Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna desistita, vicina al mondo detrans — una donna cis non conforme al genere che si identificava come maschiaccio e ha provato disforia di genere dai 13 anni per tutto il liceo senza mai fare la transizione medica. Attribuisco quei sentimenti alla pubertà, alla sessualizzazione, al trauma, alla misoginia e al non rientrare negli stereotipi femminili, e lotto ancora con misoginia interiorizzata e dismorfia corporea riguardo al seno. Ho la PCOS e una storia di psicosi e ansia, e lavoro in ambito medico. Ora sostengo le persone detrans, mi oppongo alla transizione medica e ai bloccanti della pubertà per i minori e credo che la maggior parte delle identità trans sia circostanziale. Resto vicina a mia sorella di 15 anni, che temo stia seguendo la stessa strada.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up as a tomboy — from a young age I altered my appearance to look like a boy because I did not want to be lumped in with "feminine ditzy girls"; I wanted to be taken seriously, treated like "one of the boys," and not seen as an object or someone without a brain. I now understand that period as gender dysphoria that started around age 13 and continued through high school, though back then I just gave it the name "tomboy."
What drove that feeling, in my own reckoning, was a mix of puberty, sexualisation, and misogyny. Once my breasts started coming in I wanted them gone because boys started sexualising me and avoiding me. Once I started bleeding I felt remorse and that it was completely unfair, like I was being robbed of something. When body hair came in, not shaving it off got me called gross — more shame. As adolescence went on, boys treated me like I wasn't smart because I was a girl; if I said I liked video games or Weezer I was called a liar, and my ideas were shut down. Being a girl became a competition I couldn't win against the ultra-feminine popular girls. I also said "some other things happened I don't feel like mentioning," after which I started hating women and held sexist, misogynistic views of them. I just wanted to be one of the boys again — an equal, someone of value — and I couldn't be of value if I was even slightly feminine, so I turned my back on femininity. I grew out of the dysmorphia as a teen and say I "grew out of it in high school."
I also had a psychological break when I was 22, which others in the thread brought up against me; I don't describe it further, but I referenced it defensively twice. I have PCOS, which has given me problems including my period disappearing for months (mine once stopped for 4 months) and persistent body odor I describe as "onions+skunk," which diet helps with. I experience body dysmorphia related to my breasts — I say I'd get a breast reduction but believe losing weight would shrink them, so surgery isn't on the table for me; my grandmother had enormous breasts that caused back issues and school torment. I also deal with intrusive anxiety thoughts, including existential ones like "i don't exist, nothing is real, i am actually dead rn," which I recognize as anxiety-based and try not to humor. I mention having experienced psychosis at some point, saying weekly therapy with someone helped stabilize me.
I never medically transitioned. My path has been one of desisting from a tomboy/GNC identification rather than detransitioning from medical intervention. I now describe myself as "a gnc cis female" who doesn't care about labels anymore, saying "the parts don't make the person, your personality does" and that I distance myself from groups obsessed with labels because it brings me peace. I still say I have internalized misogyny "to this day" and that I'm "still trying to get over" the masculine mindset and embrace feminine qualities — it isn't an easy task.
I came to the detrans community as a lurker, reading stories and learning, and I "vehemently advocate" for detrans people on "detransphobe" posts. I asked whether you need dysphoria or dysmorphia to be trans or detrans, since pro-trans sites say not all trans people feel those feelings, which doesn't make sense to me — to say "I'm supposed to be x gender" I'd think you need one or the other. I believe transitioning is a choice even though dysphoria itself isn't choosable, and I'd "like to think that most if not all trans identities are purely circumstantial." I find "trans without dysphoria" to sound like larping, cross-dressing, or androgyny, and think "trans has become too generic of a term for way too many complex ways to be."
On kids: I'm a supporter of self-expression and social transition for exploration, but I can't support medical transition, hormones, or surgeries for minors because they still have growing to do. I don't think parents who support their kids should be labeled abusive or have kids taken away, but I agree with not allowing kids surgeries or puberty blockers because "that stuff is permanent." As someone in the medical field, I state flatly that "puberty blockers are not reversible" and tell people to stop posting misinformation. I was glad when a state restricted youth medical transition and criticized Facebook ads selling HRT pills online "without proper roadblocks for impressionable kids."
My little sister got "sucked into" identifying as trans — she was 15 at the time, has no self-esteem or stable identity because of an upbringing with trauma and no father, and had latched onto identity after identity over the years, trans being the latest. My biggest fear was her damaging a body she already had a crippling hatred of. I'm also close to a partner — I mention my "boy" being 5'4" and enjoying being the big spoon.
On regret: I don't frame my own story in terms of medical regret since I didn't transition medically, but I feel deep sadness and frustration for people who detransition and "have to pick up the pieces and live with what has been done." I told someone not to waste a year but to see it as "learning who you really are." I find black-and-white thinking in comment sections infuriating and believe both genders have a hard time, noting that people say "Being A sucks, B clearly has an easier time, so I'm going to become B" without realizing both have struggles.