Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una persona detransizionata, nata maschio, che si è presentata come donna trans per circa 16 anni e ha smesso la TOS circa otto mesi prima di scrivere questi post, pur continuando a presentarmi come donna nella vita quotidiana. Ho 40 anni, sono sposato con un uomo, ho un'attività mia in Germania e passo. La TOS mi ha dato osteoporosi e malattie cardiache, lasciandomi bisogno di cure mediche a vita, e mi pento profondamente della transizione, desiderando di non esserci mai caduto. Ora credo che il sesso non si possa cambiare, che la transizione dovrebbe essere l'ultima risorsa e non la prima, e lo sostengo attivamente su Reddit, precisando di non cercare di fermare le scelte di nessun altro. Nel mio caso non ho descritto pensieri suicidi né autolesionismo.
Storia completa
I was born in Croatia and now live in Germany; English is not my first language, and I also speak Croatian, German, Italian and Spanish. I turned 40 in September 2023, and I had been in transition for about 16 years before I stopped. I presented as a woman, I pass, and I am married to a man I describe as a "cis" man; I also run my own business with all employees being "cis."
I went through medical transition, including cross-sex hormones, and I stopped HRT around eight months before writing these posts. I now describe myself as a detrans person — at one point I wrote "I am a detrans man who was presenting himself as a trans woman for 16 years," and elsewhere "I am detrans mfttm," while also saying I am "still living as a 'woman' but quit hrt." I still present as a woman in daily life even though I have stopped hormones.
The medical side has been serious for me. I developed osteoporosis and heart disease because of HRT, and I now need medical care for the rest of my life as a result of being on cross-sex hormones. I have said plainly that a man's body cannot function under estrogen in a safe way. I also raised fertility concerns, telling others that HRT will make you sterile.
What moved me toward detransition was a long accumulation of experience rather than a single event. Over 16 years I met many trans people and saw things that disturbed me: my best friend had SRS seven years ago and cannot use her neo-vagina for sex and hurts every time she goes to the toilet; I saw people with beards and silicone breasts; I saw young girls without breasts and with big scars on their chests; I saw people in 12- or 15-year heterosexual marriages who wanted SRS and were angry their partners had problems with it. I also saw what I considered absurdities like people referring to pets by "them." I came to feel that once makeup, heels, soft skin, long hair and silicone breasts became everyday, it was no longer special and became a burden — a lifelong fight you cannot win.
I also feel that no one told me hormones would change my personality, my sexuality, my mood or my priorities, and I think medical professionals are far too quick to put people on hormones before trying other solutions. I believe transition should be the last option, not the first, and that a person must be very stable and grounded before transitioning — being destructive or suicidal is definitely not a reason to put someone on hormones. I have been critical of the phrase "born in the wrong body" being said to children, and I think children should instead be told they are perfect and should love their bodies.
I have not described formal therapy as having helped me; my change of view came from my own long experience, from观察 of the trans community, and from reflection. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm in my own case, though I have told others that if someone is suicidal they simply need mental help, not hormones, and I have urged people not to take black-market hormones.
I have been very active in arguing my position on Reddit. I posted a thread titled "No body is borne in wrong body!!!!" criticizing a medical professional for using that phrase, and another post criticizing a trans activist named Blossom. I argue that sex cannot be changed — that a trans woman is a man on estrogen and a trans man is a woman on testosterone — and that neo-vaginas are not vaginas and gynecomastia is not breasts. I accept that people may transition and I do not try to stop anyone, but I want the freedom to express my view without being harassed for it. I have said I do not consider my views transphobic, that having an option does not make me transphobic, and that people have a right to perceive others through their own perspective.
As for my happiness now: I have concluded that transition is not what made me happy. What makes me happy is peace in my soul, my partner, my travels, my career and the people around me. I have come to the conclusion that I was always perfect, that I was not born in the wrong body, and that all the energy, money and time I spent on transition could have gone to other things. I regret the transition — I have written "I wish I never fall down in to the traps" and "get away as fast as you can" — and I feel I lost a great deal to it, though I also say that going back has no point for people already transitioned and that they will need medical care for the rest of their lives. I do not argue that all trans people must detransition, but I believe most of them are not happy.