Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I am a desisted woman who is bisexual, and I have thought a lot about how internalized homophobia and societal pressure shaped my earlier identification as trans. I recall my teenage self wondering whether I really wanted to be trans, and I remembered the trans community's line that "if you think youre trans or want to be trans, then youre trans" — which led me to reason that if I didn't want to be trans, then I wasn't, and I began to come to terms with being a butch girl/woman.
When I first desisted, I hyperfocused on being feminine because I wanted to prove that I was a woman. I eventually realized this was the same pattern as when I had hyperfocused on being masculine while I said I was trans. I noted that it was a tough pill to swallow, because it meant people had been pretending to go along with my identity since there was no way I was masculine like a man. I am tall, toned, and have short hair, so I'm not traditionally feminine, but I came to believe those traits aren't innately masculine. I stopped trying to fit with femininity, reasoning that anything I do in a female body is feminine — whether I'm working in the shop, digging in the dirt, or using the bathroom — because I am a woman with a female body. I also noted that spending lots of money on makeup and clothes is expensive.
I hold a critical view of patriarchal definitions of femininity. In an exchange with another desisted person, I argued that if femininity is defined as "acting like how women should be," then accepting that definition just reproduces patriarchal thinking — that treating femininity as a performance traps you in the same mindset you were in before, only with a detrans/desisted spin. I pushed back on the idea that we "owe femininity" in order to be women, while also maintaining that being born in a female body is what makes someone a woman.
On the question of transition itself, I have commented that when someone says trans is "not rooted in reality," they don't mean it isn't real, but rather that literally changing sex isn't a realistic thing and being trans encourages you to believe that. I've also argued that heterosexual messaging is inescapable — in music, TV, advertisements, books, seeing couples on the street, and family asking "do you have a boy that you like??" — comparing it to a fish not realizing it's in water, and noting that discovering you're gay doesn't make you immune to those pressures, especially as a teenager. I believe a lot of bisexual women and lesbians have a hard time coming to terms with feelings for women because of that bombardment, and can conclude "there must be something wrong with me and i must be a boy."
I have been critical of how r/detrans was slandered by others who then made r/actual_detrans because our community was "a bit too spicy for them." I've also taken a moderate view on activism, arguing that publicly calling people out on Reddit rarely changes minds and that the best way to change someone's mind is a one-on-one conversation, or at minimum a DM. I asked critical questions about medical practices, including questioning a clinician's remark that seemed to imply a patient was having sex with a dog, and questioning a claim that SRS causing sterility is "very beneficial to society at large."