Tutte le storie

Informarsi sulla chirurgia nel 2019 — e non fare mai la transizione

Femmina · Desistito/a203
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition... no — sono una donna cisgender ed eterosessuale (29-30 anni a fine 2019) che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma si è molto coinvolta nelle comunità sulla detransition e critiche verso la transizione dopo aver fatto ricerche sulla chirurgia di riassegnazione del genere. Non ho mai avuto disforia di genere, anche se da adolescente ho avuto depressione, dismorfia corporea e problemi di autostima. Dopo molte letture a partire dal 2019, sono arrivata a vedere i bloccanti della pubertà e gli interventi di genere come profondamente dannosi e mi batto con forza contro la transizione medica pediatrica. Consiglio attivamente ai genitori di bambini che si interrogano sul genere di evitare terapeuti affermativi e di rimandare qualsiasi passo medico all'età adulta.

Storia completa

I am a cisgender, straight woman who was born female and has always identified as a woman. I was intensely 'girly' from before I could form memories — at 3-4 years old I screamed and cried to wear dresses every day, obsessed over pink and purple, and wanted baby dolls, even though my mother (my primary custodial parent) never pushed female socialization on me and was a laid-back 'let kids like what they like' parent. That femininity never faded; I remain a very feminine woman interested in makeup, fashion, and crafting, while also pursuing a STEM PhD. I never experienced gender dysphoria. I was a depressed teenager with body dysmorphia and self-esteem issues that made it hard to imagine myself in sexual situations with the opposite sex, and I had family issues, but the idea of becoming a man to cope never crossed my mind. I lost my virginity in college and described myself as 'sheltered and a late bloomer' compared to a best friend who lost her virginity at 14. I had a successful, loving 7-year relationship (which I elsewhere described as a 7-year marriage-level relationship), then spent some time single and found another partner with relative ease. By 29 I felt increasing confidence and self-love, and I noted I'd changed immeasurably from ages 14 to 18 to 21 to 25 to 30. Around mid-2019 I became absorbed in reading about gender reassignment surgery (GRS), especially male-to-female, after looking up information about Jazz Jennings and going 'down the rabbit hole' for a couple of months. I work in science, and what I read shocked me: I had previously told a gay friend that puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries could simply 'correct' trans people's bodies, but after researching I came to believe puberty blockers are 'a brutal form of child abuse' causing early osteoporosis, organ failure, failure to mature sexually, and loss of orgasm/attraction, and that GRS surgeries are frequently 'butchery' with complications like tissue necrosis, fistulas, loss of sexual function, colostomies, and painful lifelong dilation. I concluded bottom surgery, at least male-to-female, 'should be illegal' and that doctors performing it are breaking their oaths. I also believe far fewer female-to-male horror stories exist, possibly because fewer trans men get those surgeries. I have not transitioned or detransitioned myself; rather, I spend time in detransition and critical spaces offering advice to parents of gender-questioning children. I advise against 100% affirming counselors, against any permanent changes (blockers, hormones, surgery) before 18, and suggest compiling photos and posts of surgical and hormonal regrets to show a child the risks — while always leading with love and support. I believe some children genuinely know their gender identity from toddlerhood and that there may be physiological/brain differences in people who transition, but that no medical intervention can make one biological sex fully identical to the other, and that gender-nonconforming people don't need surgery to be legitimate. I am critical of what I see as predatory surgeons, of parents like Jazz Jennings' mother whom I view as fame-grasping, and of the framing of transition as positive or risk-free. I have no personal regret about transition since I never transitioned; my advocacy is observational and based on research rather than lived experience of medical intervention.