Tutte le storie

Convinta da Tumblr a 17 anni, poi il sistema l'ha delusa

Femmina · Detransizionato/a190
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha detransizionato: nel 2010, da adolescente, sono stata convinta di avere la disforia soprattutto tramite Tumblr, e in seguito ho fatto la transizione e preso testosterone per un periodo. Ora guardo in modo critico al modello della transizione, credendo che sia stato il sistema stesso a deludermi e non io a doverne essere incolpata, e metto in guardia gli altri dal fare la transizione per i motivi sbagliati. Il testosterone mi ha fatta sentire meglio in alcuni modi, ma i suoi effetti non persistono dopo averlo interrotto, e sono ambivalente sull'incoraggiare altri a prenderlo. Ho riflettuto su come vengo percepita — compreso aver scambiato la mia voce per una voce FTM — e ora rifiuto l'idea di "sembrare più femmina", accettando di essere quella che sono. Mi confronto con l'analisi femminista sull'autonomia corporea e continuo a esplorare nomi e presentazione dell'identità.

Storia completa

I came to this community after years of trying to make sense of what happened to me. Looking back, I can say plainly that I was a late teen in 2010 when I was essentially convinced I had dysphoria, almost entirely through Tumblr. That was the environment I was immersed in, and it shaped how I understood myself at a formative age. I did transition and was on testosterone for a period of time. When someone asked me recently whether the changes from testosterone stay, I told them honestly that yes, some of it happens, but it doesn't stay — the effects fade once you stop. I've also admitted that testosterone does make me feel better in some ways, and that the expectations placed on us are so oppressive that I would be a hypocrite to tell anyone flatly not to take it, even though I don't want to encourage anyone to start it either. I've suggested to others that a low dose might be an option, while being clear about my own ambivalence. I've thought a lot about how the system itself failed me. I told someone else who was blaming themselves that they weren't really at fault or stupid — that they just made use of the system in place, and maybe the system itself just sucks. That's how I've come to frame my own experience too: I used the tools and narratives that were available to me, and the framework itself was flawed. I also warned someone else not to attempt to transition out of spite for their mother, because it won't fix anything — that came from a place of knowing how little transition resolves underlying family or personal conflicts. In terms of how I see myself now, I've been told I look like 'lesbian Elijah Wood,' and I've pushed back on the idea that there's any such thing as 'looking more female' — that you are what you are and there's no need to prove it further. I've also reflected on how, when I hear my own voice, I can mistake it for an FTM voice — I once listened to an audio clip of myself and, before realizing what community I was in, thought 'oh man you'll never pass with this.' That moment was jarring and illustrative of how disoriented I've felt about my own body and voice. I've also engaged with broader feminist analysis — commenting that a particular quote is 'one more point of contact in a woman's life where her own body is not actually hers,' which reflects how I now situate my experience within a larger framework of women's bodily autonomy. I've also asked another person whether they feel more comfortable with their middle name, which suggests I've been exploring names and identity presentation in an ongoing way. I don't have surgery history, fertility information, or formal mental health diagnoses in my public writing, so I won't speculate on those. What I can say is that my thinking has evolved considerably since 2010, and I now approach the topic of transition with much more caution and nuance than I did as a teenager on Tumblr.