Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha fatto la detransizione, che ha vissuto per anni come donna trans e che a febbraio 2023, a 32 anni, ha deciso di fare la detransizione e di vivere da uomo, definendo la transizione «il più grande errore della mia vita». Mi pento profondamente soprattutto della mia SRS fallita e ho voluto un intervento per annullarla; ho anche fatto un aumento del seno. Ho vissuto una grave disperazione, isolamento, dipendenza dai videogiochi e ideazione suicidaria — compresa la quasi attuazione di una lettera d'addio — e dopo la transizione non sono mai stato così a pezzi mentalmente come prima. Prendo ancora estrogeni e a un certo punto ho tenuto il mio nome/genere legale, ma alla fine ho concluso che non potrò mai diventare una donna.
Storia completa
I was born male and have always felt, in my own words, "gender queer, even as a little kid," though I never felt cis. I don't feel like a woman either — I've always had a hard time seeing myself as female, even though I wish I had been born that way. I transitioned as an adult and lived as a trans woman for years, but the whole experience ended in detransition.
The worst part of my transition was genital surgery (SRS). From the start I hated the result. I had asked for a specific surgeon — Hannes, the Icelandic doctor known for being very good — but the clinic gave me a new surgeon who had started doing SRS that spring. I've met at least seven different surgeons there. The hospital said they could fix it with a second surgery, but I didn't trust them. I even got my doctor at Anova to agree with me that the result "does not look human." They prescribed me antipsychotics instead of taking my concerns seriously, which I refused to take because I thought they were horrible. I felt butchered and that there was no quality control. I also had breast augmentation; my scars are quite visible because I chose small implants so the breast wouldn't hide the scar, and my surgeon didn't use the armpit approach.
By October 2019, at age 28, I was in deep despair. I posted that I'd never had a boyfriend and never would, that men only wanted me for anonymous hookups, and I asked whether suicide was my only option. I was asking whether there was any hope for a detransitioned, post-op person who still wished to be "a real girl."
In November 2019 I was banned from the mtf subreddit for seeking comfort there after they gave me no support, which made me bitter about the trans community — I felt you had to agree with everything or be "thrown under a bus and shunned."
In June 2020 I told my gender therapist I wanted to break all contact with the gender clinic and stop all treatment. I no longer wanted to transition because of my botched SRS. She insisted I still take hormones, but I didn't want them — I said I never wanted to feel the need for human touch again, because without hormones I don't have that need, and I never wanted to go back on testosterone. I asked whether anyone had detransitioned without hormones after having their gonads removed, which tells me my gonads were removed during surgery.
By February 2021 I had settled into an unusual position: I no longer called myself a trans woman and instead called myself "biological male," but I still wanted to keep taking estrogen, keep my legal gender and name, and live as a very femme "queerqueer" man. The one thing I regretted was the surgery. I hated having a neovagina and asked whether there was a surgery to undo it — to remove what was there and turn what's left into a micropenis. I said the surgery "has been hell from day one" and that I hated myself for thinking it would make me happier, wishing more people had told me how horrible it was.
My mental health deteriorated badly. In February 2021 I described playing Albion Online 99% of the time I was awake, barely eating or sleeping, and said that whenever I stopped playing I just wanted to die. I admitted that the last time I posted a suicide letter I almost actually went out and killed myself, but started playing Albion instead and basically lived inside the game. Outside the game I talked to only one person. I also posted that "I can sense what people are feeling and thinking. I know they want me to kill myself," and that I'd never pass and no one was stupid enough not to clock me.
I struggled with dating and relationships throughout. I asked whether it was even possible to date men as a detransitioned, post-op male. I noted I'd never talked to an FTM in a relationship with a gay man, and that I knew someone who lied about being bi to sleep with an FTM. In April 2021 I wrote that life gets worse after transition and I regretted transitioning, that I can't really go back, that people treat me worse and no one is attracted to me anymore. Sometimes people get interested in me romantically, but as soon as I tell them I'm trans they lose interest, so instead I pretend to be cis and feel like I'm lying and tricking them.
I also gave advice to others: I warned strongly against vocal feminization surgery, saying everyone I'd heard of sounded worse afterwards and that it has the highest regret rate of any surgery — a surgeon talked me out of it about three years earlier — and I recommended voice training instead. I also told someone worried about a short course of a low-dose medication to see a urologist about fertility.
In April 2021 I posted that I wished I could help people not make the same mistake as me, and another post asking how to cope with knowing you'll always be "a ugly beast" for the rest of your life. I also wrote that I wish I was good enough for men.
In February 2023, at age 32, I made the decisive post: "My transition failed, I will never look like a woman so I decide to detrans and just live life as a man instead. Transitioning was the biggest mistake of my life." I said I realized I can't actually become a woman no matter how much I wished I was, that modern medicine isn't good enough, and that I lived a more fulfilling and happy life before I transitioned. I said I was never as mentally unstable or broken as I've been post-transition — that as an adult male right before transitioning I had learned to live a pretty normal life, but transitioning "just broke" me. I acknowledged I suffered traumatic events during transition, one being my best friend dying, and wondered whether those events rather than transition broke me, but I still wanted to try to find a stable life as something else.
I'm not from the USA and don't understand the insurance system. I've been critical of gatekeeping debates from both sides — I defended a woman who waited 10 years before surgery as an adult, while also complaining the subreddit was "infested with terfs." I also asked "how do i sanctify myself?" in early 2023, suggesting some spiritual searching.
Current status: I detransitioned, deciding to live as a man, though I had previously wanted to keep estrogen and a femme identity. I regret the surgery above all, and I regret transitioning overall.