Tutte le storie

Una fase sociale nel mondo trans, e nessun cambiamento permanente

Femmina · Desistito/a175
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha desistito, mi identifico come non conforme al genere e sono stata coinvolta per poco tempo nel mondo trans come fase sociale, prima che la mia salute mentale migliorasse e potessi vedere che le mie motivazioni erano altri problemi e non una vera disforia di genere. Non sono andata avanti molto sul piano medico e sono felice di non aver preso decisioni permanenti che modificassero il corpo. Ora lotto con il sentirmi isolata e zittita sulle posizioni gender-critical tra amici progressisti, diffidando al tempo stesso degli spazi gender-critical estremi. Sostengo con forza la terapia neutrale, il trattamento prima di tutto dei problemi di salute mentale di fondo come DOC e ansia, e il tirare il freno sui passaggi medici irreversibili in caso di dubbio. Sono attiva nella comunità detrans, contrastando la crudeltà verso chi scrive da una condizione di disforia e il rischio che il subreddit diventi una discarica politica.

Storia completa

I came to gender questions as a desister rather than someone who went far down a medical path — I've described myself as "just a desister, not very far along when I desisted," and I've said repeatedly that I'm glad I didn't make any permanent body-altering decisions when I was younger. Looking back, I got caught up in the trans world partly as a social phase, and partly because when my mental health improved I could see more clearly that I had not been motivated by true gender dysphoria but by other problems. I was grasping for a "diagnosis," a community, and a reason to believe I was persecuted to explain my unhappiness. Hatred of my body was one of the things that led me into "transness," though I don't think I ever had the severe dysphoria or dysmorphia I've seen described by others. I've noted that it takes until your mid-20s to settle into who you are, and I speak from having gone through that process myself. Since desisting I've struggled with holding beliefs I experience as "unspeakable." I know I'm not transphobic, but I see comments I agree with get ripped apart on Twitter and accounts banned, and I hear friends call people TERFs and scum for sharing thoughtful opinions. Because many of my friends still identify as trans or non-binary, I know I have to stay silent or lose them. I often feel alone and confused, and I feel cowardly for not speaking up for what I believe to be true — that some people are getting damaged in this fight. At the same time I'm scared that I'm wrong and constantly question my sanity, because I've always been so progressive and I don't understand how everyone I know could be so wrong about this when they're so sure. Dipping into gender-critical spaces brings its own problems: real right-wing extremists, and people who have lost their humanity and just mock trans people. It's very isolating. I've also dealt with shame that I recognize in others — what I call a common form of "detrans embarrassment" where the embarrassment gets channeled into anger, and I've advised letting that resentment go because you can't control other people. I care a lot about mental health treatment preceding or replacing transition decisions. I've urged people to address OCD first and foremost, to find a therapist and psychiatrist, and I've said plainly that transition will not cure OCD or anxiety — "you will just find new ways to torture yourself" — while treatments like medication and CBT do address those conditions. I've compared obsessive body hatred to a severe eating disorder, where the perception of oneself is distorted and no amount of change will ever be enough, and I've said the problem is in your mind, not your body. I've recommended finding a therapist who is neither affirmation-only nor anti-transition — neutral, with no stake in whether you transition or detransition — as crucial. I'm wary of affirmation-only guidelines, which I believe have made many in the mental health field too trigger-happy with transitioning. I've also warned that affirmations are appealing when you're struggling with self-acceptance, but that transition is often sold as a cure for dysmorphia when the real problem is self-loathing. On irreversible steps I've been blunt: "There is no going back after bottom surgery. If you're not sure now, do not do it!" and more generally, "When in doubt, apply the brakes. You can always do it, but you can never undo it." I've been an active voice in the detrans community itself, pushing back against cruelty toward people who come to these spaces with dysphoria or trauma hoping for understanding. I've argued the subreddit cannot become a dumping ground for political grievances or an unofficial gender-critical sub full of arguments instead of personal care, and I've scolded people for insulting struggling posters rather than offering help. I've also defended a trans woman's dignity, saying she is in pain and that it's possible to transition and still acknowledge reality without being cruel. I've gently challenged posts I felt didn't belong, asking how they relate to detransition, which earned me downvotes. On practical matters I've suggested that people stop hormones if they already know hormones won't address their main issues; that pronoun stress can be relieved by privately using different pronouns for yourself and others to strip away the baggage; that detrans people should consider telling teammates or friends to lift the burden of shame; and that it's never too late to experiment with femininity or non-conformity. I've encouraged gender non-conforming cis people as much-needed representation, arguing that internalized misogyny combined with a lack of models beyond things like Legally Blonde is a recipe for dysphoria and dysmorphia in young girls. I've also expressed support for intersex people whose experiences have been "globbed in" with the transgender community in a way that doesn't make sense, and told someone they don't owe anyone silence. I've been supportive of people pausing medical transition at 18 or 19, telling them they're doing the right thing, that things open up after high school, and that if discomfort persists they can still transition later with more certainty. I've also warned that transitioning with HRT and surgeries will not stop you from comparing yourself to others and feeling inadequate. When someone described being on testosterone and unsure, I advised separating your own feelings from your family's, taking a break from T while sorting it out, and finding a therapist who prioritizes you. I've also counseled someone in acute despair that they are not destroyed, that their body is not destroyed, and that taking their own life would destroy them and their mother — urging them to give themselves time. Current status: I identify as a desisted, gender non-conforming woman. I am female by birth. I have not undergone hormones or surgeries as far as my posts indicate.