Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo bisessuale non conforme al genere che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto la transizione da giovane, sono stato messo in HRT e in seguito ho capito che depressione, ansia, problemi di identità e bassa autostima erano stati etichettati erroneamente come disforia di genere. Non rimpiango le mie decisioni e sento di esserne uscito relativamente illeso, anche se non descrivo cambiamenti irreversibili specifici. Ora credo che la vera disforia esista ma vada diagnosticata solo dopo un colloquio onesto con un terapeuta qualificato, e che la transizione vada valutata con la stessa serietà dell'amputazione di un arto. Ho detto che dovremmo ampliare ciò che significa essere uomo o donna anziché cambiare le definizioni per ottenere conferme, e incoraggio i giovani a prendersi tempo anziché precipitarsi verso interventi medici. In questo materiale non descrivo ideazione suicidaria o autolesionismo.
Storia completa
I came to this community in early 2022, writing mostly in February of that year, and what I have to say comes out of my own experience of going through transition and coming back out the other side.
For me, the story started when I was young. I've said plainly that "if you are young, like I was, HRT is not as harmless as many think" — it was a huge, life-altering decision that I made at a point in my life when I didn't have the perspective to understand what I was doing. Looking back, what I was told was gender dysphoria wasn't dysphoria at all. Depression, anxiety, identity problems, and low self-esteem were all explained away to me as gender dysphoria, and I accepted that framing. I now think a huge source of detransitioned people comes from being told their discontent is gender dysphoria when it isn't. It's completely okay to struggle with identity — you can even have a personality disorder that you get help for because of identity issues — and maybe sexuality is causing the distress. I think true gender dysphoria exists, but I would not diagnose it without an honest talk with a therapist.
Part of what pulled me in was the community itself. When I got a social boost from interacting with other trans people, it felt good to be in such a positive environment, lifted up by everyone in the community. In reality, it was making things worse. I've described how easy it is to misattribute areas of stress and discontent in your life to "gender dysphoria" and have an entire community of people affirm that misattribution and tell you that you're valid, while many of those same people still struggle with depression and anxiety. I also see a contradiction in what I'd call trans culture: breaking gender norms while also using gender norms as validation — if girls are into guy stuff they're not tomboys now, they're trans. It's tiresome.
I don't have a detailed record of specific medical interventions in what I've written here beyond having been on HRT when I was young, and I've referred to having "gotten out of it relatively unscathed," which suggests I came through without catastrophic physical damage, though I haven't spelled out particular irreversible changes. I don't describe surgeries, fertility concerns, or specific diagnoses beyond the identity issues and the depression, anxiety, and low self-esteem that were mislabeled as dysphoria.
In terms of what moved me toward detransitioning, I don't narrate a single dramatic turning point. What I do describe is a process of rethinking: I had to seek out resources myself because I wasn't aware places like this existed when I was going through it. I've encouraged others to find a qualified therapist they're comfortable with and have thorough, honest discussions, and I've said explicitly that Reddit comments should never influence serious life decisions. I've also stressed that kids and teenagers are hormonal messes and that what they often need is time rather than medical intervention.
Where I've landed personally: I'm an effeminate guy, but I'm not a gay man, an "enby," or a trans woman — just a bi, gender-nonconforming guy. I've come to appreciate my differences instead of feeling ashamed because I don't fit in. I honestly don't regret my decisions, because I feel I'm way better off having explored that subculture and lifestyle and having gotten out of it relatively unscathed. I believe we should be expanding what it means to be a man and to be a woman instead of changing the definitions in a desperate-for-validation way. I've said we are blessed to have found our way back, because many don't.
On the question of how I view others' transitions now, I'm cautious rather than absolutist: I believe real dysphoria exists, but I think the decision to transition should be taken as seriously as amputating a limb or having brain surgery, hormones have consequences, and hormones aren't necessary to identify as a trans woman either. I've also commented on why some people react badly to detransitioners — that someone detransitioning validates their deepest fear that they are just like you. I don't describe any activism beyond participating in these discussions online.