Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha fatto detransizione e che è cresciuto con un desiderio di vecchia data di essere una ragazza, indipendente da fattori sociali, e ora vivo stealth, senza identificarmi con la comunità trans né farne pubblicità, comunità da cui mi sono tagliato fuori per la mia sicurezza e salute mentale. La TOS ha alleviato rapidamente la mia depersonalizzazione preesistente, effetto che attribuisco in parte all'effetto placebo e a un problema di regolazione di serotonina/dopamina e non all'essere 'davvero femmina'. Lavoro nella sanità, critico gli standard diagnostici permissivi del settore e le sue tendenze da 'pill mill', e vedo l'AGP come un orientamento sessuale per tutta la vita da integrare più che da curare. Mi batto per un cambiamento dall'interno della comunità attraverso la Gender Dysphoria Alliance nonostante la mia famiglia preferisca che io ne stia fuori, e dico agli altri che essere nati maschi o femmine è reale mentre trans è solo un'identità che si può scegliere di non adottare. La mia identità attuale è quella di un uomo che ha fatto detransizione e vive da maschio.
Storia completa
I grew up as a boy and my experience was one of hard labor, high expectations, very little emotional support or outlet; I struggled in every way, was lonelier, and lacked meaningful connection. Violence and the potential for pain were very real, with threats, intimidation, indiscriminate targeting, and a general lack of communication. I had no sisters but was friends with and hung out with girls quite a bit, and I found their experiences equally disturbing — sexual harassment, body issues, low expectations regarding independence, cruelty and bullying that was emotional and sometimes violent; I found them even more competitive than boys, physical changes more traumatizing, and pregnancy and adulthood thrust on them earlier. I later clarified that there were pros and cons to each and that this was a generalized observation, since I also experienced wonderful things from boys and girls and group dynamics were sometimes great. Importantly, none of that culture or environment really mattered to me — my desire to be a girl ran independent from these, and it was not a 'grass is greener' situation, besides which the path to the other side was fraught with issues and compromises that made it an unattractive process.
I went most of my life without ever hearing about or knowing anyone who was trans and felt like I might be the only person out there; now I have a dozen or more people identifying as something a stone's throw from my home. I believe social factors play a role for all of us to some degree — when groups of trans people show up in one class or in friend groups all around the same time it should raise red flags. I attribute part of the issue to wide-open definitions used to define who is trans, lack of a requirement for gender dysphoria, and widespread belief that transition has no consequences.
Before HRT I experienced the same depersonalization many of us experienced. HRT in a very short time seemed to cure this and I felt connected and so much better; it has persisted to a large degree and many years later things are definitely better, though I recognize some placebo was likely involved. I still regard the effects as undeniably positive for me, but I insist this experience should not be confused as evidence that someone is really the opposite sex or trans. I speculate that people may suffer from a serotonin and dopamine regulation issue common among ASD and ADHD people, and that there may be a neurochemical effect of sex hormones influencing dissociative symptoms directly — compatible with reports of depersonalization remitting within days or weeks of starting HRT, before any visible physical changes. I recommend seeing a doctor about that regulation issue and exploring medications that do what estrogen is likely doing without estrogen.
I am in healthcare myself. I recognize that the industry has become 'a pill mill of sorts' and that practices in healthcare — not just trans care but diabetes, back pain and spinal surgery, hysterectomies — are borderline and fuzzy; it's complicated and I welcome discussion on it. I note that Plume and Folx arrived out of Covid demonstrating telemedicine has value. On diagnosis, I point out that ICD-11 doesn't recognize gender dysphoria as a mental health diagnosis the way the DSM does — gender incongruence is what is billed, under a sexual health category rather than a mental health one, and ICD billing requirements are guidelines for billing, not the DSM.
On AGP/AAP, I stress it is not a fetish per se — it can manifest as a romantic or sentimental attachment without an erotic element, a distinction Blanchard and Lawrence themselves make. I hold that, according to Blanchard who coined the term and Lawrence who wrote more on it, AGP is a sexual orientation; you will never make it go away and that is okay. It helps to identify what about it distresses you and what mitigates it, and many people find ways to integrate it — some transition, some do a mix. I believe you should only transition when it is appropriate for you.
The best thing I did was to stop associating with the trans community as much as possible — I found it so toxic and unhealthy that for my own safety and sanity I cut myself off from it, and I think most people gravitating to it have mental health issues. I am as stealth as possible: I don't advertise, don't identify, and don't out myself, and I don't recognize the community or most in it as even related to me. In its place I recommend getting out and being with other people — joining a club, taking up a hobby, or volunteering. I joined the Gender Dysphoria Alliance online, a group trying to do something about these issues. My wife and kids are begging me to stay out of it; they have valid concerns but I feel compelled, and I worry for all the other spouses and kids out there. I believe change must come from within the community because external pressure only makes people dig in. I suggested the Transparency podcast discussion with Phil Illy and the Aarons and Phil Illy's book Autohetereosexuality to others. I have told others that human beings are born male or female, that their feelings are real and innate, that being female with those experiences doesn't make them trans — trans is an identity people adopt, and they don't have to adopt it. I also read others' descriptions of anxiety surrounding being 'trans,' imposter syndrome, and fear of being found out, and asked what it is they feel is a lie.