Tutte le storie

Un episodio maniacale nel 2019, sei anni di transizione, poi la scelta della vita

Maschio · Detransizionato/a1,1K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo cristiano in detransition (MTFTM) che ha vissuto come donna trans per circa sei anni, iniziando gli ormoni a ottobre 2019 dopo un episodio maniacale, e che ha fatto un'orchiectomia nel 2024 ma nessun intervento ai genitali. Il femminismo radicale, la lettura di bell hooks, l'autismo, un sospetto OSDD/dissociazione da trauma e la consapevolezza che la disforia persisteva nonostante la transizione mi hanno spinto verso la detransition, e ora mi accetto come maschio ma femminile ed effeminato. Ho una storia di ideazione suicidaria che ho descritto come incanalata nella transizione, e ho deciso di «volere la vita e la vitalità» e ho rinunciato a quella strada. Faccio ancora fatica con l'immagine corporea, gli appuntamenti e la solitudine, e ho detto che potrei voler essere celibe. Resto critico verso la transizione per gli altri pur avendo compassione per le persone trans, e sostengo un'indagine più profonda sulle radici della disforia e una riforma dei ruoli di genere invece della medicalizzazione.

Storia completa

I was born male and I've been gender non-conforming and feminine for as long as I can remember. Growing up, I was raised Christian in what I now describe as a family of 'two runts of the litter' who made 'seriously weird choices' — I've written that 'one way or another this dysphoria is built into my pedigree.' I was always drawn to girls' and women's company, and I struggled to form deep friendships with other boys; in high school I was ostracized and called gay for not going along with the crude, misogynistic behavior of my male peers, which was 'definitely one of the first times i remember starting to feel disconnected from men.' I also noticed that presenting as a girl to my dad was the first time he showed me affection, which stuck with me. I did blue-collar and trade-type work pre-transition, including cooking and surveying, where I felt scrutinized for my feminine side. I started my social transition around 2018–2019. I transferred to a college far from everyone I knew 'in a random manic episode' and got on hormone therapy that October (2019). Over roughly six years of transition I lived as a trans woman, and in 2024 I had an orchiectomy — 'I had an orchiectomy as a result of being trans the past six years.' I did not have genital reassignment surgery; I've said I'm 'glad I didnt get srs.' I've described myself as having boymoded at work during transition and generally not passing; I never did the voice training ('i dont wanna do that stupid voice'). I've said I 'probably' won't ever pass. I was on T at some point too — in July 2024 I wrote about 'going back on a full dose of T' feeling scary, suggesting I had paused or reduced hormones while questioning. My reasons for transitioning were tangled. I preferred the company of women and struggled to connect with men, and I thought that if I were a woman those problems would go away: 'When you are seen as not right as a man... you start to think: Well If I was a woman I wouldnt be having these problems right now.' I wanted to attract masculine women/lesbians and thought transition might accomplish that — 'I always wanted to attract masculine women most of whom are lesbians so I thought transition might do the trick.' I also wanted to fit in, to be 'one of the girls,' and to have the kind of romance and camaraderie I imagined women having. I've described the desire as partly 'opportunistic' — 'My chips are down as a man for sure and the desire to be a woman was probably opportunistic subconsciously.' I was never raised to be a man and always felt inferior in that role. I also experienced a lot of alienation and harm for being feminine in a male body, which I now attribute to misogyny and patriarchy rather than to transphobia per se. I have autism — 'autism curses us with authenticity lol' — and I suspect I have OSDD (a dissociative disorder), writing 'Pretty sure I have OSDD' and noting I've met many trans people with trauma and probably autism. I've described having parts with different gender identities, including a feminine leadership part that drove the decision to transition, and parts that were 'made to resemble motherly caregivers who I didnt have, or a feminine childlike part because of how I felt my femininity was attacked.' I did IFS therapy for six months with a therapist I thought was only okay, and DBT 'really helped me a lot.' I've also referenced manic episodes — one when I transferred colleges and got on hormones, and 'another manic haze' of frantic reading in 2024. My detransition has been a slow, intellectual process rather than a single event. Radical feminist ideas were a major catalyst: by May 2024 I wrote that I'd 'been convinced mostly by radfem ideas that transitioning dosnt really make sense anymore, and it does nothing to combat patriarchy which is the source of my discomfort.' Reading bell hooks' The Will to Change in 2024 was pivotal — it made me realize 'I never truly escaped masculinity' and prompted me to ask whether transition was actually serving me ('is it serving me?: no'). I've also read Robert Jensen's work on patriarchal sex, Andrea Dworkin, Sylvia Federici, and I wrote a Substack essay titled 'The Sublime Object of Transmisogyny' about whether there should be a pursuit of a gender virtue ethic. I've engaged with manosphere content to understand male behavior and my own MTFTM experience. In December 2024 I wrote that I'd 'Realized sex was the foundation of everything and I wouldn't be able to actually obfuscate it' and 'Realized gender isn't real, sex is.' By January 2025 I said transitioning didn't make me more or less suicidal — 'Just another self destructive outlet for suicidal desires, but in deciding I wanted life and vitality I realized I had to give it up.' I've described myself as 'only considering transition' at one point in mid-2024, then as 'questioning,' and by July 2024 as 'considering detransitioning (mtftm).' I posted asking straight detrans men about their love life and asking ftms how isolation felt when living as male, because I related to that isolation. I've said accepting my biological sex has 'reduced my dysphoria a lot.' I still struggle with body image and with how I look — in July 2024 I posted about feeling 'Faire' lately and thinking about my grandfather's pencil mustache and 40s aesthetic, and I've said the questions left to me are 'whats best for my health and what will make me feel like I look the hottest?' I've noted that hormones matter for bone health: 'Having 0 hormones in your system is potentially dangerous for bone health.' On sexuality, I've described my trajectory as going 'from asexual at thier age to "lesbian" to bi,' and I think I'm bi but that it's affected by social factors. I've tended to get involved with effeminate transmascs and with women who treat me like a guy, which I find 'gross' and unsatisfying. I've written that 'Sex as a guy is weird and bad' and that I worry 'I'll never enjoy sex.' I've said I'd like to live out 'a more supportive feminine role towards a woman who acts out a more authoritative leadership role.' I've considered celibacy — 'Personally I just want to be celebate and swear off the whole thing.' I'm a committed Christian and I frequently cite scripture — Paul on 'neither male nor female,' 'everything is permissible but not everything is beneficial,' 'knowledge puffs up but love builds up' — as a framework for thinking about gender nonconformity and detransition. I've said 'Only Christ can save you from this agony.' On regret: I don't regret everything — 'Honestly it has taught me a lot and I dont regret that. Glad I didnt get srs tho for sure.' But I've become sharply critical of transition as a solution, writing that dysphoria persists for most people after transition, that 'if you've transitioned for like five years and still have dysphoria... it didn't work!!' and that 'you'll never be the opposite sex.' I've described transition as 'some form of subconscious soft eugenics.' I've said 'Before after, it's all the same, I'm still a f*g, a male crossdresser.' I've expressed resentment toward people who made me feel I needed to support the trans narrative, and I've said I don't mind 'not being associated with these freaks' in the online trans world. At the same time I still have compassion for trans people and I've said transition can serve some people in some situations. Currently I'm living as a detransitioned/desisting male — I accept myself as 'male, but boyish and effeminate' — while still sorting out what I want. I've said I don't want to 'sunk cost' myself. My mental health has included suicidal ideation historically, which I now frame as having been channeled through transition; I've said I've 'decided I wanted life and vitality.' I've described my current state as conflicted and searching: 'Oh to be anything at all.'