Tutte le storie

Una fase su Tumblr, poi anni di dubbi, senza alcun passo medico

Femmina · Desistito/a279
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha desistito e fatto detransition: nata femmina, mai transitata dal punto di vista medico, che si poneva domande sul genere già prima del 2021 e che ha avuto una «fase radfem su Tumblr durata mesi, proprio prima di iniziare la transizione». Non credo più agli schemi identitari trans o non binari e mi descrivo semplicemente come «una femmina / donna in senso biologico», che rifiuta sia la femminilità sia la mascolinità con cui mi sento a disagio. Sono critica verso la transizione e spesso spingo chi ci sta pensando a confrontarsi con l'invecchiamento, il passing e le conseguenze a lungo termine. Non ho interventi medici, rimpianti per chirurgia od ormoni o crisi di salute mentale da raccontare. Resto solidale e amichevole con chi ha fatto detransition e con chi ha desistito.

Storia completa

I was born female, and I've never really had a dramatic story to tell about it — no surgeries, no hormones, no formal transition. What I did have was a period where I seriously questioned all of that, and I've spent the years since thinking hard about it. Back in 2019 I was reading up on differences of sex development — androgen insensitivity syndrome, congenital adrenal hyperplasia — trying to understand how sex actually works biologically. That kind of reading shaped how I think about the topic to this day. By December 2021 I was already skeptical of certain claims I'd seen online, replying flatly that something was 'impossible, unless you include MTF lesbians and lesbians who date MTF.' A few days later I admitted to having had 'a months-long tumblr radfem phase right before transitioning' — that's the closest I've come to naming a timeline for my own questioning. Someone asked me to expand on it and I never did in this record. In early 2022 I was spending a lot of time in threads with people who were considering transition, and I found myself pushing back on them rather than encouraging them. I asked one person their age, and then asked a question I clearly thought was important: what do you plan to do when you're in your 50s or 60s, when the probability is you'll be less attractive than you are now? I told another person directly that they seemed very concerned about how other people perceive them, that unless they had money or already had a very stereotypically feminine face and body they probably wouldn't pass 100%, and I pressed them with a series of questions: can you imagine going on dates as a trans woman? Getting married? Having children? Do you imagine yourself in your 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s as a trans woman? Are you ready for that age not to pass as a woman? I wasn't cruel about it, but I was blunt. I also asked pointed questions about identity itself — 'how does a lesbian feel like?', 'how does a transgender person feel?' — because I genuinely don't think feelings are a reliable guide to these categories. On clothes I was consistent: there are no women's clothes or men's clothes, just clothes stereotypically worn by one or the other, and everyone should dress however they want. But I kept pushing people to examine why they feel comfortable a certain way. By August 2022 I said it plainly: 'no, i dont belive in trans stuff or nonbinary anymore.' I added that I'd still be friends with AFAB people who are 'in this thing,' but that I wouldn't date them, comparing it to not dating a hardcore religious person who doesn't share my important values. I told one commenter their comment was misogynistic, that transitioning to a girl won't get them what they think it will, and that they seemed to notice the abuse women suffer and were trying to avoid it — 'but you dont need to avoid anything since you are amab.' In October 2022 I described where I've landed: 'I don't have one, I'm just a female / woman in the bio sense, I don't engage on the parts of feminity that make me uncomfortable, the same with masculinity.' That's really my position — I don't perform femininity I dislike, and I don't perform masculinity either. I'm just female. In January 2023 I explicitly identified myself: 'i m a desister so my opinion may not be what you are looking for.' I talked about how some detransitioners seem to want to compensate for masculine characteristics they got from testosterone or surgery with a more stereotypically feminine way of dressing, acting, and living — especially new detrans or desister people — and that they don't want to be confused with men or trans people. I said it's hard to find a balance between dressing the way you want and being perceived as a woman, that it's a balancing act, and that people who detransition now aren't the same as people who detransitioned 10 years ago. In February 2024 I said nonbinary is 'someone who does not identify as exclusively a man or a woman' but added that personally I don't believe in 'identifying' with anything, so the concept is useless to me. I told someone else that while I saw where they were coming from, my conclusion was different: I don't want to be put in 'the other category' when my feelings are common and usual for a female living in a sexist world, and I think the group will be better off in the long term getting rid of the boxes altogether — though as an individual you should always do what's best for you. I've also been supportive when it seemed warranted — telling someone their face just looked more adult-like after losing baby fat, and in September 2025 telling a detransitioned woman that if I saw her I'd do a double take 'not because you look like a guy, but because you are a one gorgeus woman,' and suggesting voice training if her voice was the issue. I don't have a story of medical intervention or regret because I never medically transitioned. What I have is a questioning period before 2021, a 'radfem phase' on Tumblr, and a slow arrival at a position I hold now: I'm a female woman who doesn't believe in gender identity as a framework, who is critical of transition as it's currently offered, and who still treats detransitioners and desisters with warmth.