Tutte le storie

La disforia andrebbe trattata come l'anoressia, non con la chirurgia

Femmina · Desistito/a134
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition e ho usato questa piattaforma per sostenere che la disforia di genere dovrebbe essere trattata a livello psicologico, come l'anoressia, con una terapia a lungo termine e l'accettazione del corpo anziché con ormoni e interventi. Credo che la transizione venga presentata troppo facilmente come una cura universale, che il filtro medico sia giustificato dagli effetti permanenti e irreversibili di ormoni e SRS, e che sessualità e identità di genere vengano confuse a torto. Ho esortato i giovani che si interrogano sulla transizione a uscire dalla «bolla del genere», a esplorare problemi di fondo come omofobia, ruoli di genere e traumi passati, e a prendersi molti anni prima di decisioni permanenti. Non mi oppongo alla transizione in assoluto: ho detto che, se una persona è sicura, può essere giusta per lei; ma sostengo con forza il provare prima l'accettazione del corpo e l'estrema cautela con la SRS. In questi post non ho descritto alcuna transizione medica personale, intervento chirurgico o crisi di salute mentale.

Storia completa

I have never spoken publicly about a personal transition of my own; what I have shared on this platform is a set of arguments and reflections about dysphoria, body image, and medical treatment, written largely in response to other people's questions and posts. The central thread of my thinking began with a post I made in May 2020 asking what the difference is between anorexia and dysphoria. I laid out the parallel as I saw it: anorexia is primarily psychological, about feelings toward the body and control, and its treatment is therapy to help the person accept their body, explore the underlying reasons for their feelings, and manage the condition for life. Many anorexic people return to a healthy weight and feel happier about their bodies than they did at the height of the illness. I then asked why dysphoria, which I described as a similar 'uncomfortableness with the body, self esteem issues and potentially underlying issues regarding gender, sex, relationships etc,' is treated by changing the body rather than by encouraging body acceptance. My TLDR was blunt: 'Why treat one psychologically and the other physically?' In the discussion that followed, I pressed the question further. I asked why physical transition is 'so common (and even accepted by doctors) as treatment,' and I acknowledged that I understood why trans people would want to transition, comparing it to an anorexic person wanting to keep restricting. But I argued that there is a point where an anorexic might realise the behaviour is harmful, seek medical support, and be psychologically supported, whereas a trans person who seeks support is 'often pushed into the transitioning instead.' I said I felt medical professionals were doing trans people a disservice and that there should be a greater focus on therapy and recognising underlying issues. I questioned why long-term therapy should not be the standard treatment rather than therapy used only to gain access to hormones, and I said hormone therapy 'shouldn't be standard.' I did hold a genuine worry on the other side: whether withholding hormones and surgery and 'forcing' trans people to accept their biological sex would be on par with conversion therapy for homosexual individuals. But my stated gut feeling was that 'gender dysphoria is more on par with mental illness just like anorexia and should be completely separated from sexuality.' I developed the analogy in detail. I argued that just as an anorexic says 'I just am' fat, a dysphoric person says they are simply a woman, but 'your biological body is not. There's a disconnect so just like an anorexics body is not thin enough. Yours is not feminine enough.' I advocated therapy as a first-choice treatment, an 'long and arduous process' of coming to terms with the body as it is. Against that I set the risks of the hormone route and SRS: 'Risks and complications of surgery's, long term risks of hormones, infertility, long term making the surgery work. Causing damage to a perfectly healthy body. It's no different than an anorexics body weight becoming extremely low.' When challenged, I pushed back hard. I argued that transition has not been proven effective, citing detransition, suicide after transitioning, regret after SRS and its complications, and people who transition but still have negative feelings and poor mental health. I defended gatekeeping on the grounds that these drugs and surgeries cause 'permanent and irreversible changes to the body,' have many side effects, and can affect fertility, so starting hormones 'shouldn't be taken with a pinch of salt.' I gave a concrete example: a cis friend needed accutane for severe acne and it took over six years to be allowed the drug because of its dangerous side effects, having to try every other ineffective treatment first. I said studies had not been done into detransition and that 'this group alone refutes that,' and that suicide rates are higher than in other groups, so I would hardly call transition '100% effective.' I was explicit that my position was not conversion therapy: 'You can still feel sexual desire for whatever sex you want. Sexuality and gender identity should not be confused,' and 'You can still identify/dress as whatever sex you want.' What I proposed was long-term therapy with a view to accepting the body and making peace with it, rather than what I called the physical harm of hormones and SRS. I also raised the number of trans people who have experienced sexual assault in their past as something therapy should explore, and argued therapy should be 'long long term with hormones not mixed in with therapy,' not gender-affirming therapy used as 'a hoop to jump through to gain hormones.' I was critical of how therapy is actually conducted in the trans community, saying there are 'so many posts in the online trans community on what not to say and what to say to the therapist so a letter of recommendation is granted,' and that it is not viewed as a way to work through psychological issues or underlying issues such as