Tutte le storie

Intersex negli anni '70, e la transizione che non ha fatto

Femmina · Detransizionato/a40
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna intersex che ha fatto detransizione: negli anni '70 ho cercato di fare la transizione, ma alla fine ho vissuto la maggior parte della vita come donna androgina, considerando quel periodo un errore che ho quasi commesso. Sono un'adulta in là con gli anni con figli ormai grandi e su r/detrans offro una prospettiva di lungo periodo, scettica sia verso l'entusiasmo per la transizione dei giovani sia verso l'ostilità anti-trans. Credo che l'argomento dello sviluppo cerebrale contro gli ormoni in adolescenza sia scienza spazzatura, e mi oppongo all'idea che chiunque possa semplicemente «decidere di essere trans». Ho risposto a un sondaggio sulla detransizione e l'ho trovato devastante ma non allineato con la mia esperienza, conclusa da tempo. Non ho riferito ideazione suicidaria né autolesionismo.

Storia completa

I was born with an intersex condition — I describe myself as having been "actually IS to begin with" — and I grew up as a normal if androgynous woman. Because of that intersex history, I carried a sense that I could be or should be a male, and so I pursued transition-related things for a while back in the 1970s. I never completed a full transition; I say I "lived most (all?) of my life as a normal if androgynous woman," and that when people like me say we desisted or detransitioned, we really mean we made a mistake, or nearly made one. I'm now an older adult — I have grown kids, and I say I'm "too old and removed" to have first-hand contact with today's adolescent transition scene. I've traveled a lot and lived in vastly different countries and regions over the years; at one point I ended up living across the street from the endodontist who did my first root canal in 1987. I've been on Reddit since at least 2020, mostly engaging in r/detrans as a commenter rather than a poster. I'm skeptical of a lot of the current discourse in both directions. I think the idea that the brain doesn't finish developing until 29 is "junk science" — a trope repeated online with no controlled long-term studies behind it — and I've argued that the real long-term concern is physical development: an adolescent FTM who gets the right endocrine balance early can grow up to look like a normal man with appropriate bone and facial growth, whereas that musculoskeletal development can't be achieved post-adolescence. At the same time, I'm sharply critical of the newer notion that people who aren't actually transsexual can "decide to be trans," calling that "a horrible thing" — you can no more choose to be trans than choose to be a Thalidomide baby. I've complained about "identity" fads, comparing the current wave of people claiming trans identity to the 1970s when "every third person claimed to be bisexual," and I distinguish genuine gender dysphoria from what I see as latter-day, evidently mental rather than physical distress. I also have strong views about the toxicity around the topic. I've described how GC types on Twitter cruelly mock trans people, then gather around anyone who announces themselves as detrans as instant allies, and I've suggested the sensible way to navigate that is "probably by keeping quiet and not advertising oneself as anything in particular." I suspect some of the bullying dynamics online may parallel what ROGD-identified kids experience, though I don't know for sure. On a personal health note, I spent a couple of years suffering ulcers and holes in my duodenum from ibuprofen — I gobbled a lot of Nurofen Plus for severe headaches and got crippling gastritis after any race of 10k or longer — until I figured out the cause myself; my GP never did. I now avoid ibuprofen like the plague. I took a detransition survey at one point and found it "a bit devastating" seeing all the options, but I also noticed it presumed the respondent was still in the eye of the hurricane, when for me these experiences were long over and done with. I find real commonality with some others in the subreddit and find it endlessly intriguing, but I also think most people who say they desisted simply made a mistake and moved on. I don't do organized advocacy, but I do engage in the subreddit, offering a long-view, older-adult perspective and pushing back on what I see as bad science and faddish identity claims from various sides.