Tutte le storie

Ragazzo femminile che pensava di essere gay, poi un anno di estrogeni

Maschio · Detransizionato/a2,6K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo etero che ha fatto detransizione, che ha fatto la transizione a 18 anni per evitare la mascolinizzazione dopo essere cresciuto come ragazzo femminile che dava per scontato di essere gay, e che ha fatto detransizione dopo circa un anno di estrogeni a intermittenza. La transizione ha peggiorato la mia disforia e l’odio per me stesso, e ora credo di aver avuto un’AGP a esordio precoce radicata in problemi di autostima, in un rapporto teso con mio padre e nel risentimento verso una mascolinità da cui mi sentivo escluso. Ho smesso gli ormoni di colpo, mi sono rasato i capelli e in circa tre anni mi sono sentito decisamente più a mio agio nel presentarmi in modo mascolino e attratto solo dalle donne. Mi pento di aver fatto la transizione e ora sono esplicitamente contro la transizione, sostenendo pubblicamente che nessuno sia un buon candidato alla transizione medica e che la disforia si possa sempre superare senza. Il principale problema fisico duraturo è la ginecomastia da estrogeni, che nascondo con il binder e che spero di far rimuovere chirurgicamente; dalla detransizione non ho segnalato ideazione suicidaria né tentativi.

