Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una ragazza che ha fatto detransizione: mi sono identificata come trans dai 13 anni, dopo essere entrata nella comunità trans a 11, e a 15 anni ho iniziato il testosterone ma ho fatto una sola iniezione prima di desistere. Quella singola iniezione, insieme al binder che mi faceva male, alla mancanza di amici e al fatto di aver superato la mia disforia, è stata il mio punto di svolta, soprattutto dopo che un'infermiera mi aveva messo pressione con «tu lo vuoi». Rimpiango di aver perso un anno di scuola pubblica per passare alla scuola online, di aver perso i miei giocattoli d'infanzia e le mie cose femminili e il tempo passato a identificarmi come trans, anche se sono tornata al mio nome di nascita. Ora ho 15 anni, sto ancora detransizionando gradualmente e ho opinioni fortemente critiche sulla transizione medica per i minori e sul modo in cui l'industria medica tratta i bambini.
Storia completa
I first got into the trans community around age 11, and it only worsened once COVID hit. I started identifying as trans at age 13. Because my "dysphoria" felt so bad, I insisted on doing online school again and missed out on a whole year of public school because I simply hated my body — something most children go through. That's one of my only true regrets: I never got to say goodbye to my friends who went to a different high school.
I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria from a single online therapist appointment that didn't even last an hour. I now think gender dysphoria has such vague criteria that it could easily be diagnosed as something else, and that discomfort with your body and gender roles is normal — I have never met someone who was comfortable with themselves throughout their entire childhood. I also think the criteria for being trans is vague: "You need dysphoria to be trans," but what does that look like? I've been trying to refer to trans people as "currently trans," especially those who are 18 and younger.
I began testosterone at age 15 but only took one shot, and that's what prompted me to desist. There were other reasons as well, but the shot was my turning point — I think it was a combination of my binder starting to hurt me more than usual, my lack of friends, and generally growing out of my gender dysphoria. The things that always stood out to me, though, was how the nurse spoke to me. She would constantly say "You want this." or "This will help you." It made me realize that the shot was indeed not what I wanted.
I also thought testosterone would make me taller — it was a large reason as to why I started — but there's no evidence that supports that, and in fact there's a chance that testosterone can stunt your growth. It's really scary to think about what could have happened if I didn't snap out of it; my mom was 100% for me transitioning. I also remember my endocrinologist saying that out of her 10,000 patients, only two had stopped taking HRT, and I didn't believe that for a second.
I went back to my birth name. It's just a name and doesn't define who I am, plus I'd still like to respect my parents and heritage, even if they contributed to my transition. In the time that I was trans I was determined to get rid of anything feminine, so all of my childhood toys are gone, and all of my jewelry and makeup. Now I have to buy new underwear and bras, along with an entire wardrobe. I know most kids go through something similar but it still hurts because I have something to blame it on. It feels like the real me was locked away while someone else inhabited my body. There are also items I have no memory of getting rid of because I can't understand why I would do that in the first place, though I think a positive that comes out of it is appreciating what you still have — I'm so thankful for the things that weren't discarded.
I'm now 15 and still gradually detransitioning. It sucks, but you have to remember that adolescence is only a fraction of your life and you have so many more experiences to come. I was just crying over losing my old things not too long ago.
I hold strong views about medical transition for minors: children transitioning was not a thing even 10 years ago, it's disgusting that this was ever allowed to happen. Absolutely no one knows who they are at 15 — at least tattoos and piercings are somewhat reversible, but you cannot reverse medical transition. I hope I can see it restricted nationwide during my lifetime. I think it's vile what the medical industry is doing to children, and I fully believe that the people involved in doing this to a particular girl should be put behind bars; it's also disgusting that some people are blaming her, a child, for what happened. If someone has any doubt at all, I tell them not to go through with surgery or hormones — you can always resume taking hormones, but your voice will never go back if you regret it.
As a detrans female, I don't agree that being female is inherently oppressive — there's an equal amount of disadvantages that come with being a male, and it's not fun to be considered the oppressed sex. I don't believe being a man means your life will inevitably be easier, and I don't believe little girls need to be told that their life will be horrible because they're girls. Men make up the large majority of homeless individuals, they're more likely to commit suicide, and if a man and woman both commit the same crime, chances are the man will be granted a longer sentence. In general, women are valued more in western society, while a man can easily be replaced. However, I acknowledge women have it harder worldwide, and my heart goes out to all women who have to live in countries such as Pakistan or India.
I also think there are great things about being a woman: you're overall treated better by society, there are less expectations for women compared to men, you have an advantage when it comes to the courts and legal system, and we're literally the sex that creates life. I believe tomboys get more criticism than feminine men, likely because there's no "gay best friend" equivalent for masculine women, and there's an overarching association between masculine women and "she's just trying to escape her womanhood/femininity."
I hold critical views of trans identity claims: trans women aren't women — the word trans is there for a reason. I also think neopronouns make zero sense grammatically: you don't get your own pronouns, they're assigned based on your appearance, it's the equivalent of asking "What are your adjectives?" I've told people that if they told me they were a natal female I wouldn't question them, and that even if you realize transitioning wasn't right for you, it doesn't mean you were never trans. I also believe there's a difference between fair discrimination (like not hiring someone who isn't strong enough for the job) and unfair discrimination based on irrelevant characteristics such as race, sex, or identity.