Tutte le storie

Egg culture a 17 anni, invidia a 19, ancora uomo a 22

Maschio · Desistito/a3,8K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una persona che ha fatto detransition... anzi, in realtà non ho mai fatto la transizione: sono un uomo etero di 22 anni che si è sempre identificato come cis, ma che lotta con l'invidia di genere da quando, a 17 anni, ho avuto ossessioni da DOC sull'essere una donna trans, e poi un'invidia verso le donne apparentemente autentica a partire dai 19. In seguito mi è stato diagnosticato un disturbo dello spettro autistico e attribuisco le mie difficoltà di genere a DOC, ASD, misandria e comunità online che celebrano il trans (compresa l'«egg culture») e che hanno alimentato una spirale ossessiva. Non ho disforia fisica, non credo di essere AGP e non voglio fare la transizione per paura degli effetti permanenti e della detransition, eppure desidero ancora essere nato femmina e non riesco a guardare certi contenuti senza disperarmi. Resto un uomo che vive serenamente al maschile ma è perseguitato da una persistente invidia di genere, e non so se rivolgermi a una terapia. Ho una visione critica ma non del tutto contraria alla transizione: favorevole alle transizioni ben seguite, molto critico verso l'«egg culture» militante, il gatekeeping debole e le comunità che zittiscono gli scettici.

Storia completa

I never identified as anything other than the sex I was born male and I never medically transitioned, but gender-related thoughts have consumed a large part of my life. When I was 17 I developed OCD obsessions about being a trans woman; during that period I became really depressed, started to hate myself, and some part of me even wanted the obsessions to be true just so I didn't have to be me. Eventually therapy and medication got me out of that period and I felt secure in who I was again. The origin of that OCD spiral, as I understand it, was finding myself on a questioning subreddit during the COVID lockdown where someone talked about being non-binary, which created an intrusive thought that spiralled into an OCD obsession. Around the same time I also learned what being transgender was, and I've said that I probably would never have got the idea I could be anything other than a guy if I'd never known what being trans was. Flash forward to when I was 19 (2022) and things had shifted: I wanted to be a guy, I liked my body as it was, I wanted a penis, didn't want a vagina, and didn't want any modification to my body, but I sometimes found myself longing that I wasn't a woman. I'd watch anime or read manga and be overwhelmed with envy of the female characters for being women. I hated being seen as a threat and lumped in with predators and abusers because I'm a man, hated being expected to just take shit and move on because I'm a guy, and hated how often men are denied their humanity. I'm fairly masculine, have always hated makeup and things associated with a feminine gender role, and always felt I got along better with other guys. I speculated that the allure of being someone else might come from my male role models failing me or disappearing from my life, living in a house where shit-talking men was normalised, or seeing being a woman as a means of pressing the restart button on my problems (mental illness, suspected ASD, self-hatred, insecurity in manhood, social awkwardness). I also thought part of it was wanting to fit in and receive positive attention in progressive circles where being trans is celebrated. By mid-2022 I was consumed with envy towards women. I couldn't read or watch certain media with female characters because I found myself identifying with them, and I sometimes felt sorrow at the fact I'd never be like them, to the point it made me want to cry. I saw trans women talking about gender stuff in communities I'm part of and felt jealous that they got to be women while I was just a guy. I felt uncertain about being seen as a father or dad in the future, and it got to the point where I was starting to view myself as less human than women because of my gender. I wrote that it's delusional, that I know I'm never truly going to be female and that at best if I transitioned I'd be a crude imitation of one. I don't have physical dysphoria, I'm comfortable in my body, but I wish I could be a woman. One side of me wants to live as a male, the other female. I said my life would be so much happier if I never knew about being trans. In August 2022 I briefly considered experimenting with a more feminine presentation in private, but seeing people suspect you of being trans for doing anything 'like a girl' made me feel like there was no point trying to leave my box if I'd just be forced into a new one. Something that happened in a community I was in around that time — seeing trans people view GNC people as eggs in denial — made me not even want to bother, and left me feeling utterly alone and like I don't matter. I felt I couldn't talk about my gender problems for fear of being painted a transphobe or told I'm an egg, and that anyone I talked to would be forced to affirm me when that's the opposite of what I want. I've described the causes of my gender struggles as OCD, ASD, misandry, and being part of social groups where being trans is met with praise and put on a pedestal. In a small, left-wing online community I used to be part of, almost one person came out as MtF every month. Egg culture and the vague, near-universal nature of it caused me to doubt myself more than I would have otherwise and sent me further down an obsessive spiral that consumed my life with anxiety and stress over things that are normal. I've said that seeing online content about how 'cis people don't question' made my obsessions so much worse. I've been diagnosed as autistic since my earlier posts. As of my most recent post (December 2025, age 22), I'm a straight male, don't have physical dysphoria as far as I know, and don't believe I'm AGP — the thought of being a woman doesn't turn me on. I still have an intense jealousy of women at the back of my head, to the point I can't consume certain media without feeling despair over being nothing like the women characters. I hate the expectations that come with being male and hate that so many men are pieces of shit and I'm associated with them because of my genes. I feel like a fraud talking to my male relatives who have no clue and would frankly be ashamed of me if they did. I don't want to transition because I'm scared of health consequences and permanent effects if I do detransition, and I don't even hate my penis, but I seriously wish I was born female. If I had the choice I wish I could magically become a biological female and everyone knew me as a woman because it would save me so much humiliation, guilt and sadness. I feel like I'm staring down the barrel of either having this secret envy and desire to be a woman for the rest of my life, or transitioning and fucking up my life by finding out I'm just a mentally ill guy who let the internet influence him into thinking he was trans. I don't know whether I should genuinely go into therapy about this. On transition generally: I believe there are plenty of people who can transition and live a happy life provided they've had adequate counselling beyond instant affirmation, but I think activists are lowering the bar for 'trans' so much that harmless things like crossdressing or playing the opposite sex in video games get treated as signs you're trans. I think medical gatekeeping exists to keep people from harm, that if you don't have dysphoria you have no good reason to mess with your endocrine system, and that there should be a lot of therapy beforehand to rule out other issues and the root of the desire to transition. I've said I have nothing against individual trans people or the LGB community, but I'm cynical toward the TQ 'community' for its it's-my-way-or-the-highway attitude and for silencing critics. I've noted that detransitioners are inconvenient to the narrative and that research doesn't want to touch the subject of detransition. I also posted a plea to someone planning self-harm, telling them it's not too late to get help, and separately urged someone not to hurt themselves.