Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha desistito/fatto detransition: non ho mai fatto coming out, non ho mai fatto una transizione sociale o medica, ma a metà del 2020, a 21 anni, ho attraversato circa un mese di intensi dubbi di genere, che oggi capisco come ruminazione/pensieri intrusivi tipo TOCD, alimentati dall'isolamento del lockdown, dalla sofferenza per un amore non ricambiato, dal vivere costantemente online negli spazi dei fandom e dalla mia tendenza ADHD/ASD a iperfissarmi. I dubbi sono finiti quasi all'istante dopo che mi sono confidata con mio padre, che mi sostiene, sul mio vero problema (l'amore non ricambiato), e tutti i pensieri intrusivi si sono placati del tutto in circa sei mesi con l'aiuto della mia counsellor scolastica, del journaling CBT, della meditazione, dell'abbandono degli spazi dei fandom e della scoperta di questo subreddit. Non ho avuto interventi medici, non ho cambiamenti irreversibili e non ho rimpianti per la transizione in sé, solo gratitudine di non aver mai agito sulla base di quei pensieri, anche se mi dispiace di non essermi confidata prima con i miei genitori. Ora sono una donna etero, conforme al genere ma un po' maschiaccio, critica verso l'attuale paradigma dell'affermazione di genere pur riconoscendo che la transizione aiuta alcune persone, e dedico molto tempo a consigliare online chi si trova in situazioni simili. Provo solo un lieve disagio residuo legato al genere in certe situazioni sociali e mi considero molto più stabile mentalmente rispetto a quel periodo.
Storia completa
I was born female and I am female. I have never transitioned — not socially, not medically, not even online — but in July 2020, during the COVID lockdown in my country, I went through what I have come to call my "gender hell": about a month of intense, obsessive questioning about whether I was really female, followed by roughly four to six months before all the intrusive thoughts fully subsided.
I was 21 at the time. I have ADHD and ASD (autism), diagnosed early in life, and my parents raised me as a normal kid even though they knew I was wired differently. I was always very gender-conforming as a child — I liked Barbies, princesses and fairies — while also liking Transformers and action shows on the side. I was comfortable being female my entire life before this episode. I am straight, and I have always had a strongly tomboyish personality: hotheaded, assertive, loud, foul-mouthed, with a naturally deeper voice than most females (no hormones, just my natural voice) and somewhat sharp, masculine facial features. I dress femininely and love cute, frilly things, and my interests are roughly 50-50 masculine-feminine.
The trigger was that two of my online friends came out as non-binary around the same time. One of them, a natal female, had written a long post about coming to realise their identity, describing discomfort with their low voice and gravitation towards androgynous characters — and I resonated with it. Because I was already in a bad place mentally, my brain made a false connection between my pain and their epiphany. Suddenly things I had always been fine with — my deeper voice, my masculine facial features, my liking of GNC characters — became "signs" that I might not be female. I was in a niche online community where I did voice acting/roleplay; because of my low voice I gravitated towards androgynous or GNC characters and young boy roles, which fed the rumination further.
The underlying causes were, in my own reading of it: prolonged isolation and loneliness during lockdown; severe emotional distress from personal problems completely unrelated to gender (including a broken heart from unrequited love for a guy friend, guilt and regret over mistakes I had made, and a fear of growing up despite being 21); being terminally online in fandom spaces where people were coming out as some kind of gender every other week and being celebrated for it; and my autistic/ADHD tendency to ruminate and hyperfixate. I also think I subconsciously wanted to escape to another identity — to "start a new game" as a new character — because I saw myself as weak for being unable to overcome my problems, and I thought becoming someone else might also make me more appealing to others since my issues were tied to not feeling attractive.
I never came out to anyone. I was so anxious I could barely function for a month. I did see my school counsellor, who was an excellent source of support: he told me to do things other than think about gender, that sometimes thoughts are just thoughts, and he suggested I set aside time each day to lie down and imagine what my life would be like if I were another gender just to entertain the thoughts — those sessions grew shorter and shorter as the thoughts became satisfied. He never pushed me towards transitioning. I also detoxed from social media, picked up meditation and mindfulness, and went back to school, which helped enormously.
