Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione. Ho iniziato il testosterone a 15 anni, ho fatto la mastectomia a doppia incisione a 17, ho vissuto stealth per diversi anni e a 19 ho deciso del tutto di fare detransizione, smettendo gli ormoni all'inizio del 2023. Mi pento della mastectomia — per i danni ai nervi, la perdita della capacità di allattare e perché era inutile — ma non del testosterone in sé. Provo ancora un po' di disforia di genere, anche se è migliorata molto con l'accettazione e il lavoro sulle paure e sulla paranoia legate al trauma di fondo. Ora considero la transizione medica inefficace per trattare la disforia e credo che non debba essere venduta come trattamento per la disforia di genere, pur sostenendo la libertà degli adulti di fare ciò che vogliono del proprio corpo.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first came out around age 13, at the same time I started seeing a therapist — though I hadn't initially been sent to her for anything gender-related; my parents had forced me into therapy. She diagnosed me with gender dysphoria, wrote a letter 'affirming the validity of my dysphoria' to an endocrinologist a couple years later, and encouraged medicalization. I started testosterone at 15 and had double-incision top surgery (a double mastectomy) at 17. I was on the same dose of T for four years — 0.25 ml — and my voice dropped within the first couple months. I lived completely stealth for a couple of years in my late teens, until about a year before I wrote this.
What led me toward transition was a mix of things. I'd had a difficult childhood — I was in therapy by 13, and I've come to understand that severe fears and paranoia related to men and my sex, which developed from trauma and from living as a young girl in general, were at the root of what I called dysphoria. What I viewed as 'dysphoria' was basically a fear of men viewing me sexually and a hatred of my genitalia because I felt it made me vulnerable — I felt I would be safer if people thought I was male. I was also very gender-nonconforming and masculine in my interests and appearance even before transitioning, and I think societal looking-down on people who dress or act outside their gender norms was 'at least 50% of what caused me to question and later transition in the first place.' I was also suicidal at 15, which made me not very concerned about the medical risks at the time. I never actually believed I was male — I wanted to be male, but I never thought I was, and I don't think I ever 'identified' as a guy.
I decided to detransition at 19. The main things that caused it were fears and paranoia. I was obsessed with passing and with no one realizing I was female. Even after hormones and surgery, I stayed paranoid around other people to the point where going in public was torture because I was constantly thinking people would read some characteristic as female. Transitioning also necessitated lying — I would lie about random things because I felt it was more in line with how a male would think or what a male would have experienced. For example, I used to play softball but would refer to it as 'baseball' because softball is mostly played by women. The pressure of keeping up those lies, especially while stealth, became crippling and was the main thing that caused me to detransition. I also realized I had started to believe my own fabricated 'signs' and changing my story, and I think I permanently damaged some of my memories that way.
I stopped hormones a bit over six months before August 2023, so around early 2023. My period came back after three months off T and has come every month since. I stopped going to my doctor when I came off T, which I've described as dumb. My voice lightened some within a few months of being off T but is still male-sounding — I'd have to do voice training to pass as female. I can sing higher again than I could on T, though my laugh is still fairly deep. I've been off T for over a year and a half now and my body hair hasn't lightened, though it may be thinner in some places. I don't plan to go on estrogen — my levels should return to normal naturally.
I regret top surgery. The three biggest reasons are: nerve damage — I have little to no sensation in my entire chest, with random pains and creepy referred feelings (touching one part of my chest, especially near the scars, I sometimes feel somewhere else); I cannot breastfeed, which makes me really sad because it's something I should have been able to do since birth; and it was completely unnecessary — I did have dysphoria about my breasts and bound my chest every day for at least eight hours, sometimes the whole day and overnight, but the solution wasn't surgery. The chest I have now is worse, not because I have dysphoria about it, but because of those things. The scars haven't really faded — the left side more than the right. I don't regret T itself. I don't blame my parents; they've always just wanted me to be happy and were equally supportive when I told them I wanted to detransition. My mom felt very guilty that she let me go on T and get surgery as a child, but I don't blame her. If anyone, I blamed the surgeon who operated on me — 'a mentally ill minor' — but more broadly I don't blame anyone; I made a choice and now I live with the consequences.
I still experience gender dysphoria, though it has improved. It hasn't gone away completely, but acceptance of reality and working through my issues myself have gone a long way toward making me much more comfortable in my body. I don't consider myself trans anymore. I reverted to my old name purely for the benefit of my family — I have older family members with severe memory issues and it seemed like too much to ask them to remember a third name. I came out to my friends by appealing to their ideology: I said 'I've realized I identify as a woman again, I would like to be referred to as [birthname],' and got zero questions, partly because they're very pro-trans and believe gender is just how a person identifies. I received very little pushback from anyone, though the little I got from my mom I initially wrote off as 'transphobia.' I haven't changed my name or gender back legally yet. I still don't wear makeup or dress differently than before. Sometimes people think I'm a little boy because of my height, but it doesn't bother me; if I tell them I'm actually a woman they look surprised but I've never been questioned about it. I can still pass as male easily because of my voice and clothing, and I've said I would have to put in conscious effort to 'pass' as female. I doubt I'll ever talk about trans stuff in real life because I know I would lose friends — most of my friends are very into trans ideology.
I don't think anyone should medically transition with the intention of alleviating dysphoria — though I don't think it should be illegal for adults, and I have no problem with adults doing whatever they want with their bodies. My problem is with doctors and politicians who say it's the only treatment for dysphoria or that suicide is inevitable if you don't transition. I believe gender dysphoria isn't innate, is primarily caused by trauma and/or other mental illnesses, and is essentially a form of body dysmorphia — comparable to an eating disorder, particularly with the distorted body image, and something that can spread between people, particularly teenage girls, though you need a preexisting vulnerability. I've compared my own obsessive disguising of feminine traits to my sister's obsessions with parts of her body she views as fat, and said a doctor wouldn't prescribe liposuction as a treatment for anorexia, so why are they prescribing mastectomies to girls who don't like their breasts. I think social contagion is the biggest factor in the spike in trans-identifying people, and that nonbinary identity is primarily caused by it. I've also said I think testosterone is literally addictive and that HRT is largely untested for long-term effects, and that we were 'literally being used as guinea pigs.' I've engaged in a fair amount of advocacy and argumentation online about these issues, and I've advised others considering transition to approach the question as 'did transitioning help me?' rather than 'am I actually trans?'