Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna lesbica butch che ha fatto detransition, nata femmina, che ha preso il testosterone per circa 1,5-2 anni a partire dal 2017 e ha smesso all'inizio del 2019. La transizione era guidata da un trauma profondo, da abusi radicati nella misoginia, da un autismo non diagnosticato e dall'iperfissazione sulla transizione come soluzione; la scoperta del femminismo e di modelli di lesbiche butch ha innescato la mia detransition. Mi è rimasta una voce roca, un po' di peli sul viso e un notevole aumento di peso, ma in gran parte sono in pace con il mio corpo e dico di essere contenta di aver fatto la transizione perché mi ha aiutata a elaborare il trauma e la misoginia interiorizzata. Sostengo le persone trans che vivono come vogliono, ma sono critica verso quello che vedo come sessismo in alcuni spazi trans, e la detransition mi ha spinta più a sinistra/in senso radicale anziché verso il conservatorismo. Attualmente mi identifico come donna lesbica butch che ha fatto detransition e per la maggior parte del tempo passo per donna.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in an evangelical cult, which I eventually left and now describe myself as vaguely agnostic. I also believe I'm autistic, though it went undiagnosed for a long time — I've written that autistic people often struggle to identify what they're feeling and that my autism 'fell under the radar.' I experienced abuse with a basis in misogyny, and for years beforehand I went to therapists to make sure transition was the right decision. My mother and I had several long conversation cry sessions about it, and my entire family was sending me videos of detransitioners when I first came out — they were right, but as a teenager I was stuck in the 'it's not a phase' phase, reinforced by friends on the internet.
I got hyperfocused on transitioning being the solution to my problems rather than dealing with my deep-seated issues. I waited six months to get on hormones because I went to a low-cost clinic in Texas with a waiting list; after a single 10-minute appointment where they asked me 'how long have you wanted to be a man?' I had hormones. I was on testosterone for around two years (elsewhere I said 1.5 years, before it started making me dysphoric). I never had surgery that I mentioned.
Even when I 'passed,' I never felt like I fit in. I missed women and hated the way men talked about women when I was around; I knew they included me in that definition and was paranoid I'd give myself away. I described it as 'living as a secret agent 24/7,' the only safe space being around other trans mascs. Two years before detransitioning I felt that if I didn't transition I would die, and felt 'ants crawling in my skin' whenever I looked in a mirror.
I stopped T in early 2019 — my first post, on April 25, 2019, said I'd stopped about three weeks earlier. The first few weeks were rough: I felt like 'absolute garbage,' had terrible body dysphoria, felt fat, bloated and ugly, and even my usual feel-good clothes didn't feel right. I dreaded telling my family, feeling guilt at putting them through everything and humiliation at being wrong after all this time, but I had to live authentically. They turned out to be very supportive of my detransitioning and remained loving and supportive years later.
What moved me toward detransition was discovering feminism and finding role models — out, proud butch lesbians — which was pivotal in realizing I could just be a masculine female, and that being a woman who loves other women didn't make me a broken person. I wrote that a lot of my abuse had a basis in misogyny and that feminism is what got me to question whether I should detransition. About three months off T I wrote that I welcomed my body, felt 'at home with her, hair, breasts, fat and all,' and felt 'so female and so, so powerful.' I also realized I'd been obsessing about passing and putting myself into a 'male' box, limiting myself to 'male' activities; when I stopped feeding my dysphoria it got smaller and more manageable.
Medically, I was told by all my doctors that the irreversible changes would be voice deepening, clitoral growth, hair growth, and male-pattern hair loss. A year off T (after about two years on), my voice hadn't returned to its pre-T pitch but had gotten noticeably higher; my clitoris had gotten smaller but not as small as before; hair growth remained more or less the same but came in more slowly; I was lucky not to experience baldness. The hardest thing to reverse was weight: I was around 130 pounds before T and gained about 60 pounds over two years, which has been hard to lose despite being fairly healthy and active.
Currently I identify as a detransitioned butch lesbian woman. I 'pass' as a girl about 95% of the time — roughly 1% of people think I'm an actual dude and 4% are LGBT people who assume women can't wear jeans. I have a gravelly voice, muscles, a crewcut, flannels, work boots, and a couple of chin hairs I think are cute, and I'm happy with my voice and leg hair. The facial hair is the only thing that bugs me, and I prefer the scruff to the feeling after shaving. I love being big and strong for my community and showing little girls there are different ways to be a woman.
I'm glad I transitioned: I learned a lot about myself, processed deep-seated trauma, and got rid of a lot of my internalized misogyny, which made me a better woman and person overall. I have some dysphoria days still but I'm mostly neutral about my body — 'it's just the meat that holds all of me together.'
Socially, I find it exhausting that people ask me (and only me) my pronouns and then they/them me even after I say I use she; I find it aggravating when people ask 'but are you *really* a girl?' I'm frustrated by what I see as sexism in some trans spaces — being asked my pronouns simply because I'm a GNC woman in pants — and I've said I often don't get along with trans women because of misogyny. I've also written about how autistic women can fall down a rabbit hole questioning whether they're women at all when womanhood is defined as a feeling connected to womanhood or femininity they don't relate to due to sensory issues.
On politics: detransition hasn't made me conservative — it's made me 'even more of a radical.' I refuse to align with men who don't think I'm a person just because trans people gross them out. My position is that trans people are people who deserve to live however they please, but they don't get to trample on women's hard-earned rights and spaces. I'm not a radfem and disclaim being transphobic, though I keep up with those circles. I'm uncomfortable in left-leaning spaces that prioritize 'feminist witchhunts' over rooting out pedophiles and racists, and I said I'd leave a subreddit if it became a 'republican circlejerk' after seeing LGBT people called groomers. I was crushed by Elliot Page's coming out, worried about the loss of lesbian role models, but said he doesn't owe us anything and I wouldn't wish my journey on anyone.