Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born male, and I came out as MtF in early 2021 at age 23, a few months before my first post in April 2021. Coming out felt liberating at first — I was happy to dress and present as a woman, and I was initially desperate to get on hormones. I had dysphoria that I said had plagued me since childhood, and I told myself it could finally be relieved.
But within months I was in a worse way than before coming out. I hated my body, hated my life, wanted to disappear, felt I belonged nowhere, was drinking heavily and feeling alone. I have a really traumatic childhood that included physical and sexual abuse, and I was diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type. I suspected BPD at one point as well. I felt my dysphoria was real but that a lot of it was unpacked trauma and a desire for escapism, and I even wondered whether delusional thinking played a part. Seeing a male body and face in the mirror made me angry and foolish-feeling, and I hated my low bass voice. I also felt that even with hormones and FFS I would still be trans, and that when I dated I would still be seen as AMAB rather than as a woman.
By April 2021 I was already concluding that I could be effeminate and gender non-conforming as a male, wear women's clothing and makeup without medical transition, and keep my female-sounding name. I said having dysphoria didn't mean I had to medically transition or live as a transgender person. I was on a high dose of a new atypical antipsychotic, which helped, and I was working with a therapist.
In June 2021 I posted that I was ready to socially de-transition and live as my birth sex, male. Coming out had gone downhill fast: I found elements of the trans community deeply toxic, cliquey, lacking in empathy and solipsistic, with people overly consumed by appearance, transition, and romantic and sexual lives. I was treated poorly by other trans people and felt lonelier and angrier than ever. After much meditation I realized I had tried to transition to assuage deep trauma triggered by various forms of childhood abuse, that I also struggled with body dysmorphia, and that I hadn't been getting enough treatment for my schizoaffective disorder — all of which pushed me toward gender transition instead of mental health services. I still had dysphoria ranging from mild to intense and asked for coping suggestions.
In October 2021 I wrote that I had gone to therapy to affirm my gender identity and it did the reverse: I ended up realizing a lot of my dysphoria came from psychological, physical, sexual, financial and verbal abuse. I still experience some dysphoria looking at my body and hearing my bass-baritone voice in recordings, but transition wasn't helping me — I wanted to be a cis woman, and transition actually amped up my dysphoria because I realized I would never be a cis woman, never relate to a period, carrying a child, or cis-female socialization, childhood or culture. I said I was navigating living as a male after very publicly coming out and living as a trans woman, and that I had had to reckon with my misogyny and sexist/anti-women ideas. I worked on that through self-reflection, acknowledging bias, talking to women in my life, and recognizing that abuse I experienced from women in early life had made me bitter at women — while remembering women as individuals aren't responsible for what was done to me.
In November 2021 I said I came out as a trans woman a year ago, suffered deep worry and shame afterwards, felt worse dysphoria than ever because I knew my body would never look like a cis woman's, and felt deeply isolated from my body, society and people. I desisted officially a few weeks/months earlier and needed to come out again to family. Detransitioning forced me to reckon with myself deeply: I hated being a man, grew up around women and wanted to emulate them, the few men in my childhood were abusive and misogynistic, I was disgusted with manhood, dissociated from my maleness because of abuse, experienced bullying, and I'm bisexual and not super masculine.
In February 2022, around my 24th birthday, I learned that while I identified as trans, all of my "supportive" family talked shit about me behind my back — calling me by my birth name, using he/him, mocking me, making clear they were only humpering my "eccentricity," one even calling me basically a deviant while smiling to my face. I was relieved I'd made the right decision to desist, tired of my self-esteem depending on others entertaining my feelings, tired of hoping surgery would make me a woman, tired of saying I'm a woman while having broad shoulders, five o'clock shadow, a penis and a bass-baritone voice. I was also hurt and bitter about the fakeness. I wrote that desistance is the best decision I've ever made — owning my reality, embracing that I am a man, getting away from toxic people and ideologies that took years from me. I had regretted desisting initially but was now happy. It was my 24th birthday and my first birthday genuinely happy to be alive since I was six.
Later in 2022 I said I was treated like an eccentric crossdresser when I transitioned socially, never treated like a woman, that it was a lonesome, tiring existence full of performance, and that I'd prefer to live as my birth sex partly because I didn't want to lose sexual function and because romantic relationships were even harder while trans. In July 2022 I said I'd just gotten off the phone with a trans friend I couldn't tell I'd given up on living as a woman; I wished I'd never come out to family and friends and ruined so many relationships; I never passed — short but broad with wide shoulders and a deep voice, a masculine-looking man. I also said I'd watched porn since age 9 and only recently stopped at 24, and that it had been partially responsible for influencing my desire to transition. A large part of my dysphoria was internalized biphobia — I hated being attracted to other males and thought being a trans woman would make it easier to accept my androphilic tendencies; it didn't.
In September 2022 I described my appearance: as a kid I enjoyed being gender non-conforming and read as feminine; puberty was a shock, my androgynous features became hard and objectively male, and I cried when facial hair started to grow. I have a large boxy jaw, broad shoulders, and I'm 5'7" (170cm), read as male because of gait and posturing. I've had a decent chunk of people express sexual or romantic attraction to me. I've had to learn to appreciate my healthy male body; FFS probably wouldn't make much difference and I'm better off living as my birth sex.
In January 2023 I said I didn't get bottom surgery and only did hormones for a bit, realized early on I would never pass, and that after coming out many people cheered me on but stopped interacting with me on a deep level, leaving me with very few real friends and family.
On attitudes: I've been critical of modern trans identity politics, saying mental health that depends on being perceived as the identified sex is unhealthy, and that much current discourse is basically humouring trans folks, which I think is cruel and will have bad effects. I've suggested cultural categories like historical East African and other non-Western roles for feminine males and masculine females as a more fluid alternative, and I've endorsed Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's statement that "trans women are trans women." I've considered writing a book, blogs, or video essays. I've offered to talk to others in my inbox and PMs.