Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I have been writing on the detrans board about my own transition and detransition, and about the broader politics around gender in the West. I was born male, and I transitioned and lived as a woman for a period before deciding to come back. The clearest marker of that reversal for me was surgery: I had my breast tissue removed at a surgical clinic, and I described it as "a huge relief, to be able to go to the beach and be shirtless and not insecure. Summers were a nightmare before I had the surgery." That tells me I had developed breast tissue on hormones and lived with the insecurity of it for some time.
On the medical side I have been open with others about what testosterone withdrawal does to a male body. I told another detransitioner that the testicles shrink because testosterone directly affects their size, but that "in most cases they will return to their original size (mine did)." I also reassured them that penile tissue does not permanently change: "As I said, my penis size is the same, and testicles returned to the same size as well." I explained that the perceived loss of girth was really about infrequent full erections and reduced blood flow, and that things were "still getting back online so to speak." So my own recovery of sexual function was gradual but, as far as I described it, complete.
Sexuality and porn have been a real theme in my detransition. When someone described a new sexual drive returning, I said "I experienced the same thing. I would recommend directing your new sexual drive towards healthy sexual pursuits. I got into porn during my detransition and developed unhealthy habits." I have also been quick to read other people's transition wishes as sexual rather than identitarian: when one person reported dreaming they were a woman and ejaculating, I said "That sounds like this obsession of yours is very much sexual in nature. Rather than some kind of deep sense of identity," and I added that quitting porn for a couple of weeks does not remove its influence, especially if someone had been watching "transsexual porn or sissy/emasculation porn."
I have a fairly dark view of what transition actually delivers. I told someone who was keeping the fantasy of transition alive that "Being trans isn't cool or fun. Its nothing to want. Just lowers your life TBH," and that it is easier to give up once you have actually spent years pursuing it and felt "the depression and discomfort it brings." I also said "Most people can't and don't 'know' if they are trans or not. You either do it or you don't," and that "Very few happy trans people over the long term." I framed black-and-white thinking — "If I'm this I should do this" — as typical of how people reason about identity.
I think weak self-identity is a major driver into transition. I wrote that people may be "using it all as a crutch for generally having a weak self identity," and that "people with weak identities get sucked into trans stuff more easily. This contradicts the narrative that the average trans person is someone who has a very strong identity that just happens to be of the opposite gender/sex. In reality most trans people have weak identities, and are stumbling through life half-blind." I also pushed back on the idea that the body signals whether HRT is right: "your body does not tell you whether HRT is right or wrong." And I challenged the framing that being short and light (5'6", 130 lbs) makes someone a candidate for transition: "Lots of men are 5'6" and 130 lbs... you are already framing this all as some kind of game where if you aren't the 'ideal' male you should be tranz. That is a toxic perspective."
I have also been candid about the physical risks of testosterone for female-bodied people. I said "the main worry would be the voice," noting that I had met females whose voices changed so much on testosterone that "they no longer sound anything like the average woman/female," and I was not sure how that is fixed. At the same time I tried to reassure a female-identifying person that she looked like a normal woman and that she was "a product of their decidedly female genetics."
On the wider culture-war side, I see the current moment as a product of polarization in the English-speaking West. I argued that the left runs so hard against formerly dominant groups that its characterizations of "oppressed" groups become "ungainly and unbalanced," failing to recognize the cultural power those groups now hold, "still thinking we live in an American society of 1950." I extended this to LGBT politics, racial politics, and class politics, and I claimed there is "already backlash happening against LGBT in other countries... due to the gross excess of LGBT politics in America and the UK," so that by fighting so hard at home, "LGBT people have doomed non-western LGBTs to levels of scrutiny and fear and oppression." I also argued that American Democrats are far to the left of every other Western nation except Sweden and the UK, that claims to the contrary are "just a redditism," and that leftist Americans are "extremely leftist" and very rich by global standards. I was dismissive of pride flags as "Tribalism," critical of shows like Euphoria as "sex obsessed garbage" in an already pornified society, and skeptical of transhumanism as a path to social progress. I also told someone that a problem they were attributing to gender "sounds like your problem is more with anxiety, rather than gender."
As of these exchanges in early 2022, I am living as a detransitioned male, comfortable being shirtless again after chest surgery, with sexual function and testicle size recovered, but with a lingering habit of pornography use that I flagged as unhealthy. I am critical of transition as a solution for most people and read a lot of transition desire as rooted in weak identity, anxiety, or sexual fantasy rather than in a stable cross-gender identity.