Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che ha desistito, non ha mai fatto una transizione né sociale né medica e ora si identifica come donna. La non conformità di genere dell'infanzia, un disturbo del linguaggio, l'EDS e l'odio per il seno in sviluppo mi hanno portata a identificarmi con i maschi, ma il mio desiderio di essere madre da sempre e la paura di perdere la fertilità mi hanno impedito di andare oltre. Informarmi sulla transizione mi ha lasciato domande senza risposta, e a 18 anni mi sono tagliata i capelli e ho riconosciuto che avevo voluto essere un ragazzo, non che lo fossi. Ho imparato ad accettare il mio corpo, seno compreso, e ora credo che il fatto di essere una ragazza non significhi essere "solo" una ragazza. Ora ho opinioni critiche sulla transizione, sostenendo che sia intrinsecamente dannosa, e sostengo gli altri nella comunità.
Storia completa
I am female, and I never transitioned socially or physically — I have always been a girl. My story starts early: at age 3 in preschool I loved wearing dresses, mostly pink, light purple, and light blue, and I always did a "spin test" before my mother would buy one. I ran with the boys and wrestled them, and parents would tell my mother things like "she's just like a boy" and "maybe she was meant to be a boy," though they were joking. I also had a speech disorder — no one could understand me until I was nine, and by 12 no one would have guessed I'd ever had trouble speaking. I've always been confident and assertive; I'd repeat myself until people understood me.
At age 5 I went to a superhero-themed birthday party as Princess Pea from Super Why, the only girl there, hunting everyone with a Nerf gun. I wonder sometimes whether my speech disorder kept me from playing with girls, but I'm not sure that's the reason. At age 7 I refused dresses and cut my hair as short as my mother allowed. At age 8 I told my aunt I was "more of a tomboy," and my aunt and extended family said "what, no you're not a tomboy. You're a beautiful young girl." That hurt, and imagining myself as a beautiful girl, I knew it should make me happy but didn't know how to feel about it.
One thing I've been sure of my whole life: I want to be a mother. As a child I'd imagine being a boy, but the only reason I wasn't totally happy with the idea was that I'd be unable to breastfeed my baby. At age 9 I wore dresses again because I loved the twirling. At age 10 I was drawing chalk with a group of boys; when one boy's sister screamed about chalk on her dress, I rubbed chalk into my own dress to show her it was fine, then mocked her with the other boys — we laughed and I felt accepted, but deep down I knew I shouldn't have made fun of her and I still wish I hadn't. I begged my parents for karate but they refused because I have a joint disorder, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), which makes injury much more likely. I also lost most wrestling matches but had fun anyway.
At age 11 my breasts started growing and the boys treated me differently — they stopped pushing me on my chest, one apologized frantically after brushing against me, and I could tell they let me win sometimes. A kid once asked if we were girlfriend and boyfriend while we were wrestling; we both got up embarrassed and I felt too awkward to wrestle anyone after that. That was also when I first learned what transgender meant — I was told "even if someone looks like a girl, they could be a boy," which confused me.
At age 12 I started hating my breasts; nothing fit, I had to shop in the women's aisle, and I grew my hair out to hide my chest. A boy pushed me off the playground and said I didn't fit in; I told myself he was a jerk, but afterward my fascination with boy things grew. I asked my mother what my name would be if I were a boy — she said Nicholas — and I'd stuff my hair under my hoodie in the bathroom to imagine being Nicholas. I looked up "can a man give birth," saw a picture of a pregnant man, and decided it was photoshopped after remembering my mother's warning about the internet.
At age 13 I stopped playing with boys or anyone, read a lot, and kept my hair long to hide my chest. Girls told me my parents were unfair not to let me do karate or football and that I'd be allowed if I were a boy (they were wrong — my parents were just worried about my EDS). That was also when I learned what transgender actually was, and it made no sense to me: "How can someone feel like a girl? I don't feel like a girl, I don't feel like a boy." I pretended to be a boy on Roblox and Minecraft, but when real-life friends asked to play, I went back to being me.
At age 14 I realized I was denying myself anything "girly" for no reason, so I started wearing dresses again, let myself enjoy pink and cute things, and braided my hair — though I still wasn't comfortable with my chest and wanted it to go away. A doctor told me I'd officially stopped growing (early period meant I was done) and I was upset to be stuck at 5'6" instead of the 5'10" I'd been promised, though I'm happy with my height now. At age 15 I researched transgender topics but ended up with more questions — everything seemed linked to a personality trait or fashion choice.
At age 16 a Snapchat filter showed me what I'd look like as a boy, and seeing myself as a boy made me happy and excited. When I asked trans people questions, every answer was to ask myself what being a girl means to me. I asked why people transition if both genders can do anything, and was told it's for dysphoria; I asked what dysphoria is and why changing the body fixes the mind, and never got an answer. At 17 my hair was so long I could sit on it, and I asked my grandmother to cut it (still longer than my breasts). At 18 — two weeks before I wrote my first post on September 26, 2024 — I chopped off eight inches so it ends above my breasts.
Looking back, I think I really wanted to be a boy, and I'm worried that if someone had told 12-year-old me I didn't have to be a girl, I would have believed them. If I'd been told I could be a man and still have children, I think I would have wanted to do it. If I didn't want children, I believe I might have truly wanted to be a boy. I asked the community whether this makes me a desisted female.
I've thought a lot about whether body dysphoria is real or just a side effect of body dysmorphia. I distinguish dysmorphia (seeing a feature as horribly ugly when it isn't noticeable — like an anorexic seeing fat) from dysphoria (just hating a part). I used to hate my breasts, never wore anything tight, and covered them with my hair, but I eventually learned they aren't a bad thing — they're just part of me — and I've grown to accept them and no longer feel insecure about them. I've said that what helped me was understanding that just because I'm a girl doesn't mean I am "just" a girl, and I consider myself luckier than others because my dysphoria was more manageable.
I've been supportive of others in the community: I've told someone there's nothing wrong with being a feminine man and that acting emotionally doesn't mean you have to transition; I've reassured a woman that she's beautiful and not masculine-looking; I've encouraged someone in despair that there's a future and hope, praying for them; and I've given practical advice about hairstyles now that someone has their hair back. I've also engaged in theological debate, arguing that moving between genders is not something a higher consciousness should do, and defending a Catholic (rather than pagan/syncretist) view that God transcends gender entirely rather than switching it — while agreeing with my interlocutor that seeking transition is inherently harmful to the seeker. I never took hormones or had any surgeries, and I have no regrets about medical interventions because I never had any.