Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nato maschio, ho fatto la transizione come transfem e ho fatto la detransizione dopo che gli ormoni hanno scatenato convulsioni e ansia, la perdita del lavoro e della patente, e dopo aver accettato che volevo vivere una gravidanza, cosa che la transizione non può darmi. Al momento sono non binario, sto ancora capendo se la transizione fosse giusta per me e la considero il peggior errore della mia vita, restando aperto al fatto che per altri possa essere giusta. Perdere la famiglia e metà degli amici quando ho parlato di detransizione è stato devastante, e per questo mi sono ritirato dagli spazi della comunità trans. La disforia di genere a volte torna, ma l'esercizio, l'allenamento per un triathlon, la spiritualità/taoismo e una cerchia che mi sostiene mi hanno aiutato. Fisicamente devo fare i conti con una ginecomastia residua dovuta alla terapia ormonale e con l'inversione della depilazione laser, anche se la fertilità è tornata nel giro di un anno.
Storia completa
I was born male, and I'm 27 as of early 2024 (my February 2024 post stating "I'm 27, transfem" puts my birth year around 1996-1997). I was raised Catholic and, looking back, part of my own story was that "Part of me thought I would fit in better with my Catholic upbringings, Had I just been born female."
As a child my pediatrician decided I was "unacceptably too short," so I was put on growth hormones. That flooded my body with testosterone as a shot to the pituitary gland to compensate for starting puberty two years late. I was an extremely angry teen, and I've wondered how much the rapid masculinization contributed to wanting to be transfem — though I also note "it did before that. It felt wrong after in different ways." I also had a medical basis for gender non-congruency before I even knew what trans was: a brain scan showed "odd" grey matter patterns, and hormones at puberty started spiking progesterone. Despite that, I've been called a "trans medicalist" bigot by others in the community.
I transitioned as a transfem. I was on "white market E" (estrogen obtained outside official channels) for about 14 to 16 months — I've given slightly different figures, saying 14 months in one comment, "about 16 months" in another, "a year and a half of hrt" in another, and "after just under a year on hormones" when describing the onset of seizures. I did voice training while transitioning, using a sing-song "gay" voice to raise pitch, and within two years I was "passing pretty well." I also had laser hair removal on my chin while medicated.
Things went medically badly. Hormones increased my anxiety to the point I started having seizures after about a year on them. Doctors suspect the hormones caused the seizures. The seizures cost me my driver's license and my job, "and the next 3 after that." I stopped hormones for medical reasons. Within a few months of stopping, erections and body hair came back, including the chin hair I'd lasered while medicated. My fertility returned within a year of stopping.
I detransitioned. The decision crystallized through a long talk with myself — "a really long talk with myself in the mirror so to speak" — asking whether this was worth it, "Trading one charade for another?" The answer was no. A central reason was that I wanted to be a mother, to experience pregnancy, and "there is NOTHING in the trans process that can grant that. I have to let it go." My recurrent dreams of being a pregnant new mom-to-be had been one of the driving factors behind my gender dysphoria diagnosis. I also said "One of the reasons I detransitioned was because I know the technology just doesn't exist."
I had been questioning detransition for a while before the break. Those doubts "were kept at bay by the 'support' I had found in many online communities." What pushed me over the edge was getting permanently banned from r/trans in February 2024 — first for following r/detrans, then for defending a 17-year-old who was considering detransition. The moderator response, and the vindictiveness of it, made me realize that the support "was an absolute lie." I described the community as "vindictive, absolutist, and cruel" and compared them to "siths dealing in absolutes" and inquisitors.
The social fallout was severe. When I mentioned I was considering detransition, "half my friends turned on me like rabid animals." When I said doctors suspected hormones caused my seizures and I was considering detransition, my family "cut contact." At Miami Beach pride, one activist called me a "traitor to the cause" and told me to "join the Jesus freaks across the street and gtfo our pride." I've said "100% of trans activists I've had the displeasure of dealing with have turned on me" once they learn I'm non-binary, stopped hormones, and am still figuring things out, or simply that I'm not an activist. I concluded that staying in trans spaces was "a net negative."
I took a sabbatical trying to live as a cis man again. I currently identify as non-binary and am still figuring out whether transition was right for me. I'm 5'5" and before losing weight I "looked like a dwarf" next to most of my guy friends. I've described my ongoing gender state as "a mess," and I've said "If I could press a button and be biologically female I would in a heartbeat. I do NOT want to be trans." I've also said I'd rather "silently be trapped in a male body doing my best rather than be a part of the hyper politicized culture that is the trans community today."
I reject the AGP framing outright: "at no point in my entire life was the thought of being a woman sexually arousing. On the contrary, I wish I was just content as Cis, but I'm not." I called the assumption "disgustingly reductive."
On the physical side, I developed noticeable chest growth on estrogen — I reached a mid-B cup while weighing 220 lbs. After detransition I lost 40 lbs (I've also said 25 lbs at one point), put on muscle, but the glandular tissue from HRT remains and is "the bane of my existence." It looks like "puffy nipple mini A cups just pasted onto a broad chest." I had an embarrassing moment at the beach where a friend said "oh wait you got TITTY titty." I'm also trying to undo the laser hair removal and hope to one day grow a full beard. As a coincidence, because laser targets visible follicles and hormones had thinned my hair, I got a lot more hair growth once I stopped hormones.
Mentally, gender dysphoria "still hits sometimes." What's helped: exercising, training for my first triathlon, losing weight, surrounding myself with people "NOT obsessed with the alphabet mafia," going back to church, studying spirituality and philosophy (I consider myself a Taoist), and staying away from politics. I've been invited to MENSA but call myself "one of the dumbest people I know." I have a wife — I've joked about someday wanting to "get into bed with my wife and swap places" via future technology. I live in Florida (my "home state of FL"). I wear vests, glasses, and hats as "a suit of armor," partly because the vests flatten my chest; people now recognize me by the hat. I'm saving for a steel-boned male corset vest.
I now think transition was "the worst choice I ever made" and "Dumbest mistake ive ever made" for me, while still believing people who transition can be valid and people who detransition are valid too — I've cited Blaire White's point that for some it's a life improvement, for others detransition is. I'm critical of WPATH ("About time someone went on the WARPATH against WPATH") and skeptical of low detransition statistics. I've also speculated hopefully that brain-computer interface tech might one day give people what they're looking for and "potentially save millions from falling into the trans trap." I haven't described formal advocacy, but I've defended detransitioners publicly and pushed back on the community's orthodoxy, which is what got me banned.