Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una lesbica che ha fatto detransition o desistito e vive nei Paesi Bassi, e non ho mai preso testosterone. Mi identifico come femminista radicale e ho una visione del genere basata sul sesso, definendo uomo e donna in base al sesso biologico. Ho molti amici detrans che prendevano testosterone e descrivono problemi di salute duraturi, il che mi ha resa critica verso il modo in cui la comunità trans online mette a tacere le voci detrans e critiche: sono stata bannata da un subreddit lesbico per aver detto che non uscirei con qualcuno in terapia con T per le complicazioni di salute. Prima mi sentivo staccata dal mio corpo nella fantasia, cosa che ora comprendo attraverso la lente dell'eterosessualità obbligatoria e della rappresentazione sessista nei media, e ho lavorato per relazionarmi con me stessa così come sono davvero.
Storia completa
I'm a woman living in the Netherlands, and I've never taken testosterone — I have a naturally low, raspy voice, which I've noted is something some lesbians seem to like. I identify as a lesbian and I'm a radical feminist; finding radical feminism was a significant step for me.
On the question of how I relate to my own body and fantasy, I realised fairly recently that I used to never really include myself — 'me me' — in my fantasies. It was as if I never lived in my body. I think that had to do with being in my head too much. I've noticed that many lesbians do the same thing, and I attribute it less to penis envy and more to the fact that there is very little media about women that isn't built on sexist stereotypes — men in media get to be cool, witty, funny, have agency, have personality — so it's probably compulsory heterosexuality or something like it. I've started trying to fantasise about how I actually am, and it hits differently; it's so much more personal than being distanced from my own body.
I've thought a lot about the meaning of sex and gender. My view is straightforward: a man is someone of the male sex, a woman is someone of the female sex. Gender doesn't really mean anything to me — it's just a way to say whether someone is a male or female human being.
I've been active in detrans and lesbian spaces online. I've reassured other women that they look female even with short hair, and told someone they looked much happier. I've also been open about my own voice — I've told people I've never been on T but naturally have a low, raspy voice.
The thing that has discouraged me most lately is the trans community's treatment of detrans voices. In October 2023 I posted about how I was getting discouraged with the trans community and how they silence detrans voices. Mainly I was talking about how critical thought and science seem to be treated as taboo, but the misogyny and homophobia is part of it too. I knew you could get banned easily on Reddit for some opinions, but I didn't realise it had gotten to that point. Someone on the subreddit butchlesbians asked if lesbians date transmasc people, and I got banned for my answer. What I said was that I wouldn't date someone on T because of the health complications. I was confused and frustrated by the ban — it felt like the majority of the community wants to keep dysphoric people ignorant and unaware, and I didn't understand why. It felt like anyone who dares to talk about the downsides of hormones gets shut up. I have many detrans friends who used to be on T, and they all tell me how much it messed with them and how their health is bad now, but you're not allowed to speak about that.
I've also been a supportive presence for others in the community — offering my DMs to people who wanted to talk, and complimenting people's progress and appearance.