Tutte le storie

Niente ormoni, niente interventi, e bannato comunque dal sub detrans

Maschio · Desistito/a-7
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono nato maschio e ho provato una transizione sociale, ma non ho mai usato ormoni né fatto interventi; più tardi ho fatto una detransition sociale dopo aver capito che cosa fosse meglio per la mia salute mentale. Al momento non mi identifico come trans, ma dico che mi interrogo ancora sul mio genere e non rientro bene nella categoria detrans. Mi sono iscritto a r/detrans in cerca di risposte, ma sono diventato un critico persistente di quella che vedo come la transfobia, l'ostilità e l'ipocrisia del sub, il che mi ha portato a molti downvote, rimozioni di commenti e al ritiro del mio flair da parte dei moderatori. Credo che ci siano problemi reali nel modo in cui la transizione viene medicalizzata e che alcune persone ne siano danneggiate, ma mi oppongo con forza a un sentimento anti-trans indiscriminato e all'invalidare le esperienze altrui. Non ho descritto interventi medici, diagnosi di salute mentale né pensieri suicidi.

Storia completa

I was born male. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — but I did go through an attempted social transition, and I later socially detransitioned. I've described myself elsewhere as an 'AMAB who fits your description' when discussing male socialization, and I've written that 'it's one thing to struggle with one's transition as I did.' I came to r/detrans on purpose, seeking out the community because gender questions weighed on my mind: 'why would I be in a sub about gender (de)transitioning reading the other side of things if the thought didn't weigh on my mind? It's not a walk in the park as I've come to find out thanks to this sub.' I initially felt a 'great disconnect between what I felt was right for me in my attempted transition and what actually the better option for my mental health,' and I was 'very glad this sub existed at first.' I'm not detrans, but I questioned my own gender and read the posts, and I've said I've 'learned a thing or two.' I've been active in the sub since at least 2021 and have consistently pushed back against what I see as transphobia and hostility toward trans people there. I've repeatedly clashed with other commenters and the moderators. In February 2022 I argued the sub 'gets pretty straight-up transphobic real fast' and that 'the transphobia reeks in this sub.' In October 2022 I told a commenter their 'posting history is pure, unabashed, and mindless transphobia' and that they were 'applauding every single detransition like being trans is inherently bad.' I've said things like 'This sub in a nutshell' and '"It didn't work out for me, so that means I must invalidate everyone else's experiences and life choices" — Typical of this sub.' I've been heavily downvoted for these positions, with comments scoring -9, -10, -13, -18, and -23. In November 2022 I wrote a long comment describing how 'I regularly see people here calling people in the screenshots mentally challenged for stating their opinion on trans topics and being overall awful to liberals who defend it, but partake in that same exact behavior they criticize. Every time I call it out it's always some form of deflection because this sub isn't welcoming of other points of view, ironically.' I noted I'd 'reported comments that broke the sidebar rules that got removed for being that awful and people still defend their statements with tooth and nail.' I've also been accused of not belonging, since participation is 'limited to folk who have detransitioned, desisted, or are actively in the process of questioning their gender transition.' I answered 'yes' twice — implying I fall into the questioning category — but also said 'I don't owe you a single answer.' Someone in the thread was 'trying to kick me out.' I've said 'I'm not detrans' but that I 'question my own gender.' The moderators have removed some of my comments and, I believe, removed my flair. In March 2023 I wrote: 'My comments are being deliberately removed and my flair is unjustly taken off.' I accused mods of 'censoring me under the guise that only people who harbor such feelings are valid for detransitioners' and said 'the mods play dumb when they don't like what they read.' I also criticized the sub's response to a poster who said she felt transphobic after socially detransitioning, arguing the comments were 'poisoning the well and creating a sentiment of us-vs-them.' I've also expressed frustration with the sub's hostility toward me generally: 'I've always gotten some contrarian on my ass in here trying to shut me up.' I've said 'I don't mind the lack of support in this sub anymore. It's clear people here aren't practicing what they preach. I'm saying what's needed to be said and I'm fine with being that person for what I believe is the right cause.' In one exchange I acknowledged a commenter's feedback about my own defensiveness: 'I've considered your comment about the way I'm interpreting things out of my general frustration from some people in this sub and I do need to take a step back. Thanks for the feedback.' But I also said my 'observation of this sub is inherently negative because this sub is negative, overly sensitive and hypocritical.' On broader issues, I've defended the place of intersex people in the LGBT community, cited a study suggesting detransition rates around 10%, argued that gender identity has biological underpinnings analogous to sexual orientation, and dismissed a book (title not stated) as an 'absolute garbage book written in bad faith.' I've argued against right-wing think tanks' research on trans issues, saying 'It's exactly why you'd have to dismiss it entirely: bias.' I've also defended telediagnosis and pushed back against conspiracy-tinged arguments about 'petropharmaceuticals.' I've said I'm 'not outright mean' and 'strive to be fair and civil,' but I 'won't stand for people being jerks to me.' I've described myself as a 'cat person' and joked about downloading Duolingo to improve my English, which I've self-deprecatingly described as inadequate. I've been critical of both extreme pro-transition claims ('Puberty blockers are 100% safe and reversible/No one regrets transitioning if they're genuinely dysphoric/Gender is innate the same way sexuality is innate') and blanket anti-trans sentiment. I've said 'there's lots of room for improvement in the medical scene and something's clearly not working for a section of the trans population or those of us contemplating a transition.' I have not described any specific mental health diagnoses, medications, surgeries, or hormone use. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm. I have not described a specific current identity label beyond being someone who questioned their gender, socially transitioned, socially detransitioned, and is not currently identifying as trans.