Tutte le storie

Sei mesi dopo l'ultima amica trans, la disforia è tornata

Femmina · Desistito/aPrima disforia 12 → Transizione sociale 12 → Desistenza 14710
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un'adolescente che ha fatto detransition/desistenza — autistica, mascolina, nata femmina — e vivo in un paese dell'Europa orientale con un accesso molto limitato. Mi sono identificata come trans dai 12 anni, sono uscita da un gruppo trans circa un anno fa e ho tagliato l'ultimo legame con quelle persone circa 6 mesi fa, dopo di che la mia disforia è sparita — e poi è tornata in parte. Non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi; la mia transizione è stata interamente sociale e 'nella mia testa', e l'ho rifiutata perché voglio essere biologicamente maschio, non un uomo trans. La mia allora migliore amica (un'adulta FTM) ha reagito con ostilità quando ho detto di non essere trans, e un'altra amica ha cercato di riconvertirmi dopo la mia desistenza. Ora cerco di convivere con una disforia ricorrente che 'sembra la morte' quando si riaccende, senza alcun autolesionismo o comportamento suicidario registrato.

Storia completa

I am a teenage girl living in a former Soviet country in eastern Europe, near Russia, far from the US and UK, where transition is heavily gatekept — you must be 18, diagnosed as trans, and it can take up to 2 years, with no self-ID and no informed-consent model. I am autistic and, by my own description, "not really functional in real life." I first heard about trans people in general at age 11, and at age 12 I discovered that transitioning was a thing — that was also when I got into what I now call "the trans cult." A year ago (so around age 14, given I was 15 when my then-best friend reacted badly to my coming out as cis) I got out of that group. When the group went quiet and I filled my life with other things, my dysphoria disappeared completely. I later realized the "dysphoria" had largely come from hanging out with trans people constantly. I cut off my last connection with those people about 6 months before mid-2022 and said I was happy. But then the dysphoria came back — "kinda." I don't even know if it qualifies as dysphoria. I want to be a biological male; being a trans man wouldn't be enough, because I'm too aware of my sex. That's precisely why I won't transition: a trans man body would be worse than my female one. I explicitly reject the usual explanations people offer: I'm not gay, I have no sexual trauma, I wasn't bullied, and I didn't grow up under strict gender roles. I say none of those reasons are true for me. What I describe instead is an obsession with male physiques — "I'm so interested in and obsessed with men (nothing sexual) that I want to be one desperately." I hate being female because of the biology and because of feminists. I describe having painful, heavy periods — "having to bleed every month until I pass out from low hemoglobin." I resent how feminists portray women either as victims who must be protected or as "total crackheads." My desire to be male has nothing to do with gender roles: even if every gender role were burned to the ground, I'd still want to be male. It's about the body. The only reason I can live with a female body is that I can't have a male one, and I'm definitely not going to have a trans man one. I also note my body has too many physical issues for me to ever be perceived as male even with full transition. I describe myself as a masculine girl and I hate the term "GNC" (gender non-conforming) — "I'm a masculine girl and I hate the term 'GNC'." I wish I were a normal girl or boy rather than what I call a "messed up piece of shit," and I clarify I haven't been shamed for being masculine. I know I am female but don't see or count myself as one: when dressed, I see a male; shirtless, I still see male despite having breasts; only fully naked do I see female, because then I see "the main part of my sex." When women's rights are discussed, or when Roe v. Wade was overturned, my reaction is "doesn't affect me, I'm not female." When I imagine myself in third person, I see someone who looks somewhat like me but better and male. Because everyone pushes me toward trans organizations for "it's totally okay to be trans uwu" lectures, which I don't want, I developed a coping mechanism: a male in my head who shows his body whenever the dysphoria triggers. Every time it triggers it feels like death. I desisted socially without changing my appearance at all — I had never changed it when I started identifying as trans; "It was all in my head." I did my social transition with clothing and short hair. My voice is sometimes low, sometimes high, but it doesn't matter because the people who think I'm a boy are mostly strangers; one of my classmates told me my voice gave me away. My native language has no gendered pronouns, so I only use male pronouns online and have no real-life experience of them. I posted a song I translated from my native language in which the "you" is the trans identity — lines about wasted years, carrying all of its stuff out, forgiveness, and seeing it recede in the rear-view mirror's dust cloud. I also shared screenshots of how my then-best friend (ftm, an adult while I was 15 at the time) reacted when I said I'm not trans, which got a lot of attention; I read their attitude as caring about me only as long as I was useful — "They only care about you as long as you're useful to them (identify as trans, support the narrative)." When I desisted, my closest friend at the time tried to convert me back to being trans. I've never received sexual attention, so I don't know what that feels like. I don't believe in God; religion isn't important in my country. I've shared an article about hormone side effects and argued that the concept of "gender" is too broad and implies something called gender exists. I think transition helps those who transition due to genuine gender dysphoria but not those who transition due to social pressure. I have no recorded surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers — my account describes social identification only, and I explicitly say I won't transition. I have not described any self-harm or suicidal behavior, though I say the dysphoria "feels like death" when it triggers. My current status: I identify as a detransitioned/desisted girl, a masculine female, and I'm trying to live with the returning distress.