Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna in desistenza: per oltre un anno mi sono identificata socialmente come genderfluid, mi facevo chiamare Syd con i pronomi lui/loro e ho fatto detransizione sociale nell’ottobre 2023 a 19 anni, senza mai fare la transizione medica. Ora mi chiamo Amelia, il mio nome di nascita, e sono una donna bisessuale cis che lavora per sentirsi più femminile. Ho capito che la mia presunta disforia era in realtà guidata da autismo, DOC, vaginismo, invidia dello stile più che invidia del genere e pressione sociale di un’amica. Resto fortemente favorevole ai diritti trans e ho sostenuto pubblicamente contro la transfobia negli spazi detrans, nonostante forti reazioni contrarie. Non descrivo rimpianti intensi, complicazioni mediche né ideazione suicidaria.
Storia completa
I am Amelia. I was born female, and I use she/they pronouns. I am 19 years old as of October 2023. I never went through any physical or medical transition — my detransition is social only.
For over a year I went by the name Syd and used he/they pronouns, and I identified as genderfluid. I moved to university in September 2022, so nobody at uni knew me as Amelia until I announced my detransition on 19 October 2023. Hearing people call me Amelia felt 'SUPER WEIRD. like an insult' at first because I had grown so used to resenting that name, even though I have always loved it and think it's pretty. I asked for advice on how to get used to being called my birth name again. What has helped me is watching POV videos of people being gendered female — she/her pronoun testers or repetition videos of my name. Hearing my name and pronouns helps a lot. It was awkward at first and sometimes still is, but by December 2023 I said I was much more used to it.
I announced my detransition publicly with an Instagram post and changed my social media handles. I discussed it first with a few close friends, my partner, and a teacher at uni I'm comfortable with who is also LGBT. The Instagram post got the most likes I have ever had on that account, and everyone has been very supportive. I also mentioned I was in the process of changing my name on everything.
Here is what led me to realise I wasn't actually experiencing dysphoria:
- I am autistic and have OCD, and I also suffer from vaginismus. I said these combined make me feel very disconnected from my genitalia and see it as 'out of sight out of mind', which sounds like dysphoria but isn't.
- I want to be androgynous and sometimes want my chest to be flat, but I don't want a beard. My 'gender envy' was mainly towards females, and the males I got it from (Robert Sheehan, Timothee Chalamet) were femme — I realised it wasn't gender envy, it was STYLE envy.
- I had very few childhood signs, and only started feeling socially dysphoric after a friend told me I'm probably not non-binary if I don't feel a certain way. I started thinking too much about it and made myself more socially dysphoric.
- My childhood signs could all be explained by being queer, autistic, having OCD, or having vaginismus. As a kid playing Roblox I liked dressing up with a boys' haircut and girls' clothes, wanting people to ask if I'm a boy or girl — not because I'm non-binary but because I'm gender non-conforming.
- I always had a connection to girlhood as a kid and loved my name. That was more of a recent thing, which was a red flag for me.
- I felt like I was forcing myself into a box with my gender. I missed girlhood and being a woman.
- My partner also thinks I didn't actually have dysphoria, just other similar things.
- I might still bind or even envy top surgery, but I won't actually get it because I do like having boobs — I just want to be flat sometimes for aesthetic reasons. As a kid, when I was flat I hated it and wished I was pretty with boobs.
I applied for the NHS gender healthcare waiting list in the UK aged 18, which was a 3-6 year wait, and I desisted in October 2023 before finishing that wait. I said I was thinking of getting top surgery but didn't even come close. I own two binders which I don't wear anymore but kept because they're expensive and because I'm an acting student and they could be useful for a role.
Since detransitioning I have been working on feeling more feminine. I had short curly hair reaching the base of my neck and was growing it out. I shaved my head in July (2023), grew it out, got it cut short again in October (2023) — a short pixie with bits of the sides shaved — and now it's a layered short bob with bangs. I have curly hair with an extensive curl routine. I've been building a wardrobe I like — I adore vintage 1950s pinup/rockabilly style, which I'm building up slowly over time, and I style masc clothes in a feminine way. I have pink and black nails on, recently healed ear piercings I've been enjoying earrings with, and I wear makeup (I buy cheaper brands). I also mentioned growing my hair out as part of my 'slow feminisation'.
I am autistic, which I mentioned when people got angry at my posts — I said maybe I phrase things wrong. I also have OCD, which I linked to my gender confusion, and vaginismus, which causes disconnection from my genitalia. I don't mention other mental health conditions. I don't describe any trauma or adversity.
I am bisexual — I described myself as a 'tomboy bisexual woman' who is sometimes femme. I have a partner. I mentioned dating a guy at some point who told me he used to identify as non-binary, and I was fine with it. I have many trans people in my life who love and accept me.
I regret my social transition enough to have detransitioned, but I don't express intense anguish about it — I describe it as 'just a part of your history. It's not you!' I do say detransitioning is 'still horrible for me' in the sense of the social awkwardness, but it's 'no where near as bad as someone who had any surgeries'. I don't mention fertility concerns or medical complications since I never medically transitioned. The main ongoing irritation is that I can't change my Reddit username, which still says Syd.
My mental health conditions (autism, OCD) are mentioned but I don't describe how they changed after detransition.
I am broadly supportive of transition for other people. I have repeatedly argued against banning trans healthcare, said 'trans men are men, trans women are women', and said being a detransitioner/desister is not a reason to be transphobic. I wrote a post on 17 January 2024 titled 'Hot take: being a de-transitioner/desisted person is NOT a reason to be transphobic', which gained a lot of attention and pushback. I said there should be doctor checks and risk warnings, that detransitioners can and should share their experiences, but that trans healthcare shouldn't be banned. I got heavily downvoted for these views multiple times. I also pushed back on people telling others to detransition for social ease, saying 'If you want to transition, transition. Even if it's hard.' I have not done formal activism beyond these Reddit posts and my Instagram announcement.