The turning point came on 10 September 2020. I finally confided in my parents about my unrequited love problem. My father was surprisingly supportive and shared his own experiences of overcoming unrequited love at my age. The moment that conversation ended, all the remaining gender-questioning thoughts "dissipated into thin air almost instantly." I realised my questioning was actually my problems with unrequited love in disguise. I was slightly mad at myself for not confiding in them sooner.
I also stumbled across this detransition/desisting subreddit during my questioning period, and it really helped settle the questions on my mind — it was essentially the alternative explanation that let me break out of the framework. I later found that reading about detransitioners was probably the best solution in pulling me out of my problems. I also discovered TOCD (transgender-themed OCD) and became convinced that was essentially what I had experienced, though I never sought a formal diagnosis because I was doing so much better. The character Naoto Shirogane from Persona 4 — a female who presents as male because of societal pressure and ultimately accepts herself as a woman — became a fictional role model who helped ground me back in reality with my sex.
My recovery toolkit, which I have recommended to many others since: quitting the online spaces rife with gender ideology; focusing on studies, personal development and relationships; CBT journalling (writing down distorted thoughts, identifying the cognitive distortion, and reframing); meditation and mindfulness; walks in nature without my phone; and developing my own way of thinking by listening to heterodox viewpoints. About half a year passed before all gender-related intrusive thoughts fully subsided.
Medically there is nothing to report — I never took hormones, never had any procedure, and never socially transitioned. There are no irreversible changes, no fertility concerns, and no ongoing medical needs related to this. I did hate my breasts as a teenager and wanted to be flat-chested so I could cosplay male characters I was attracted to, but that passed.
Mentally, I had a month of near-paralysing anxiety and rumination, worst at night and under stress, sometimes triggered by forms with an "Other" gender option. It was not a clinical diagnosis but I described it as feeling like I was going mad, like an alien had hijacked my body and was gaslighting me. Since recovery I am doing way better — I feel driven, confident, and I have had epiphanies about why I do what I do. I still describe myself as a bit of a hermit and I am still terminally online in different spaces, and I still experience a residual discomfort or anxiety around gender in social situations — I get strangely fixated when friends say "she" in conversation, though not when family or professors do — but it is nothing like the earlier episode.
As for adversity, I was bullied by a lot of boys growing up and did not form close platonic bonds with guys until university. I experienced "vicarious" trauma from witnessing others being traumatised online. I had my first heartbreak around this period. Nothing more severe is described.
Socially, I come from a fairly westernised Asian country with a conservative culture (I am a Chinese Buddhist, though secular, as are my parents). My family is supportive — my father was supportive about my love problems. I have female friends I confide in deeply and I hang around a lot of guys. I have largely gone MIA in my old fandom and online spaces because I knew I would be mobbed or called a TERF for my views; I have lost touch with old trans-identified online friends. I now spend time on Discord with fans of a politically heterodox podcast and with other creatives who are well-adjusted adults.
Sexually, I am a straight female, and I was straight before and after this episode. I do not describe internalised homophobia; I do describe discomfort with how women are sexualised and a fear of being sexualised.
On regret: I do not regret a transition because I never transitioned. I have expressed being thankful, repeatedly and strongly, that I never did anything — "Thank god I never did anything like socially transition" — and that I had the sanity to take the other path. I do express some regret at not confiding in my parents sooner to avoid the stress, and regret at having spent time in fandom spaces that caused me major mental health problems. There is no ongoing intense regret about my body or medical changes because there were none.
My attitudes now: I am critical of the current gender-affirming paradigm while acknowledging that transition works for some people. I believe gender dysphoria should not be treated as having only one pathway; I advocate exploring the whole person first, citing Sasha Ayad and Stella O'Malley as models I hope will be more widely adopted within ten years. I am sceptical of "gender euphoria," of egg culture (which I have called grooming), of the concept of a gendered soul, and of the way GNC people are pushed towards transition. I am not a gender-critical feminist and I do not hate men, but I describe my politics as "heterodox centrist" and I have become comfortable forming my own viewpoints. I have done no formal advocacy or activism, but I have spent a great deal of time on this subreddit advising others in similar situations, recommending CBT, OCD resources like Chrissie Hodges, and non-gender therapists.