Tutte le storie

Commentare su r/detrans senza aver mai fatto la transizione

Maschio · Desistito/a217
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo gay che ha partecipato a r/detrans come commentatore, non come qualcuno che ha fatto la transizione o la detransizione. Ho scritto di vergogna e fantasia sessuale come motori dell’identificazione trans maschile, della mia difficile adolescenza, di anni di terapia benefica e di mia madre, una lesbica butch. Ho opinioni critiche sull’attivismo trans e sul genere come concetto, pur sostenendo il benessere dei detransitioner. Alla fine ho cancellato i miei post e ho smesso di partecipare al sub. Non mi identifico come persona che ha fatto detransizione, desistenza o come trans.

Storia completa

I am a gay man who came to the r/detrans community as an observer and commenter rather than as someone who transitioned or is questioning transition. My first post on the sub, in November 2022, was a cliche observation that there had been a 'glorious moment when homophobia had abated and before gender ideology took hold where you could be an individual' without labeling yourself, and I felt the last six years or so had not been an improvement. I deleted that post after rereading the rules, since I was not detransitioning or questioning transition and did not want to take space from detransitioners. I have written at length about what I see as the sexual dimension of trans identification among men. I believe part of why men detransition or desist is shame: the realization that 'there was a powerful sexual fantasy element to the desire to be trans,' which is embarrassing to admit when you have changed your whole life because of it. I have argued that the uptick in trans identification among men is partly a dis-regulation of men's sexual expression through porn, kink, and app culture, and that it is destructive that men who become compulsive or obsessive are told this is an identity to take up. I have also written about how the sex-positive movement curdled from a useful tool for destigmatizing sex into an ideology where you cannot discuss compulsion, fetishes, or harmful behavior without being accused of kink-shaming. I have been open about my own psychological history. I wrote a long post in November 2022 that was the first time I had ever put certain behaviors and thoughts in writing; I was surprised how hard it was to give a psychological account, and I said I 'still hold the memories of the person who did those things. What's left of them. But I no longer understand that person's thinking.' I have described puberty as 'a form of psychosis' and said puberty made me 'practically psychotic.' I have also referred to 'running into the wall (i've been there)' as something that should be considered an immense gift. I have discussed my mother, describing her as a butch lesbian and saying it has been heartbreaking to see the disappearance of butch lesbians in young millennials and zoomers. I have said I have had years of therapy, that I am still a big believer in it, and that I am grateful to every therapist I have had, though I think each could have put exercise on the agenda. About nine months before March 2023 I started with a personal trainer; in our first session he pushed me to the point of feeling ill, and my first instinct was to feel offended, outraged and invalidated, which I recognized as having 'caught the zoomer disease.' I now believe strongly in being the master of one's own mind and exercising tolerance for low-level discomfort to build resilience. I have written extensively about trans activism, arguing it is unusually toxic because the obsession with passing drives a demand for institutional support — HRT, surgeries, legal sex designation, changing language — to create a society where sex assigned at birth is undetectable. I have called this regressive because it requires medicalization and maintenance of gender stereotypes. I have also argued that 'gender' is not a particularly useful concept and that gendered thinking is a regressive way of thinking about everyday life. I have expressed sympathy for liberals caught between Trump populism and social media pressure, praised J.K. Rowling as a rare figure of standing who emphasizes that detransitioners are not pieces to be deployed in an ideological game, and supported super-strict moderation of r/detrans as an emotional support space first and debate second. I have engaged with discussions of mass violence, arguing against rationalizing mass shootings and cautioning against drawing quick conclusions about the Nashville shooting, while noting the 'we're being genocided' rhetoric worsens mental health in vulnerable people. I have discussed autogynephilia as a well-established phenomenon with DSM entry versus autoandrophilia, which lacks one, and I have commented on autism and gender dysphoria, noting that dysphoria in undiagnosed autistic people should be treated with their autism taken into account. By April 2023 I had deleted the last several posts I made on the sub and said I did not think I would be able to participate on the forum anymore, while insisting it was not a plea for change. I have never described transitioning, detransitioning, hormone use, or surgery as my own experience in this transcript.