Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition (nato maschio) e che si pente delle scelte mediche fatte mentre esploravo un'identità di genere fluttuante guidata da AGP, autismo e instabilità emotiva. Ho preso estrogeni a intermittenza dai miei primi trent'anni fino ai 40, mi è cresciuto un seno piccolo, ho fatto una vasta depilazione laser di cui ora mi pento e ho fatto qualche intervento al viso. Ho smesso gli estrogeni all'inizio del 2024, ho vissuto un'astinenza difficile e un peggioramento della depressione, e ho chiesto una consulenza per la top surgery rifiutando la doppia incisione consigliata. Ora mi identifico fermamente come uomo, definisco il sesso immutabile e sono critico verso la transizione, soprattutto per i giovani, mentre lavoro con uno stipendio a sei cifre, sono sposato da 10 anni e aspetto un figlio. Brevemente, a marzo 2024, durante un conflitto online, ho espresso pensieri suicidi, ma più tardi ho detto di non aver mai davvero pensato di farla finita e di stare bene.
Storia completa
I was born male and I have always identified as a man — I never considered myself trans in the sense of changing sex, because I don't believe anyone can change their sex or gender. What I did do, however, was start taking estrogen in my early 30s for about a year, then stopped. That first round gave me some breast growth. At 36 I resumed estrogen intermittently until I was 40, occasionally using testosterone gel as well, while consistently working out to maintain muscle mass. I'm now nearly 40.
The core driver for me was AGP — autogynephilia. I am a heterosexual male who is aroused by the fantasy of being female, and it took me a long time to admit that publicly. I was embarrassed for years and thought I'd go to the grave with that shame. I didn't even know AGP was a thing until I read about it. I now wish I had kept it as a silly fantasy instead of letting it creep into my life — it led me down a terrible path. I've also dealt with autism, ego, and emotional fluctuations, which have left me feeling isolated even though I've been married for about 10 years.
My gender identity has been a constant source of internal debate, fluctuating between nonbinary, transgender feminine, transgender masculine, and other possibilities. That indecision manifested in concrete medical actions: I underwent facial laser hair removal on my cheeks, under toward the neck, butt, stomach, arms, and about two leg sessions, and later felt despondent about my inability to grow facial hair back. I treated my chest, hands, feet, and legs as well, and now feel a sense of loss about the body hair I never wanted growing up but whose absence now leaves me feeling incomplete. I'm contemplating beard implants but am waiting to see if resuming testosterone might improve the patchy growth. I had some facial feminization surgery — specifically nose and chin work to get rid of a strong dimple — done in what was framed as a 'nonbinary way,' so in some sense it didn't feminize me, just gave me plastic surgery I wanted anyway. At first I felt great, but then I got depressed because it wasn't enough; I kept chasing more and more but never being happy.
On hormones, I went from 205 lbs with an 80 lb bench press on testosterone to 150 lbs with a 130 lb bench press on estrogen — whoever says you can get ripped and big on E doesn't know what they're talking about. I worked out my pecs hardcore the entire time, running and working out almost daily while on estrogen. I stopped estrogen cold turkey about two weeks before I posted about it in late February 2024, and I felt incredibly sick — vomiting at work, wild emotions, and worsening depression. I wasn't sure if that was withdrawal, flu, or COVID. I also developed what I describe as 'moobs' — small breasts, roughly an A cup, enough that I can run without support but noticeable with my shirt off. I have no chest hair.
I've been in a transmasc support group — they let me in as a 'transmasc AMAB person,' though I'm not sure if I'm trans or what. My stance on gender is critical: I believe in the immutability of biological sex and the significance of sex assigned at birth, and I define a woman as an adult human female with XX chromosomes. These views have estranged me from the transgender community and led others to compare me to cisgender people. I feel alienated from a community that, in my view, sometimes seems detached from reality, particularly regarding the implications of hormone therapy. I've unfairly directed frustration at FtM individuals without holding myself accountable.
I pursued top surgery consultation in early 2024. The surgeon recommended double incision, which disheartened me — my breasts are small enough to run long distances without support, and the whole point was to feel confident at the beach without a shirt. Massive DI scars would be ugly and a lasting reminder of 'this trans BS.' I emailed asking whether keyhole with revision could be an option, and I do not want my nipples touched — the surgeon suggested I might not want them because 'they aren't functional for males,' which horrified me. I'm also considering a tummy tuck unrelated to transness, since I lost a lot of weight and will never have abs because of extra skin, though that would also need a scar across the belly. I got the top surgery scheduled eventually.
On the mental health side, I've struggled with depression that seems to be getting stronger. I work remote, so it's often just me alone in a circle of thoughts. I've started with a new therapist and tried hard to find an in-person support group because I can't focus online. In early March 2024 I posted a vent about feeling like no one cared and made comments about 'unalliving' myself and 'maybe I'll have better luck in the next life,' though I later said I'd never actually considered ending things and that I'm actually doing great now. I've been told I'm direct and sometimes unkind in comments, and I said I might stop commenting because of how people respond to me.
I've found some things that helped: running, eating right, working on my relationship with my spouse, and looking at male people I wanted to emulate instead of always looking at women. I also tried to appreciate the positives — I'm 5'11", thin with muscles, and I figured I'd have it better than any FtM and most men. My spouse likes my facial hair, and we've worked through days when I feel more feminine; I've accepted that I'm the man in the relationship but that it's a team effort. Most of my friends are cis men and women — I found them through shared activities and Bumble BFF. I work a six-figure job at a big company (I mentioned getting a raise to $200k) and have a kid on the way as of March 2024.
I regret my medical choices. I mourn the pre-transition me. I now think detransition for me meant realizing it's okay to be male — I was always a man regardless of how I presented. I still struggle, but I've accepted that I would never literally be female. I'm critical of transition for others, particularly young people: I think doctors need to be sued for giving this much surgery to girls under 18, and I believe hugboxing and positivity push a fantasy along until people are in their 30s with no career, no education, and health conditions. I think trans is a choice in the sense that you can choose not to transition, and that sex is immutable. I comment online mainly to try to help other people reach a good place, while acknowledging I can be blunt and hurtful.