Tutte le storie

Uno studio sul sesso del cervello e un decennio di ormoni

Femmina · Detransizionato/a1,3K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto la transizione sociale e medica da giovane, ho passato anni con ormoni cross-sex e ho fatto degli interventi, e oggi mi identifico come donna e abolizionista del genere. Leggere la letteratura primaria sul sesso del cervello (in particolare lo studio di Kurth et al. del 2022, che mostra un'ampia sovrapposizione tra uomini cis, donne trans e donne cis) e imbattermi in dichiarazioni apertamente misogine di importanti figure trans mi ha convinta che l'ideologia che avevo interiorizzato fosse patriarcale e non liberatoria. La mia disforia si è in gran parte attenuata con la maturità e il tempo lontano dagli ormoni; non ho figli e ho dubbi irrisolti sulla fertilità. Sostengo il diritto degli adulti di fare ciò che vogliono del proprio corpo, ma sono critica verso l'impostazione delle cure di affermazione di genere e verso gli sforzi per eliminare il sesso biologico come motivo legale di discriminazione. Sostengo ampiamente queste posizioni online.

Storia completa

I have never written out my own transition story publicly, and I'm not sure I ever will in full, but the way I argue about gender online is inseparable from what I went through, so I want to lay it out plainly. I was born female. I don't have a neat, single origin story for my dysphoria. What I can say is that from early adolescence I felt a strong aversion to being read as female, and that this intensified in a culture — online and in the clinic — that kept offering me a single explanation: that I must have a male brain in a female body. I came out while still young, socially transitioned first, and then moved onto hormones. I was on cross-sex hormones for a period of years; I don't want to overstate precision here, but it was long enough that the changes it made to my body are permanent. I have had surgeries as part of medical transition. I do not have children and I have concerns about my fertility that I don't think will resolve. What actually moved me toward detransition was not one dramatic event but a slow accumulation of doubt. I started reading the primary literature rather than the headlines — the brain-sex studies in particular. I remember sitting with the 2022 Kurth et al. paper, *Brain Sex in Transgender Women Is Shifted towards Gender Identity*, and realizing that the finding was being sold as far stronger than it was: if a cis female brain scores 0 and a cis male brain scores 1, a trans woman's brain scored about 0.75 on average, with enormous overlap between all three groups. The title pointed in the direction the authors wanted; the data showed that brains are a sliding scale with no clean cutoff. That realization cracked something open. I had been told there was a hidden, scientific truth that would confirm me. There wasn't one. Alongside that, I began to notice how much of the discourse I had internalized was openly misogynistic. I read Andrea Long Chu writing that femaleness is "an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes," achieved through "techniques for scooping out intelligence," and that this won a Pulitzer Prize. I read Hunter Schafer describing "an attraction to misogyny" and "not feeling femme enough without being the victim of rape." I saw influencers joke about "bimbo pills" — meaning estrogen — and about being irrational and bad at math as the reason one is a woman. I had never once seen a trans man say he was a man because he was violent, unempathetic, or rapey. Being a man was described in terms of rationality, dominance, breadwinning. Being a woman was described in terms of submission and stupidity. Once I saw that asymmetry I could not unsee it. I had been handed a definition of womanhood that a patriarch would have written. I also had to confront the fact that I had been oppressed not because of some inner identity but since childhood because of how my body looked at birth — and that this is a shared, material condition of biological females, not an opt-in/opt-out club. Girls in some parts of the world still cannot go to school because they are female. AFABs in Switzerland could not vote until the 1970s. That is not the same as choosing a gender role because you find yourself submissive. Detransition for me was mostly a private reckoning: time off hormones, a lot of reading, and the slow work of reconciling myself to the body I actually have. I did not find a therapist who helped; the clinical framework I had been inside was part of the problem. What helped was argument, evidence, and the growing realization that there is no "correct" brain-body combination to be found. I am a gender abolitionist in many respects: I don't think biological sex should limit which social roles we perform, and I view gender-affirming care as plastic surgery — something I believe adults have the right to choose for their own bodies, while opposing the normalization of the sexist ideas attached to it. I am not trans anymore. I identify as a detransitioned woman. I do not experience the dysphoria I once did; I think maturity and the removal of the ideological frame both contributed. I am not opposed to other people's bodily autonomy, and I don't campaign to take that away, but I am sharply critical of the movement's gender-role conservatism, its hostility to recognizing biological sex as a protected characteristic in law, and its willingness to define womanhood through negative stereotypes. I spend a great deal of time arguing these points online, and I do it because I once believed the other side and know exactly how it is sold.