Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo eterosessuale che ha fatto la detransizione: ho iniziato gli estrogeni a poco più di 30 anni, ho smesso, ho ricominciato a 36 anni durante la pandemia e di recente ho smesso di nuovo. Mi sento isolato come maschio biologico nelle reti detrans e a volte ho sentito che la solitudine mi faceva venire voglia di fare la transizione. Ho un master e oggi affronto il genere in modo logico, criticando le definizioni mutevoli di sesso e genere nella comunità trans, le etichette non binarie e l'idea che l'omosessualità riguardi il genere anziché il sesso biologico. Con gli estrogeni ho perso 50 libbre e messo su muscoli, e per farcela uso pratiche di affermazione positiva (Blinkist, dirmi che valgo e che il mio corpo è valido). Sospetto che tratti dello spettro autistico e genitori emotivamente immaturi abbiano contribuito al mio sentirmi solo e al trovare compagnia immediata negli spazi trans.
Storia completa
I was born male and have lived as a detransitioned person for some time now, though my path has been complicated. I started estrogen in my early 30s and stayed on it for about a year, then stopped until I was 36, at which point — during the pandemic — I started again, and more recently I stopped once more.
I hold a master's degree, and I've found that thinking about gender logically rather than emotionally has made me question a lot of what I was told in trans communities. I got into a conflict with someone who became upset when I said, 'well your body is female and a vulva is a female body part' — they insisted 'no I am male now and thats a male body part.' That exchange really crystallized my confusion about the shifting definitions I was encountering: gender and sex being different in one conversation and the same in the next, female bodies on testosterone being called male bodies. I also heard an afab person claim they weren't really afab and that who knows what their chromosomes might be. I've wondered whether I missed some new medical revelation, or whether this is self-delusion.
I've struggled with feeling isolated as a biological male. I've noticed that both masculine females and feminine females who get top surgery seem to have this great support and love and bonding, whereas men — and especially detransitioners — seem to have a much colder, smaller network with none of that support. Sometimes that loneliness has actually made me want to transition again. I asked in the community how long a person needs to be on testosterone (off estrogen) before pursuing top surgery, or whether it even matters.
I've thought a lot about stereotypes and performance. When ftm people say things like 'like a guy,' it bothers me — it makes me feel like being a man is being reduced to a stereotype, as if someone can be a guy by acting a certain way when gender isn't really about performance. I don't like the phrase 'living as a man' either, because it implies man is some sort of thing you can just act as. In reality I don't see why male and female experiences have to be all that different — we can choose to wear whatever we want and act as we want, with the major difference between males and females being what's in their pants. When I was transitioning, the only change in clothing I made was smaller clothes because I lost 50 lbs; I still shopped both sections and I literally changed nothing about how I acted or what I did.
I've dealt with body image issues. I lost 50 lbs and gained a lot of muscle while on estrogen, and I actually felt better about being male as that happened. I've questioned why we pay for 'gender affirmation' but not weight affirmation. I also observed that my doctor said gender is often visible in the eyes and brow ridge — without a male brow bone, faces can look off to me, and I've noticed ftm people often have sparse facial hair and that the brow bone is the giveaway.
On sexuality, I hold fairly firm views: I think homosexuality is about biological sex, not gender — you're born male and like others born male, or born female and like people born female. I don't think trans guys can really be gay guys without a penis; a vulva owner being with a man seems straight to me, or at most queer. I worry that if anyone who calls themselves a man can be a gay man, the word loses all meaning. I've also pushed back on nonbinary, saying I don't even know if it has any meaning — almost every LGBTQ person uses they/them and it seems to describe nothing. I'd rather ask people why not just identify as female, since the one thing I learned through all this is that M and F don't mean much outside of someone's birth sex.
I've thought about what drives people to transition. I've heard someone say 'if I was born male I would still be trans,' which made me wonder whether being trans is now just a social identity, trend, or community rather than a real disorder. I think there was a time trans meant someone who dearly struggled to be the opposite gender, and sometimes I wonder if now it's just a trend or a way to get attention for some. I've also noted that being on the autism spectrum seemed much more common among trans people — my doctor started doing their own surveys because it was so common yet somehow not studied enough. I relate to that personally: as a white het male with emotionally immature parents, it's easy to feel alone, especially if you're neurodivergent, and these spaces offered instant companionship at the cost of being filled with mental health issues.
On my own healing, I've started listening to Blinkist and positive-thinking books, and I do think the words we tell ourselves can reinforce themselves. I've been trying to tell myself every day that I'm worthy, I am likable, and my body is valid. I know you can't get back certain things, but I've encouraged others that breast augmentation has come a long way if that's something they want. I've also acknowledged that sometimes I'm just venting and need to get things out. I've offered to be open for DMs for anyone who wants to vent.
I've been critical of how some people in the community argue — that you can't win when the only rule is whatever trans people say is valid, and that 'terf' gets thrown out even if you aren't a feminist, like calling someone a racist when it has nothing to do with the discussion. I've also questioned why so many females would want this for their lives, and whether male socialization is flawed. I've noted studies suggesting 100% of women on T had internal vaginal tissue changes of unknown long-term health and cancer significance.