Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: ho iniziato il testosterone a 14 anni senza alcuna disforia di genere precedente, ho fatto una doppia mastectomia a 16, ho preso la T per circa 2 anni, mi sono identificata come non binaria per 2,5 anni dopo averla smessa e ho fatto ufficialmente detransition intorno al 2017-2018. Rimpiango profondamente di aver fatto la transizione medica da bambina senza un'adeguata indagine psicologica e convivo con effetti permanenti tra cui voce grave, peli sul viso, cicatrici al petto, petto asimmetrico e dolori toracici cronici. Al lavoro mi hanno ripetutamente chiamata «signore» e mi hanno chiesto i pronomi, cosa che ho trovato umiliante ed esponente, e a gennaio 2022 ho scritto che la situazione mi rendeva suicidaria, anche se non descrivo tentativi. La mia salute mentale si è in parte stabilizzata negli anni senza ormoni, aiutata da mindfulness e DBT, e ora ho un partner che mi sostiene, amici e un lavoro che mi piace. Oggi sostengo con forza la transizione sociale prima di qualsiasi ormone, critico la facilità con cui la TOS viene prescritta ai minori e rifiuto sia l'identità non binaria sia figure politiche esterne che parlano a nome di chi fa detransition.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first thought 'Wait... am I transgender?' one night as a teenager and went with it, thinking it was the reason for and answer to my unhappiness. I started testosterone at 14, in 2014, with no prior history of gender dysphoria, after only about 2 months of therapy, and after learning about transition from Tumblr at 13-14 where my best friend in middle school was trans. I had top surgery (double mastectomy) at 16, in 2016. I stopped taking testosterone about a year and a half after starting, roughly 2 years on T total. After stopping T I identified as nonbinary for about 2 and a half years before accepting that I wanted to live and be seen as female again. I officially detransitioned around 2017-2018; by 2022 it had been over 4 years since I officially detransitioned, and by late 2024 I described myself as 8 years post-detransition. I am now a detransitioned woman.
I developed chest dysphoria only after I started identifying as trans. In the weeks/months before my top surgery I had stopped wearing a binder and felt perfectly comfortable, but went through with the surgery anyway because I had already been on T for a year and a half and the thought of 'being a woman' after putting my body through that made me feel I would be unloveable and ostracized. I deeply regret not thinking through what medically transitioning would actually do to my body and simply jumping in as a child who did not know myself better. I do not regret that I dressed and acted like I thought a boy would. I wish I had just gotten a breast reduction instead. I also regret never socially transitioning or presenting masculine first, due to a fear of being considered 'ugly' and being terrified of people knowing I was trans at all.
Contributors for me included: growing up in a very affirming family, obsessive 'Who am I?' identity searching as a Gen Z person plugged into the internet from an early age, Tumblr posts about how to lie to doctors and therapists to get hormones, my best friend being trans, and a personality 180 when I transitioned at 13-14 where I went from being very against 'PC' ideas and identity politics to 100% for them. I also think white guilt and escaping being 'the oppressor' drives many transitions; I felt less like a bad person when I identified as nonbinary rather than a trans man. I now believe the way society perceives manhood and womanhood, plus rigid Western gender roles, drives much of transitioning, and that I was 'a woman who was deeply traumatized by the preconceived societal notions of womanhood and the female experience, so I ran away from it.' The way I experienced being female in society was a big part of why I transitioned, and I have harsh thoughts and feelings about men I still need to work on. I was very 'anti-feminist' for years before realizing how deeply misogyny runs through social behavior.
Physical effects and medical issues: my voice dropped within a week or two of my first shot or two and fully dropped to being read as male over the phone within about 3 months; years off hormones people say it is deep but no longer has a 'masculine' timbre. I still have coarse facial hair and shave every other day; leg hair got lighter and less thick off T; I never grew chest hair. I did some electrolysis sessions on my upper lip and chin about a year before asking about it (around 2020) and hair grew back within 2 weeks; it was expensive. Facial hair is 'probably the single most distressing thing' about my detransition. My top surgery recovery was over a month; one drain was dislodged so part of my chest is not as flat as the rest; I still get phantom-like pains in my chest, mostly on the right side where the drain was, plus residual numbness, and sore nipples years later. I desperately want my chest back but reconstruction success rates and intensity deter me. I wore a small bra for a long time to illusion a small chest, then stopped and decided to own being flat-chested.
Mental health: on T I was angrier than usual and physically could not cry; I had to re-learn how to cry. I experienced cognitive dysfunction and inability to focus or find pleasure in things I enjoyed while on T, and to this day seriously struggle with reading books and making art, which I consider my life's passion. Off T I became much more sad and could cry at the drop of a hat; this leveled out to a more stable place about 3 years off HRT. I found mindfulness/meditation and DBT skills helpful. I have carried guilt, shame, and trauma about my transition. In January 2021 I said the regret was 'more raw than ever.' In January 2022 I posted that I was having a really hard time, that I feel my life is ruined, that I am 'tormented by this mistake I made when I was a CHILD every day,' and that 'This shit makes me suicidal. I am physically and emotionally disfigured.' I have not described any attempts. I have self-image issues I am still working on.
Adversity/social: at a front-of-house job before COVID layoffs I got Sir'd constantly and a child laughed and said I 'look like a girl!' which broke my heart. At a 'hip' grocery store job I was hired alongside two other women and was the only one repeatedly asked 'what are your pronouns?' mid-shift in front of others, which I experience as publicly outing me. I often get read as a trans woman by both trans and non-trans people, and coworkers have used they and said they were 'waiting for me to tell them' what I am. I find the pronoun question humiliating. I told my parents about my detransition over the phone because it was hard to say in person, and it made subsequent conversations easier. My parents were 'totally affirming.'
Sexuality/relationships: I dated a straight man for a long time who never cared about my flat chest, facial hair, or deep voice; I was in a 5-year relationship with a cis man who called me his girlfriend (after 2 years of 'partner' and they/them) which I ended in early 2023; I am now dating a bi man who tells me I'm beautiful. Detransition made dating more selective. I have good friends and a job I'm passionate about who don't care about my past.
Attitudes: I believe medical transition should be much more thoroughly examined therapeutically first and I strongly suggest social transition before hormones; I consider 'toying' with HRT a red flag. I do not believe in non-binary identity; I believe there are two sexes but people are individuals. I am upset when detransition is championed by figures like Jordan Peterson or Matt Walsh ('hucksters speaking for us'). I participate in studies about detransitioners when I can. I feel stuck between a political rock and a hard place when people's first reaction to my detransition is reassurance that I don't hate trans people.