they began sharing graphic sexual fantasies that were essentially lesbian porn directed at and for men, something that had never been part of our friendship before, and they started overtly hitting on me. It made me feel gross in a way a woman never had, and I felt like a pawn in their fetish. More recently, another trans lesbian befriended me with the same dynamic: hitting on me despite knowing I had a partner, and only talking about graphic sex scenarios from a male-gaze perspective. I regret validating both of them, because they constantly fished for it, just to avoid being hurtful or seeming like a prude. I never had those vibes or conversations with any of my lesbian or heterosexual cis friends. I attribute this to a combination of male socialisation and a misunderstanding of what it means to be a lesbian, based on poor source material like porn. Both of them told me they wanted to be with a woman 'as a woman,' and not in terms of genitals, which felt alien to me because I don't think any relationship needs traditional gender roles regardless of the sexes involved. I've seen heterosexual friends in gender-conforming relationships and ones largely indiscernible from mine apart from being a man and a woman. I'm frustrated that a large part of who I am feels appropriated by trans women in a way that doesn't reflect my experience, and that they help perpetuate harmful gender stereotypes. I wish they would use the word 'queer' rather than 'lesbian,' and I feel pushed out and talked over in spaces that should be for me. I also find 'gender fluidity' as a phrase irritating, especially when tied to trans identity — expecting people to conform to different pronouns and accept you in different sexed spaces on a whim strikes me as counterproductive. I believe sex is immutable and that gender, being defined by multiple factors including sex, is effectively synonymous with it. I acknowledge this is my theory rather than an incontrovertible truth. I'm critical of how trans healthcare is defended: I've argued with detransitioners who think it's all fine, and I've pushed back hard against people who dismiss concerns about informed consent, arguing that many people attest to being poorly informed about their choices. I don't consider myself an activist, but I do engage passionately in these debates on detransition forums.