Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition (nata femmina in Germania), che si è identificata come ragazzo trans dai 18 ai 20 anni circa ma non ha mai fatto una transizione medica. A 18 anni ho subito un trauma sessuale che ha peggiorato la mia disforia di genere, e più tardi ho capito che cercavo di proteggermi dagli uomini diventando uno di loro. Ho desistito verso la metà del 2019 dopo aver trovato risorse sulla detransition come il Pique Resilience Project, grazie ai dubbi di mia mamma e all'esplorazione di altre cause della disforia, tra cui un possibile autismo. Dopo aver smesso di usare il binder mi è venuto un disturbo alimentare (restrizione sotto le 1000 kcal al giorno più corsa), e ho avuto anche depressione, ansia, attacchi di panico e problemi di immagine corporea. Verso metà 2020 la mia disforia era migliorata molto, facevo terapia, i rapporti con la mia famiglia si erano ricuciti e ormai non penso praticamente mai al mio genere; continuo a sostenere la transizione per alcune persone, ma nel complesso sono più scettica.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in Germany. My gender questioning started around age 14 when puberty began — I felt my body changing and didn't connect with the other girls, and I concluded I just wasn't one. I found out being trans was a thing at 16 through short films on the topic, repressed those thoughts, went abroad for a year, cut my hair short at 18, and then it 'clicked' and I started identifying as a trans guy. I identified as a trans guy for about 1.5 to 2 years (roughly ages 18 to 20).
Around age 18 I experienced sexual trauma, which made my dysphoria much worse — I later realized I was denying and repressing my female body and identity to distance myself from the trauma, essentially trying to protect myself from men by becoming one. I started binding and it felt liberating; I started passing as male to strangers, was male online, and visited LGBT youth groups where I was male. All of it felt good and I got positive feedback I'd never had before, which improved my self-worth. Before I had a binder I used two sports bras (one size too small, one worn backwards) or ace bandages, which caused bad back pain. I later got a gc2b binder and wore it for almost two years, often more than 8 hours a day.
I never came out publicly. I told my parents I was questioning — they were unaccepting and we stopped talking for a while, and I felt suicidal during that period. I also told a few close friends (super supportive) and my therapist. My mum said something that got through to me: roughly 'you're my daughter, I've always felt when you were struggling, I usually knew before you did, and I'm sure this isn't right for you.' Because I knew she was right, I started doubting everything again. I later said I don't know where I'd be if my parents had been supportive — if I'd had access to hormones and a supporting family I'd probably be a bearded man by now. In Germany hormones and surgery are strictly regulated, so I couldn't just start medical transition. I never took hormones, never had surgery, and never had any medical professionals involved — just me and the internet.
Around April 2019 (age 20) I was still questioning and posted about not knowing who I am. YouTube had recommended detransitioned women's videos. In May 2019 I found the Pique Resilience Project and other detrans people, which shifted my perspective. I realized that having gender dysphoria doesn't mean you're trans or that transition would help. I said: 'I have gender dysphoria but that doesn't mean I'm trans or that transition would make me any less dysphoric.' I desisted from the trans identity around mid-2019 (I later said I stopped identifying as a trans man 9 months before March 2020, i.e. around June 2019).
The process of letting go was hard. I started by using gender-neutral vocabulary since German is heavily gendered, then slowly reintroduced words like woman, sister, daughter. I changed my pronouns and name online back to she/her and a gender-neutral name first. My male name Noah has faded and is just part of my past. Stopping binding was very hard — I'd gotten used to the pressure on my chest, my masculine reflection; it made me feel strong and brave, so identifying as a woman felt weak. I also stopped wearing my old underwear again, which felt like finally accepting I'm cis.
After I stopped binding I developed an eating disorder — I was restricting to under 1000 kcal a day and running 12km four times a week, with the thought that my chest would disappear if I didn't eat. I've struggled with disordered eating because of chest dysphoria and the thought that losing weight would shrink my chest. I also had body image issues, body dysmorphia, depression, anxiety, and panic attacks.
Things that helped: limiting internet/social media/YouTube use, getting outside, sports, reading, and pursuing other interests (photography, medicine, politics). I got back into track and field (which I'd done at a high level in high school), trained 4-5 times a week, and planned to run a marathon in October 2020. I joined a youth group of a political party, watched a series with my mum, took daily walks, and reread the Harry Potter books. I researched OCD and Asperger's to see if something else was causing my dysphoria. I'm not diagnosed but was on a waiting list and later in therapy, fairly confident I'd get an autism diagnosis; I believe I'm on the autism spectrum and highly functioning.
I also worked on my family relationships — my parents are likely on the spectrum too, and communication has gotten much better; I feel safe at home now. I experimented with clothes, borrowed my mum's and dad's clothes, and wore a skirt to my niece's birthday. I went back to the LGBT youth centre after distancing myself; I'd been going twice a week as a trans guy, stopped because I felt judged, then returned. I worried it triggered dysphoria because I was jealous of trans guys on testosterone or after top surgery, but the people there accepted me without labels.
By January 2020 (age 21, having just turned 21) I felt a lot of shame about ever having identified as trans: 'How was it possible for me to think I was a different gender? ... I feel really stupid.' I was also frustrated by being constantly misgendered as male now that I'd desisted, even though a year earlier I'd have been happy about it. I started therapy in January 2020 after a 6-month waiting list; previously I'd been in therapy for about half a year (every two weeks) which didn't help and the therapist basically threw me out.
By May 2020 I said my dysphoria (ages 14 to 21) had gotten a lot better in recent months — I'd actually accepted it might accompany me for life. For a while I thought I might still get top surgery while identifying as a woman, but those thoughts went away after a year. I now basically never think about my gender anymore.
On transition for others: I still believe some people need transition to be happy and I totally support trans people who want to transition, but I'm more skeptical now and more likely to think trans-identified people might detransition. I think there should be more gender-nonconforming people visible in media, that dysphoria has many causes that should be explored first, and that 'speaking to a counsellor two times and then getting hrt is really not a safe way to treat people with dysphoria.' I've given a lot of advice to parents of gender-questioning kids on Reddit, encouraging love, time, getting kids off the internet, and exploring alternatives. I don't think detransition should become a new identity or label to jump to.