Tutte le storie

Un maschiaccio che non ha mai fatto la transizione, e non se n'è mai pentita

Femmina · Desistito/a1,8K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna cis, nata femmina, che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma è arrivata alla comunità r/detrans come commentatrice più anziana e critica del genere. Ero un maschiaccio che detestava il suo seno grande e che in seguito ha fatto una riduzione del seno senza rimpianti, e devo alla psicoterapia e alla DBT l'aiuto nell'attraversare un periodo di depressione profonda. Ora sostengo con passione che la transizione sia un meccanismo di coping disadattivo e una forma di terapia di conversione, e mi batto per una vera terapia, per aspettare la piena maturazione del cervello e per stare lontani dai media trans. Ho una famiglia unita, con una sorella lesbica e figli che cresco con regole ferme. Non ho rimpianti per la transizione in sé dato che non l'ho mai fatta, e la mia salute mentale al momento è buona.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up in Appalachia as a coal miner's daughter, in a close-knit family with regular gatherings spanning five generations of women — my daughter, myself, my mom, grandmother, and great-grandmother — plus three sisters. I was a huge tomboy as a kid: I rode my own dirt bikes, did physical-labor chores like mowing lawns, climbed trees constantly, played sports, and volunteered at the local animal shelter. I wore boys' t-shirts, which I now understand was because I was trying to hide my large breasts, which I loathed. I never interpreted that dislike as evidence I was a boy — I understood myself as a girl who hated her large breasts and the way boys made her feel about them. I was a sad and lonely kid in high school with confidence issues and a struggle to figure out where I fit into the world. I was impulsive as a teen — I got caught shoplifting, drank and drove at 17, and my dad took my driver's license away for an entire year, which I now believe probably saved my life. I was very close with my parents as a kid and remain close with them now. I later became a parent myself, raising a teen and other children, and I describe myself as almost 50 (in May 2020) and elsewhere as in my 50s. I have never transitioned and I am not trans or detrans — I have said explicitly, "I am not trans/detrans, but I have made other life mistakes that I can't take back." I did, however, have a breast reduction at some point, and I have no regrets about it. I contrast that with what I call voluntary double mastectomy, which I view as far more drastic and indicative of mental instability. I went through a period of deep depression in my life. During that time someone told me about "laws of attraction" — the idea that thinking positively attracts positive people, experiences, and outcomes — which helped me. I also credit talk therapy with saving my life, and I specifically recommend DBT therapy to others, saying I have found it "very helpful in moving forward after trauma." I came to the r/detrans community as an older cis woman who identifies strongly with gender-critical views. I was drawn to the sub because I feel a deep sadness for young women today who think transitioning will fix their hurt. I have described myself as a cis woman who is "somewhere in between" butch and super feminine, and I say there is no wrong way to be female. I wear jeans, Target t-shirts from the plus size section, and flip flops every day; I don't wear dresses, heels, makeup, or painted nails. I enjoy kayaking, work hard, take care of my family, and help in my community. My sister is a lesbian with short hair who drives a Harley Davidson motorcycle and works as a welder. I admire her for busting through toxic stereotypes. I have a 12-year-old son whose voice I used as a reference point for what an in-between adolescent voice sounds like. I have a relative who was a pharmaceutical sales rep and told me doctors get kickbacks for prescribing certain drugs. I hold very strong views about transition. I believe transgenderism is a maladaptive coping mechanism for depression, anxiety, and emotional trauma — comparable to drug addiction, alcoholism, cutting, anorexia, and hoarding — and that it is "100% a coping mechanism." I also argue transgenderism is the new conversion therapy, designed to eradicate homosexuality. I embrace the label "terf," defining it as a critical thinker free from groupthink. I support excluding biological men from women's sports, bathrooms, locker rooms, prisons, domestic violence shelters, rape crisis centers, and all female-only spaces, and from being lesbians. I advocate strongly for real talk therapy (not gender therapy), for waiting until age 25-30 before any life-altering decision, and for staying away from trans sites and media. I am critical of trans YouTubers as a for-profit industry, of the affirmation-only therapy model, and of the medical establishment's financial incentives. I have encouraged detransitioners to share their stories, saying "an army of detrans experiences is hard to ignore," and I have celebrated people who detransition, telling them they look happier and more authentic. I am a parent who spot-checks my kids' phones, bedrooms, and friendships, and who believes in rules, curfews, and chores. I have no regret about my own life trajectory beyond acknowledging I've made other mistakes I can't take back. I have no reported regret about transition because I never transitioned. My breast reduction I describe as having "no regrets." My mental health improved through talk therapy and DBT, and I describe myself now as loving myself and being happy.