Tutte le storie

Transizione a 15 anni, e la frase che non è colpa di nessuno

Femmina · Detransizionato/a139
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition, nata femmina, che si è identificata come trans ed è stata medicalmente transitata dai medici da bambina a 15 anni, con cambiamenti irreversibili al corpo, alla fertilità e alle capacità sessuali. Ora sono fortemente gender-critical e arrabbiata con il sistema medico per aver agito su una quindicenne, dicendo agli altri di non incolparsi perché 'Nessuno sa che cazzo sta succedendo quando ha 15 anni.' Vedo il disagio corporeo femminile come un prodotto della cultura e dello sguardo maschile più che una condizione medica, e rifiuto l'idea che sentimenti o autodichiarazione costituiscano una prova su sesso e genere. Mi confronto in modo schietto e critico sia con le persone che si identificano come trans sia con l'ideologia di genere, anche sugli spazi separati per sesso. Non descrivo la mia salute mentale attuale, le relazioni o l'identità oltre all'essere una donna che ha fatto detransition.

Storia completa

I came to these conversations as a detransitioned woman who is firmly critical of gender ideology and of the medical pathway I went through as a minor. I was born female, and I identified as trans and lived as a man for a period; I have spoken about doctors helping me as a child to irrevocably alter my body, fertility, and sexual capabilities, and about being 15 at the time those decisions were made. I told another person that they 'don't have a disease or a condition' but rather the normal insecurity, dislike and shame about genitals that 'men bestow upon us from a young age,' and that 'there's nothing wrong WITH YOU. Or your body. There's something wrong with a culture obsessed with pleasing the male gaze.' I framed my own experience of female bodily discomfort as a product of culture and the male gaze rather than a medical problem. I am blunt and confrontational in how I engage. In one exchange I told someone outright, 'You have a fetish,' arguing that stereotypically gendered behaviours don't indicate being 'born in the wrong body' and that they were 'terribly misogynistic.' I have also pushed back on claims about gender identity being self-evident, mocking the idea that simply 'feeling' or 'saying' something is true counts as evidence, and I told a woman who listed traits like changing her own oil, an interest in how things work, a STEM/engineering mindset and low sociability that 'You think you want to be a woman but you don't even know what a woman is.' I treat these traits as sex-based rather than identity-based. On the medical side, my central grievance is that doctors were 'complicit in helping you as a _child_ to irrevocably alter your body, fertility, and sexual capabilities.' I drew the comparison that you can't legally get a tattoo at that age, yet they 'voluntarily removed your healthy genitals.' I told the person involved that they have a right to be furious but shouldn't be angry at themselves, because 'Nobody knows what the fuck is going on when they're 15.' I don't describe my own surgical details beyond that reference to genital alteration and loss of fertility and sexual capability in childhood. I hold strongly gender-critical views about sex-based spaces and about trans people generally. I have said I 'hate when men pretend to be women online. Or in my bathrooms and on my sports teams,' and I responded approvingly to someone calling out 'terfs pretend[ing] to be trans online.' I treat trans women as men and trans identity as something that can be performed or faked. I don't describe my current mental health, relationships, career, or whether I've had therapy; the record is mostly my commentary to others, through which I articulate my own detransitioned perspective and my anger at the medical system and at gender ideology.