Tutte le storie

Una pozione magica e la decisione di vivere senza

Femmina · Detransizionato/a524
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono nata femmina, mi sono sempre sentita attratta solo dalle donne e mi identificavo come trans con una grave disforia di genere prima di fare la detransizione. Ora vivo come donna mascolina detransizionata, accettando il mio sesso di nascita anche se vorrei comunque essere maschio se esistesse una pozione magica. Vedo la transizione come un progetto cosmetico e ideologico che non ti dà il sesso opposto, ho smesso di odiarmi e ho abbracciato la realtà. Resto critica verso la promozione della transizione, soprattutto per i giovani, e verso l'ideologia secondo cui si nasce nel corpo sbagliato. Non rimpiango di essere stata davvero trans, ma considero la transizione una perdita di tempo e di risorse.

Storia completa

I was born female and I have only ever been attracted to women. I identified as trans for a period of my life and I would be considered "true trans" by every metric imaginable — I had gender dysphoria so severe that I constantly considered killing myself. I transitioned, and I detransitioned. I now describe myself as a masculine detrans woman. What led me to transition was a combination of things. I've always been gender nonconforming — even among other GNC women I don't fit in for being too masculine behaviorally, so being male would simply have been easier. I wanted to be the opposite sex; if there was a magic potion I could drink to become male, I absolutely would drink it. I was drawn to hypermasculinity. But I came to see that transition doesn't actually give you the opposite sex — hormones and surgeries are cosmetic solutions that "work" for people who want to be trans, not for people who want to be the opposite sex. Even when you pass flawlessly, you're still just a virilized woman, and there's an uncanniness you can never get around. I hated being trans because being trans makes you an uncanny facsimile of the opposite sex at best, which just wasn't good enough for me. I don't regret transitioning in the sense that I understand why I did it — I was as trans as it gets — but I also don't endorse doing this to yourself or the ideology behind it. The ideology tells people like me that we're born in the wrong body and need to make ourselves sick to fit in. I don't think trans is an innate thing and I don't think cis is either. There are just people who exhibit varying degrees of gender nonconformity and gender (or sex) dysphoria. No one is born in the wrong body. Gender dysphoria doesn't arise from a vacuum. I think what's destructive is the lazy understanding that being trans is something you're just born as and you have no choice but to pretend to be the opposite sex or you'll be miserable and suicidal. What moved me toward detransition was realizing that being trans means constantly chasing external validation — measuring my self-worth by how well I could deceive others — and that medicalizing my body out of self-hatred wasn't healthy. I stopped hating myself and embraced reality. I compare it to an addict quitting drugs or a bulimic stopping binging and purging. Transition was a waste of time and resources, and the mature thing is accepting that there are things in life you can't have. Even if I'm not completely happy with my sex, I accept it because that's the thing that's brought me peace. Transition did the opposite. I don't think I was "confused" or did an oopsie — I was genuinely trans by every available definition, and plenty of detransitioners were trans; we've just chosen to stop destroying ourselves. I'm critical of the idea that being trans is an innate identity. I think heavily GNC people prone to gender dysphoria exist and probably have since the inception of gender roles, and some of them consistently wish they were the opposite sex — I'd know because I'm one of them — but that doesn't mean I endorse the metaphysical belief that some people are born in the wrong body. On physical dimorphism, I can relate to struggles with physical strength and sex dimorphism. Even on androgens we don't have the same bone density or organ size as male counterparts. I don't mind my height. I've worked on confidence — posture, taking up space physically, eye contact — because getting big isn't going to fix you. I'm critical of how transition is promoted, especially to vulnerable youth, and I see the medical system's involvement as medical malpractice. I don't think the low regret rates people cite are accurate. I'm active in detrans spaces and I'm supportive of other masculine detrans women — there are plenty of us. I don't think the subreddit encourages repression so much as self-acceptance. I'm skeptical of "conversion therapy" framing and critical of what I see as gender ideology's capture of the discourse. I don't think transition should be presented as the only option for people with severe gender dysphoria, and I believe enabling someone's neuroses makes them more neurotic, not less. Current status: I live as my birth sex, a masculine detransitioned woman. I'm not completely happy with my sex but I accept it, and I consider that honesty to be better than the make-believe and misery of transition.