Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che ha detransizionato: ho fatto una top surgery a doppia incisione a 24 anni mentre mi identificavo come uomo trans, sono tornata a vivere come donna e ora mi definisco una femmina orgogliosa che rifiuta il binarismo. Per circa un anno dopo l'intervento ho avuto un grave disagio psicologico, anche se da allora ho imparato ad accettare e persino ad apprezzare il mio petto piatto, aiutata da antidepressivi, protesi mammarie e dall'esprimere la femminilità che avevo represso. Non ho mai preso il testosterone a lungo — l'ho provato per poco più di tre mesi nel 2022 e ho smesso per paura per la salute — ma lotto ancora con la tentazione ricorrente e la gelosia quando vedo altri in T, in particolare per il cambiamento della voce. Non rimpiango del tutto l'intervento, ma dico che non lo rifarei se potessi tornare indietro, e vorrei aver scelto una riduzione. Resto attiva nella comunità detrans, mettendo in guardia gli altri sui rischi di binding e interventi e sostenendo le persone con forte disforia.
Storia completa
I was born female. I developed large breasts — 36DDD/F — and had top surgery (double incision, with nipple grafts) at age 24 while identifying as a trans man; I never took HRT at that time. My mother died of breast cancer when I was 19, and I now suspect that loss and the health anxiety it produced subconsciously contributed to my perceived need to be rid of my breasts; I remember feeling like my own chest was a ticking time bomb despite being very young. I also recall that binding was a slippery slope for me: the first time I wore a binder in a situation where I couldn't take it off I almost had a panic attack, but I powered through and eventually the pressure became soothing rather than anxiety-inducing. I believe that if I hadn't gotten a binder people told me was 'safe' and hadn't believed it was a harmless, reversible change, I would still have my breasts and might have made peace with them another way.
Before transition I was obsessed with the aesthetic of some men without being attracted to them, and I daydreamed for as long as I could remember about being my favorite male characters. I also went by the name Connor while living as male after playing the game Detroit: Become Human. I had gotten myself so dissociated from my breasts — and was so dissociated during that time in general — that they no longer felt like part of me, which was distressing.
The aftermath of surgery was far harder than I expected. I felt good immediately afterward, but as soon as the surgery happened I felt so wounded, and I've never quite recovered from that even at 10 months healed. I experienced intense mental anguish and confusion for 6+ months — really more than a year — purely because of my body's visceral reaction to the abrupt, irreversible change; I was pretty severely messed up for almost a year afterwards, crying about it every other day at least and berating my past self. I had two large dead spots that were completely numb for the first year or so. Nothing could have prepared me for the phantom sensations and my brain expecting weight that wasn't there, especially when trying to sleep. I thought I'd be proud of my scars but they're just scars — marks of unnecessarily inflicted injury on my body. I had partial numbness, pain, and unscratchable itches that made me sad sometimes. If I could go back in time, I wouldn't do it; I'd tell anyone with doubts not to get this surgery.
Around May 2020 I was approaching detransition and wanted to 'fem it up' more often, missing how my chest filled out feminine outfits. I ordered silicone breast forms and was surprisingly pleased: they sat well, looked realistic, and gave me a noticeable calm and relief — the weight was almost just right, as if my chest was back the way it was, while still being removable so I could enjoy being flat. My only complaint was nipple irritation underneath them. I also tried on an old bra out of curiosity and it felt absurd since I'd been a double D and there was nothing there now.
I started antidepressants, and by August 2020 I posted that I felt so much better: something clicked, my body felt whole again, and I loved my flat chest. I wrote that letting the dam break — allowing myself to express all the femininity I'd suppressed while identifying as male — let me feel comfortable and confident again, and that my body is just mine. I described myself as a proud binary-rejecting female. The show She-Ra was meaningful to me: it was the first piece of media in a long time that had me identifying with and wanting to be female characters rather than male ones, and it helped me reconcile with being female.
Despite that progress, the temptation to go on testosterone recurred repeatedly. In November 2020 I wrote that the temptation crops up often, especially seeing others thrive on it — a FOMO feeling, wondering if I'd be a 'more ideal' version of me — while knowing I have almost no physical dysphoria anymore and that T would be a mistake. Triggers included college friends coming out and starting T, and the online community my partner and I run, which has many transmasculine members who talk about transition milestones. In August 2021 I asked whether the temptation ever fully goes away, more than a year after deciding never to pursue HRT.
In March 2022 I described actually starting T because the idea was stuck in my head. It felt good at first, but after about two months doubt returned; fear of damaging my body, of possibly needing a hysterectomy, and of long-term endocrine dependence led me to stop at just over three months. I'm left with new hair on my thighs and stomach that I'm not a big fan of, and a slightly lowered voice that's only occasionally noticeable to anyone but me. Going on T briefly seemed to be the only way to get it out of my head. I really like the voice change and want more of it.
In June 2022, seeing a transmasc performer live — particularly their rich, male-sounding voice — triggered old desires so strongly that within days I scheduled an appointment to discuss going back on hormones, then waffled about whether to attend. I worried whether this would be a pattern forever. I noted that trans folks tend to downplay the risks of T while gender critical types tend to be alarmist, making it hard to feel informed; atrophy alarms me most. I decided to prioritize my health and not go back on for now.
Current physical status: sensation has largely returned across my chest but is drastically reduced overall — it takes more pressure to feel, light touch may go unnoticed, my grafted nipples are a bit puffy from scar tissue, feel pain rather than touch when pressed, and I have close to zero erotic sensation (I had some before surgery). I still get random shooting pains where my drains were. I went to a well-regarded surgeon with consistent results.
On regret, my feelings vary day to day, sometimes hour by hour. I don't fully regret it, but if I could go back in time I might make a different choice; I wish I'd had a reduction instead, since I could always have proceeded to full mastectomy later. I now feel more settled and accepting of myself as a female person and it doesn't seem like such a big deal. I enjoy practical benefits: I'm more physically comfortable, I can wear crop tops I couldn't before, I love sleeping and working out shirtless, and my girlfriend says I'm the most attractive person in the world to her. On the few occasions I still wonder if I made a mistake, it comforts me to know I'm safer from breast cancer.
I have a cis female partner who is bisexual; she's attracted to masculinity and encourages my masculine traits, which I think contributed to my pursuing transition in the first place — a subconscious insecurity about whether she'd be happier with a man. I'm not sure whether I'm overall attracted to men/mascs but I allow that I might be a bit bi.
Attitudes toward transition for others: I think binding and top surgery are viable options for people whose dysphoria is severe and debilitating on its own, but that binding is too readily encouraged and its risks downplayed for people with mild dysphoria or before exploring body acceptance and mental health treatment. I advise anyone considering top surgery to only proceed when at peace with themselves, having addressed other mental health issues, and 1000% sure it will improve quality of life. I've counseled others to slow down, address dissociation before transitioning, and to distinguish 'presenting male' from 'presenting masculine.' I've also noted that there's no 100% consistent trans narrative and that a comfortable trans identity without bodily modification is fine. I've expressed discomfort with research referring to trans-identified subjects as 'women,' feeling it would be received better if presented more respectfully. I've been an active, visible participant in the detrans community, sharing my experience to help others.