Tutte le storie

Una madre che non ha mai fatto la transizione, e lotta per quella di sua figlia

Femmina · Desistito/a487
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una madre consapevole sul tema della detransizione e un'attivista, una donna eterosessuale sulla quarantina che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma che ha lottato io stessa con il disagio dell'essere bambina. Mia figlia di quattordici anni si è identificata come trans nel 2019, insieme a depressione, ansia e autolesionismo, e mi sono impegnata per rimandare qualsiasi transizione sociale o medica garantendole una terapia. Organizzo eventi di sensibilizzazione sulla detransizione, tra cui un incontro collegato al Regno Unito nel 2019 e la Detrans Awareness Day nel 2023, e faccio ricerca accademica su disforia di genere e depressione. Sono molto critica verso il modello affermativo, il contagio sociale e le alleanze partitiche che credo confonderebbero il messaggio sui nostri figli. Continuo a fare attivismo pubblico temendo di essere chiamata bigotta, e spero che mia figlia risolva la sua identificazione senza medicalizzazione.

Storia completa

I am a heterosexual woman in my forties, and I am the mother of a fourteen-year-old daughter who came to identify as trans. I never transitioned myself, but I have lived alongside this issue closely through my daughter, and I have become active in detransition and gender-critical advocacy as a result. My own history with gender discomfort goes back to childhood. I hated how I felt as a young girl and coped by fattening up and trying to be invisible. I grew into adulthood and, as I put it, came into my own as a woman, going through what I describe as the 'bullshit trappings' — push-up bras, miniskirts, heels — before arriving at a comfortable, low-maintenance style in my forties: comfortable shoes, pants, plaid shirts, barely grooming, and feeling content. I also mentioned never expecting to live long enough to see forty, which suggests I struggled significantly when younger. I have never had any interest in medical or social transition; dressing in feminine clothes feels to me like wearing a costume, so I wear pants and comfortable shoes instead. The central event of my recent life has been my daughter's identification as a boy. She says it started in fifth grade, and around July 2019 she was diagnosed with depression and anxiety and started medication, which I felt made a huge difference in reducing the intensity of her need to transition. Before I knew about it, she had cut her hair, was binding, got rid of her 'girl' clothes, and secretly told her close friend group to use he/him pronouns. She also began self-harming — I found and removed razors, tacks, and a Swiss Army knife we had given her at age ten. She self-harmed most often when I was direct with her about transitioning, which was devastating for me. She was mistaken for a boy about ninety percent of the time, had a crush on a straight guy, and told me that even if surgery and drugs were awful, they would feel better than how she felt now. She was convinced she had a male brain and that hormones and top surgery would fix everything. I refused to allow binding or pronouns, though I did let her get the haircut and buy male clothes — something I later regretted, believing it psychologically reinforced her perception that she was a boy. I slowly tried to remove those clothes from her closet and replace them with subtly different options. My position was that we would not condone social transition at home or at school, that she should leave the door open, and that she should not do anything medical until she was twenty-five, when her body and brain were fully grown. I found her a therapist who specialized in body image and addiction — someone who knew nothing about gender dysphoria but could address self-hatred and the obsessive nature of her identification. I also recommended exposure therapy and self-exploration to a detransitioning person I was speaking with. What baffled me most was how similar all FTM teen stories were — no prior history of wanting to be a boy, no interest in boyish activities, a rewritten personal history. I came to believe this was social contagion, noting that I had heard the same 'group trans' story from other mothers. My daughter had fallen in love with a homeschooled trans kid she met through a friend, and that person later dropped my daughter for another new identity and friend group, leaving her 'betrayed and broken.' I concluded that nowhere was safe. I became politically and socially active. I organized around a detransition awareness event in the UK in November 2019 organized by Charlie Evans and tried to organize something similar in the Los Angeles / Southern California area. I posted about organizations using misleading website names to divert traffic from detransition and questioning resources. I was disappointed by what I saw as partisan co-opting of legal help, and I explicitly argued against allying with groups that were not LGB-friendly, worried that associating with the political right would taint the message and that my daughter, who I believed had a high chance of being gay, deserved allies who cared about her future. In 2023 I helped organize Detrans Awareness Day on March 12, soliciting video submissions of detransitioners saying 'I am detrans' for a social media campaign under #iamdetrans. I also did academic work on the subject: a research paper for a class in late 2019 in which I created a Google Form survey studying whether undiagnosed depression might affect gender dysphoria, with gender dysphoria as the criterion variable. I hold strong critical views about transition, particularly for adolescents. I have described the affirmative model as 'cult like,' said that 'trans is the golden ticket to adolescent discomfort,' and called transition 'a lie' and 'not a cure for puberty or for womanhood' but rather 'a lifetime of medical issues.' I believe my daughter's identification stems from self-loathing, depression, anxiety, and a desire to escape female bodies in a 'pornsick misogynistic society' — an impulse I understand but cannot support medically. I think the left has 'wholeheartedly embraced something so blatantly homophobic and misogynist.' I am cautious about speaking publicly, noting that saying these things out in the open gets you called a bigot fast. As for my own mental health, I have not described a diagnosis. I did mention not expecting to live to forty, but I gave no details. My daughter's self-harm remains ongoing and upsetting to me. I continue to hope she finds a happy medium and does not want or need medicalization.