sexual abuse, growing up and family, or past bullying. I countered the argument that you can't talk away hatred of your genitals by saying that if that were true, you couldn't talk away an anorexic's feeling that their body is 'fat and disgusting' — but you can, though 'It's not a magical immediate cure and involves unpacking a lot of other issues.' I also listed specific medical harms I was concerned about: multiple surgeries and complications from surgery and anaesthesia; MTF bottom surgery requiring years of maintenance afterwards with sensitivity potentially lost when the previous genitalia were 'functional and healthy'; and HRT that can cause infertility, hair loss, and osteoporosis, among other 'permanent and irreversible effects.' On children and young adults I was firm: 'Especially for children who aren't in a position to make these decisions. There's a reason drinking, voting age etc are what they are.' I also argued that 'young adults/children often there's a lot of other things going on that also need addressing that simply changing bodies can't.' In June 2020 I responded to a 19-year-old who was questioning whether they would regret transitioning. I told them that the very fact they were asking the question was 'both good and potentially revealing,' and that they did not need to hit a list of criteria to regret or not regret a decision. I encouraged them to explore the reasons they were transitioning: 'Is it because of homophobia, is it because of gender roles in society, is it because of intense discomfort with your body? Could you accept yourself as you are? What do you hope to achieve with taking hormones? Do you want children in the future? Are you prepared for the side effects?' I expressed worry about how much trans communities 'push' people down the need-to-transition route and make transition seem like 'a magical cure all for all lives problems,' and I advised spending time away from what I called 'the almost cultish rethoric of the trans communities' before making a big decision, focusing instead on hobbies, in-person relationships, interests, and exercise, and getting out of the 'gender bubble.' I told them 19 was 'still very young' and suggested considering waiting until 21 or even 25 to mature and grow first. I expanded on body acceptance in a later reply, saying most cis as well as trans people have things they hate about themselves, pointing to the rise in plastic surgery and the billion-dollar cosmetic industry, skin whitening creams, fake tan, and hair straightening or curling. I said it is normal for anyone to have things they dislike about themselves, and that some people need only a single surgery or cosmetic change while others chase impossible perfection and are still never happy. I suggested seeing yourself from others' perspectives, as you would a friend insistent on a boob job when you can't see anything wrong with her, and being kind to yourself by asking whether you would talk about a friend the way you talk about yourself. I described the body as 'amazing, functioning, healthy' and asked whether focusing on what it does for you rather than what you hate would change how you feel, comparing it to recovering anorexic people learning not to see themselves as fat. I also raised what I said came out of detrans experiences: 'conflating sex with masculinity or femininity.' I asked whether the person could be happy still being male but embracing the feminine aspects of themselves, and said 'There's no right and wrong way to be a man.' I asked how they envisaged themselves in the future — in relationships, as a dad or a mother, and what they would be when old and physical appearance is lost regardless of gender, and whether they were prepared to become what it means to be a woman in general society. I was careful not to present myself as having the answers: 'It's a lot of questions and again I don't have the answers but I do think self exploration is worthwhile.' In my final reply I advised trying different things out and researching, noting that thinking you want something is often different to reality, using the analogy of wanting to switch houses without having tried decorating. I said that if they were sure they wanted to transition maybe it was something they should do and hopefully it would help them, but again urged them to research the permanent effects 'just in case you did ever want to detransition.' I ended by 'pretty much begging' them to take a lot, lot, lot longer for SRS if that was ever a path they considered, to read stories of complications, and to have realistic expectations of results and of what the process entails. Alongside these debates I also offered practical psychological advice in a separate comment, suggesting focusing on the positive rather than the negative through mental tricks to give perspective: identifying something you like every day, ideally linked to health or ability (for example, liking that you can run fast because of your legs), then moving on to features, to focus on the good rather than the things you don't like. I contrasted the feeling of thinking 'I'm so lucky I have so and so as a friend' with 'I hate ...' I also suggested that when in a 'beat yourself up I hate myself' mood you should ask whether you would speak about a friend that way, and that you should think about what you notice about other people — a workmate, friend, or family member — and what features come to mind, to realise that no one else is thinking the things you think about yourself and that no one notices nor does it matter to them. Finally I advised exploring what is making you feel this way, maybe going to therapy if possible, but not overthinking because 'it's easy to get sucked into this world and gender be all consuming and forget the rest of life exists,' and finding other interests, activities, groups, aspects to your identity, and things you are passionate about. Throughout, my consistent position was that therapy and body acceptance should come first, that hormones and surgery carry irreversible risks that are underplayed, that sexuality and gender identity should be kept separate, and that young people in particular should take much more time before making permanent decisions.