Storia completa

I was born male and grew up as a feminine boy — by my own description, 'a fem-ish boy growing up like birth-12, not very or explicitly feminine though, but definetly more feminine than my peers.' I wore women's clothing, shaved my body hair, and acted hyperfeminine during my teenage years. I now understand a lot of that femininity as a way of rejecting masculinity I felt excluded from: 'I didn't just like femininity, I resented masculinity, and in retrospect this was obviously because I felt left out of it, so I latched on what seemed like the next best thing.' A strained relationship with my father was a major factor. I've written that I was 'a more feminine boy (probably due to a strained relationship with my dad)' and that I had 'a weak male father figure,' which left me with 'negative associations of masculinity with just being a bad person.' Everyone assumed I was gay — family, peers — and so I assumed it too, even though in hindsight I was clearly attracted to women: 'Even though in hindsight I experienced clear attraction to women, I really thought I was gay and I guess wanted to be as well and so I just stuck with it.' I built my identity around being a 'super fem twink gay' during my teenage years and wore women's clothing and light makeup in high school as a 'gay guy.' I now think of that period as 'very early onset AGP' — I internalized my desire for women and feelings of inferiority toward other men as being the feminine party, and my attraction to men was 'just a paraphilia brought about by feeling inferior to men and desiring women, but projecting womanhood onto myself.' I watched mostly straight porn or male solo and couldn't get into gay porn because 'the guys weren't masculine enough.' I transitioned at 18, explicitly 'to try and avoid masculinization.' I learned about transgenderism as a mainstream concept through media — I've cited TikTok and the show Euphoria as influences — and 'immediately latched onto it because it felt like clearly what I was.' I was on feminizing HRT (estrogen) for about a year at the end of puberty, taken orally, and I went on and off frequently during a period of uncertainty. At one point I would 'restart the rx every time a new episode of Euphoria came out.' I also had a period where I was 'rapidly switching between on/off HRT for months,' including 'on/off HRT every other week for a period of 1 month or so early on in detransition, just rapid cycling my hormones.' I passed reasonably well after a short time on HRT — 'After a few months of HRT and growing out my hair, I passed pretty well' — and was gendered as a woman in public. But it made things worse, not better: 'Even after getting to the point of being gendered as a woman in public, though, I still felt dysphoric but now much worse and different. I felt like a creep amongst women, and a freak amongst men and I hated myself much more than ever.' I hid my doubts the whole time: 'I was having tremendous doubt and shame the whole time that I never expressed and just dismissed as my own internalized transphobia.' My family was very supportive of my transition, with only 'a little resistance from my Mom.' I now think that lack of resistance is precisely why I detransitioned relatively easily: 'I only think I detransitioned because of the lack of resistance I got to my transition, I wasn't always on the defense with my identity and so it led me to think about it more which of course lead to detransition.' I detransitioned early compared to many detransitioners — I describe myself as '21' in May 2024, having transitioned at 18, so roughly three years since transition, with only about a year of actual HRT exposure. In early detransition I told nobody and 'just sorta slowly presented less female,' and I didn't tell anyone when I went off hormones. I stopped HRT cold turkey. I also did a buzz cut when I detransitioned, which 'felt like a necessary phase,' and have since been growing my hair back out. In early detransition I identified as bisexual and non-binary while figuring things out. Over time my sexuality shifted back: 'Pre transition I was an overtly feminine gay guy, and now post transition I am only attracted to women and am a lot less feminine.' I don't think the HRT chemically changed my sexuality, but rather that transition and detransition forced me to reevaluate: 'I was very uninterested/sometimes grossed out by the female body which is weird considering I was bisexual before identifying as gay... I think part of my lack of attraction to women during those years was due to seeing myself as a feminine (and thus lesser) man and not esteeming myself as capable of being with them.' I also fell for a female friend, and 'it wasn't until I felt like I could be with a woman... that I realized I really only wanted to be with women.' Physical changes from estrogen: I developed gynecomastia — 'I have bad gynecomastia from estrogen' and 'I had a lot of breast growth though so surgery is definetly needed.' I currently bind my chest with a compression shirt and exercise my chest, and I say 'I have not done anything abt my chest (yet).' I'm saving for surgery but worry about scarring: 'I feel like I have so much tissue that I'll have big scars.' I also noted 'a period where my hair was slightly thinner after stopping HRT,' though I couldn't tell if that was from weight loss. My body and facial hair 'thinned a lot on HRT but has returned to baseline after like 3/4 months.' I also have 'softer features and lack of musculature' and describe myself as 'a smaller male, don't have strong beard genes, and have softer facial features.' I have a constant fear of being perceived as an FtM: 'since detransition I definetly have a constant fear of being percieved as a FtM, since my features are softer, I lack a lot of muscle, and have gynecomastia that I bind down.' On mental health: I've described myself as having had 'self esteem issues,' resentment toward masculinity and men, and obsessive, OCD-like thought patterns around gender: 'I used to always obsess about what it would be like if I was a girl, and it was very frequently in these frenzied, manic thought patterns that I would get stuck in.' I've compared gender rumination to OCD — 'It's like OCD, if not a kind of it' — and described early detransition as involving 'really aggressive flip-flops between wether or not I wanted to be transitioning anymore. Sometimes I would, in the same day, change my mind like 10 times and was just in this constant state of panic and anxiety.' I also referenced being 'too autistic to not constantly overshare my half baked hot takes,' though elsewhere I'm skeptical that autism is overdiagnosed. I don't report a formal diagnosis. What moved me toward detransition was not a single event but growing doubt combined with the absence of social pressure to defend the trans identity. I also began reading gender-critical and detransition material and found the research on transition outcomes unpersuasive. I've cited the WPATH Files and the article 'Cohn, J. The Detransition Rate Is Unknown' (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10322769/) as things that shaped my views. I also mentioned psychedelics in passing as a suggestion to someone else ('Also shrooms'), but I don't describe using them myself. On therapy: I've advised others to be 'clear with your therapist about your desire to not transition as some are very encouraging of this,' implying I encountered or am aware of affirming therapists, but I don't describe my own therapy in detail. Current status: I am a detransitioned, gender-critical man. I present male, have become considerably more masculine in presentation than I was before transition, and describe myself as straight. I still have some feminine qualities but say they feel 'more tuned down and true to myself as my child, before it spiraled into what it was.' I don't tell people about my detransition except close friends: 'If you worked with me or had a class with me you would just think I am some guy.' I've been reposted on 4tran4 and called a 'repper.' Regret: I clearly regret transitioning. 'Transition sucked and I wish I didn't do it.' I've said 'my life improved in every way when I detransitioned' and that now, about 2-3 years out, 'I don't even really think about how I used to be trans unless I'm engaging in this community, or see an old picture... It used to bring me pain to remember, but now I'm just thankful I got out when I did.' I do 'kick myself a bit about how long it went on' (referring to backsliding onto HRT in early detransition) but am thankful I stopped when I did. The main ongoing physical regret is gynecomastia, for which I want surgery. I don't describe fertility concerns for myself directly, though I raise fertility loss as an argument against HRT for others. Attitudes toward transition for others: I am explicitly and strongly opposed. 'I am anti trans. I don't believe there is anybody best suited for a medical transition. Transition is an extreme and not medically necessary plastic surgery that everyone can forgo and lead a happy life.' I compare it to voluntary limb amputation for BIID and to race transition. I believe 'everyone is capable of overcoming gender dysphoria without HRT.' I've advocated for detransition publicly on Reddit, argue frequently and at length with people considering transition, and have offered to DM and talk with struggling individuals. I hold a range of other controversial views — critical of homosexuality (while saying I wouldn't vote against gay marriage), skeptical of autism diagnoses, and critical of what I call 'trans ideology' — and I acknowledge these are unpopular even within the detrans community. I am politically diverse in outlook but note that only conservative outlets platform detransitioners.