Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha desistito, che è andato vicino a iniziare l'HRT ma non l'ha mai fatto, dopo aver capito che facevo la transizione soprattutto per amicizia e accettazione e che non avrebbe risolto la mia depressione. Ho desistito, ogni tanto metto ancora le calze autoreggenti e sto lavorando sulle cause profonde dei miei problemi di salute mentale. Non mi identifico più come trans e trovo imbarazzante il mio passato inseguimento della transizione. Ho posizioni critiche sulla transizione medica, soprattutto per i bambini, pur sostenendo le persone in entrambi i casi. Non ho descritto pensieri suicidi, autolesionismo né tentativi.
Storia completa
I never actually started hormone replacement therapy, but I came very close, and looking back on that period disgusts me. In the years before 2022 I had fantasized about becoming female, and I came out to small groups of friends under a new name. I got a lot of support and felt accepted and happy for a time — I thought I was finally being true to myself. I was talking to a doctor about starting HRT and had an appointment set up, but I kept putting it off for a few weeks because I was hiding all of this from my parents. In the end that delay turned out to be the right decision: the people who had been supportive and made me feel welcome slowly stopped talking to me. That loss made me realize that even if I had gone through with transition I still wouldn't have been happy.
I ended up in a dark place after that, but I pulled through. I came to understand that I had been chasing a dopamine hit through the idea of HRT and transition, and that it wouldn't work. I also recognized that I had wanted to transition partly just to have friends and to be accepted — that I didn't like my body and thought maybe if I were female I'd fit in. After a long time I realized I was just as depressed as before and wasn't treating the root cause of my mental health issues. I have desisted and realized that being female wasn't actually me. I'm still working on my mental health.
I do still sometimes wear thigh highs and I like the way it feels, but I know now that transition isn't the answer. I've described my own experience as being 'guilty' of attempting to transition for social acceptance, and I look back at what I wrote and did during that period with disgust.
On the medical side, I never took hormones and had no surgeries, so there are no irreversible changes or fertility concerns from transition for me. I do think about voice: I work in a job where I voice things, and I've told a detransitioned woman that she sounds like a woman with a slightly deeper voice that I'd have no problem using for a female commercial part.
My views on transition for others are conditional and somewhat critical. I believe a very minute, infinitesimally small percentage of people — particularly those born intersex — genuinely need medical transition. I think everyone has some form of body dysmorphia to some degree, and that both body dysmorphia and being trans are mental illnesses with a deeper root cause that needs mental health support and treatment. I'm strongly against medical transition for children. My preferred approach is: don't transition medically, especially children, but be supportive of the person — because for some people it really is true, and if they detransition you have to be supportive of them too. I've also expressed concern that a large percentage of transgender youth don't identify as transgender as adults, that youths transition for friendship (citing UK studies), and that there is adult pressure and manipulation involved — describing the environment around youth transition as 'a cult with pressure from adults' and referencing algorithmic manipulation by China via TikTok as a destabilizing factor. I've commented that some groups seem 'transphobic' and also against people transitioning back, existing 'for chaos sake,' and I've said a particular outcome 'genuinely saddens' me.
I have not described any activism or advocacy work beyond commenting online.