Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna cisgender e matrigna, non una persona che ha fatto detransition, che si è avvicinata alle comunità di detransition per preoccupazione verso i giovani che prendono decisioni mediche permanenti. Il mio figliastro ha fatto coming out come trans a 13 anni e, dopo anni di forte identificazione, ha mostrato segni di retromarcia, cosa che sospetto rifletta la paura di fare detransition. La nostra famiglia ha accettato la transizione sociale ma si è rifiutata di finanziare quella medica, chiedendogli di farsi carico finanziariamente di eventuali ormoni o interventi. Sostengo pieni diritti per gli adulti trans ma credo che ai bambini vadano vietati ormoni e interventi, e critico la comunità medica per un filtro inadeguato. Seguo e apprezzo le comunità di detransition come fonte di realismo su questi temi.
Storia completa
I am a cisgender woman and a stepmother to a child who came out as transgender (female-to-male) at age 13. I want to be clear from the start: I am not trans and never have been, and I am not questioning it either. My involvement in these conversations comes entirely from my family experience and my concern for young people making life-altering medical decisions.
My stepchild came out to us four years ago at 13, and it has been a rollercoaster. At first he was 'hardcore trans' — everything trans-related was all he would talk about. He adopted very masculine clothing, got a short haircut, wore a binder, and used male name and pronouns. As he's gotten older, we've watched that intensity fade. He stopped asking about testosterone, stopped binding, stopped packing, grew his hair out to a neutral style — something like a short bob — and started wearing a mix of female and male clothing. His Facebook profile now says non-binary. At one point he shifted to non-binary, backed off altogether, and then returned to identifying strongly as trans again. I suspect he may want to detransition but is afraid of being called a liar, seen as fake, or no longer considered LGBTQ. We think he might be waiting until after he graduates high school (he turns 18 in March) to say anything.
Our approach as a family has been to be supportive but not to his detriment. We affirmed his name and pronouns and allowed social transition — clothing, hairstyle — but we have been staunch on not funding medical transition. Our reasoning is that medical transition is a lifelong commitment: testosterone shots, surgeries, endocrinologist visits every six months, gynecological care, therapy, picking up prescriptions, dosing on time. He will have to finance and manage all of that himself as an adult anyway, so we instilled early that he would have to figure that part out on his own. We also deliberately did not put him in gender therapy because we felt it lacked critical thinking; instead he sees a non-LGBTQ therapist. My husband also has a strong family history of heart disease, which adds to my worry about testosterone specifically. My stepchild is, in his own words, 'super lazy,' and at 17 I don't think he's mature enough to handle his own medical care.
I want to be clear about where I stand overall: I am not against transition and I don't think it's a scam. I believe trans adults who live as regular working, tax-paying citizens 100% deserve the same rights and respect as anyone else. My issue is with how the medical community has failed trans people, especially young people, by not digging deeper into underlying issues. If there were more gatekeeping and thorough medical and mental health care, we wouldn't see as much need for detransition. I personally know families whose children transitioned at age 5, had top surgery and testosterone at 14, and had both at 16 — that is far too young. I also know two minor children who had double mastectomies paid for by their parents, one of them only 14. I believe children should be barred not only from cross-sex hormones but from surgeries as well. Social transition is fine for questioning kids so they can 'test the waters,' but nothing beyond that until they are mature and financially responsible.
I have also followed these issues closely online. I shared a post about Buck Angel's call for the medical community to fully disclose testosterone's effects on natal females — he suffered horrible atrophy that fused his internal anatomy and caused a septic infection requiring emergency surgery, after 20 years of transition with no disclosure from his doctors. I've drawn advice from a YouTuber named Carey, whose videos informed much of how we handled our son's trans identity. I follow the detransition subreddit and have said publicly how helpful I find it, only to be told by others that 'that sub is cancer' — which frustrated me.
On a personal level, I am 44 years old as of May 2020, a professional makeup artist who rarely wears makeup, has never had her nails done, stopped shaving three years ago, and generally doesn't care about conventional beauty standards. I identify as a cis woman with resting bitch face. I have a strong, opinionated presence online and in person, and I care deeply about kids like my son — I've said that as parents we sometimes feel helpless.