Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che per circa quattro anni si è identificata come FtM e che nel 2019-2020 ha valutato se iniziare il testosterone, propendendo alla fine per non modificare medicalmente il mio corpo per il rischio di rimpianto. La mia disforia riguardava la voce e il voler essere percepita come più mascolina, e ho notato che l'esposizione a storie transgender nei media innescava episodi in cui pensavo di essere trans. Ho una storia di psicosi e diffidavo dei terapeuti di parte o focalizzati sul genere. Al momento di questa trascrizione non ho dichiarato di aver iniziato ormoni o interventi, e attualmente mi identifico con il mio sesso di nascita, femmina, mettendo in guardia gli altri sui rischi della transizione medica.
Storia completa
I have been wrestling with whether to medically transition for years, and my account here is really a record of that ongoing uncertainty rather than a completed detransition.
I first figured out I thought I was female-to-male (FtM) around four years before August 2019, when I was 20 years old. By that point I had a history of psychosis, which I mentioned when I related to someone else in a similar position. My conclusion at the time was that I needed to learn to love myself as I am — to "deal with the cards iv been delt" — while acknowledging that doing so is really hard.
A major factor in my hesitation has been the influence of the online transgender community. I described getting "sucked into the ideology" and finding it really hard to get out, calling it kinda scary. I also noticed a very specific trigger for what I called "episodes of thinking I'm trans": being exposed to transgender stories in the media. Hearing or seeing a transgender person's journey and how well it went for them made me adopt their mindset instantly, and only when I cut myself off from those sources did I start thinking clearer. I described living in a constant battle with myself — one moment feeling confident that I am "trans" and that transitioning would be great for me, and then a minute later getting back to reality and seeing that I really am female and just need to accept myself as I am. I told myself I was being delusional, but when I slipped into that mindset I saw things very differently.
The specific thing I was weighing in mid-2019 was going on testosterone. I said plainly that I did not think I would regret going on T at that moment, besides a possible increase in depression, while acknowledging that might change after permanently altering my body. By September 2019 I was nearly 21 and told myself I needed time to think about it, not wanting to make rash decisions that would make permanent changes to my body that I wouldn't like. In the moment I felt strongly that I needed a deeper, more androgynous voice, but I recognized that feeling might change in a month or a year.
My stated reason for wanting testosterone was thin: I said I did not have a solid reason other than being annoyed by my own high voice and wanting to be perceived as more masculine in social situations — essentially voice dysphoria. I wondered whether I could combat the dysphoria in other ways, and whether going on T was just the easy way or instant-gratification path, while also doubting I could naturally get my voice as deep as I wanted. I worried specifically about ending up with a nasally voice on T, and noted I might be able to speak more from the chest and less from the nose, but that there was no guarantee — it would be a big risk to take. At one point I reflected that perhaps it was just a confidence thing, and that I had an ideology in my mind that my voice sounded gross and weird and that changing it would be the answer, but maybe I should try to work with what I have and become more confident in my voice as it is.
I was actively researching and asking questions in January 2020, including posting a question I said I mostly asked to help me in my decision to transition or not, and considering asking on the FtM subreddit. I was also reading detrans communities by then and offered my own definition of what the subreddit was for: detransitioned people who previously identified as the opposite gender, transitioned, but now identify with their birth sex. I noted not everyone switches back to their birth pronouns and that doesn't mean they are still trans, and I said that not all detransitioned people are against transitioning — just that it was not for them and they warn others about the dangers of medically transitioning because they might regret it.
My advice to others in a similar position was to find a therapist who is not biased and will not push transition when what is really needed is to work out emotions and get to the root of why one feels dysphoria, and to find a therapist independently rather than through a psychiatrist referral — not a gender therapist. I also suggested finding a support group of friends who are trans but decided not to take hormones, and I offered to chat with anyone who needed to talk.
On the transcript I have, I never state that I actually started testosterone, had any surgery, or formally detransitioned, so I leave those fields empty rather than assume an outcome.