Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first came to feel discomfort with being a woman in my youth, though I did not have the language for it at the time; I recall that at 14 I would not have recognized misogyny even if I had considered it. I transitioned in the 2000s, before the surge in public awareness of trans men, when information about female-to-male transition was scarce and I had to deliberately dig to find anything. I lived as a trans man for about a decade and was on testosterone for roughly ten years, using Nebido (an injection given every three months). I had a double mastectomy (keyhole surgery) as part of my transition. I passed as a cis man for much of that time and was a trans activist myself; I described myself as having been 'a woman on anabolic steroids' in hindsight.
Several things contributed to my transition. I had internalized misogyny of a particular kind - not hating women, but finding women 'a bit boring, a bit dull, uninteresting, not as cool as men,' and believing butches secretly wanted to be men. I had confused womanhood with a misogynistic stereotype and could not imagine that someone like me could be a woman. Pornography and the pornified idea of womanhood played a role in how I saw myself as a woman before transitioning; I did not watch porn myself but lived in a society saturated by it, and the only lesbian representations I saw in my youth were oversexualized performances for men. I was sexually harassed from the age of 8. I was autistic and, by my own description, 'gifted' in terms of IQ and highly educated, which did not protect me from distorted beliefs. I was also polyamorous at the time I transitioned, though I say this was an active decision rather than something I was drawn into. I experienced a fear of being sexualized and a desire to escape the narrow social role of womanhood.
My detransition was not a single dramatic decision. I quit testosterone 'cold turkey,' but because I was on Nebido the change was gradual - my hormone levels stayed in the male range for months and it took about a year for labs to return to the female range. My period came back after about a year, and my cycle was very irregular for several years afterward (cycles of 80 days and similar), settling into relative regularity after two or three years. I had facial hair removal by laser - more than 10 sessions - which was very effective; I had a thick dark beard and am now essentially hairless on my face. I have used minoxidil (Rogaine) for years for testosterone-induced hair loss, and I have been afraid to quit it for fear of losing the regrowth.
A pivotal moment was an experience of altered consciousness - what I would call a mystical or spiritual experience, not prompted by psychedelics or any substance - that permanently shifted my perspective on womanhood and allowed me to separate womanhood from capitalist-patriarchal imagery. Alongside this, I came to understand my transition through the lens of internalized misogyny and radical feminism. I also realized that living as a man had not worked for me socially: I felt awful outside of trans circles, felt like shit when people assumed I was a cis man, and found it hard to connect with women when assumed to be a man. I wanted to connect with women, not men. After a decade or so on T I simply found my face and body 'weird and unpleasant.' I also experienced a change in sexual orientation: on T I became interested in men in a way I had not been before, and after quitting T that interest largely disappeared and I became interested in women again. Off T I describe myself as bisexual with a very strong preference for women - 'the kind of bi that's very close to a lesbian' - and I only date women.
I took detransition very slowly. I quit T, got laser, and changed my name; I did not announce anything. I experimented with makeup and stereotypical women's clothing, found it felt wrong, and went back to men's clothes. I identified as non-binary for some years during the process, which helped me make sense of my experiences and develop professional confidence, though I no longer identify that way. I only told my family several years into detransition; their response was 'Are you ok? Is there something you need?' I later noticed my father began using male terms for me more than he had before. I changed my legal sex back to female only after several years of detransition, once I was mostly being read as female. I have never made an announcement at work; I told my boss only when I changed my name.
Medically, I have had no surgeries as part of my detransition until relatively recently. I had a keyhole mastectomy during transition and, years later, a fat-transfer breast reconstruction (no implants, because I did not want the health risks). The initial result looked and felt very much like my original small breasts, but much of the fat was reabsorbed and my chest is now almost as it was before the reconstruction - though there is lumpiness and scarring in the donor area on my stomach. I am planning a second fat transfer. I have considered but not pursued other reconstruction; I have become wary of surgery after my transition. I have ongoing medical issues: severe PMS (which I think may be related to having no breast tissue left), male-pattern hair loss that I treat with minoxidil, and vocal problems. After quitting T I had throat pain and vocal cord issues - a doctor suggested rapid hormonal changes - with pretty much daily pain for a couple of years, and a detransitioned person told me I speak at a pitch too low for me; the pain has improved substantially over the years and I am now mostly pain free. My voice remains deep and I have not deliberately trained it, though it has lightened somewhat and changed without my trying. My Adam's apple became much less prominent off T. My shoulders, chin and facial structure returned to their pre-T shape over several years. I have not had periods of suicidal ideation since detransitioning, though I say I have 'felt regret' and 'wanted to die' at some point in the context of discussing regret with others.
I do not experience deep regret, though I sometimes mourn some things. I say transition 'was a mistake for me' and that I regret my transition, but also that I couldn't have made different decisions with the knowledge I had then, and that I like my life as it is. I describe my detransition as successful: I am content with myself, I live a normal, good life, have love and friends and a job, and I like being myself. I am the most comfortable in my body than I have ever been, though I acknowledge I am 'not pretty' and 'visibly a genderfuck' in some environments. I still struggle with passing: I am read as a woman more and more, especially by older people, but some people still assume I am a man, and some assume I am non-binary. I wear only men's clothing and men's hairstyles, do not wear makeup, and refuse to perform femininity; I have found that wearing baggy men's pants with a somewhat fitted top helps signal a female silhouette without compromising my values. I am anxious about women's restrooms and often avoid them. I have had sexual harassment from age 8 and a long-standing fear of men; I am critical of patriarchy and identify with radical feminism.
I now support trans people and have trans friends, and I do activism for trans rights, while being critical of transition being always the right choice and of the current direction of trans discourse. I believe transition was the wrong choice for me but can be right for others, and I have said I know trans people who have been happy with transition for decades. I am critical of the conflation of gender non-conformity with being trans, of what I see as a subcultural or identity-based expansion of 'trans' beyond medical transition, and of the erosion of female-only spaces. I have advocated for more nuanced conversation about dysphoria, for detrans spaces that are less transphobic and more centered on self-compassion, and for detransitioners to organize and find each other offline as trans people once did. I have been outspoken on Reddit over several years, offering advice to people questioning transition, and I have at times been criticized for it.