Tutte le storie

Nove mesi di T, quattro anni di binding — e un caso di studio

Femmina · Detransizionato/aPrima disforia 14 → Transizione 18 → Detransizione 19252
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha detransizionato: mi sono identificata come trans per 5 anni, a 18 anni mi è stata diagnosticata la disforia di genere, ho preso testosterone per 9 mesi e ho usato il binder ogni giorno per 4 anni. A 19 anni, dopo un'esperienza terapeutica traumatica, ho capito di non essere trans, ho interrotto il T di colpo e da allora sono in terapia, che ha tenuto sotto controllo la mia disforia. Faccio risalire la mia disforia agli abusi sessuali subiti nell'infanzia e a un disturbo alimentare iniziato con la pubertà, e ora la gestisco vestendomi in modo mascolino e accettando il mio corpo invece di cambiarlo. La detransizione mi ha lasciato una voce permanentemente più bassa, peli sul viso persistenti, libido ridotta e problemi duraturi di respirazione e costole dovuti al binding, su cui ho lavorato con mia madre, fisioterapista, per arrivare a un caso di studio pubblicato. Resto critica verso il modo in cui la transizione mi è stata imposta da adolescente con una forte disforia, ma sostengo le persone trans in generale, e oggi mi definisco una donna bisessuale che ha detransizionato.

Storia completa

I was born female. I first felt a disconnect with my body around age 14, when people online and in real life explained what being trans was and it seemed to explain a lot of my feelings. Most of my friends at the time were also trans identified, and I felt accepted in that community. I identified as non-binary until I was 16, then began to identify as a trans man. I wanted to be sure my feelings were genuinely gender dysphoria before going further, and I trusted a therapist would be able to analyze me better than I could myself. I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria at age 18 by a "gender therapist" — he was a trans man and, in my view, biased — and I started testosterone right after. In total I was trans identified for 5 years. I wore a binder daily for 4 of those years. Before that I had been a competitive swimmer with great lung capacity. After binding I went to struggling to get deep breaths, having shortness of breath, greatly decreased lung capacity, and daily rib and back pain. I stopped using my binder over a year before writing about it and still experienced shortness of breath, trouble getting deep breaths, and rib pains; even wearing a bra made me feel like I couldn't breathe because I had used a binder for 4 years. I was on testosterone for 9 months. After about six months I started growing facial hair — I'm blonde so it was light, fairly thin, and not super noticeable; I shaved about twice a week. Over a year off T I still got facial hair but it came in much slower, only about once a month. My voice also didn't change back: over a year after stopping, my voice still sounded the same. I don't talk from the same place (talking from my mouth as opposed to my chest) though that only helped a little, and I still got called "sir" on the phone. I planned to look into voice training to try to get my voice back to how it was pre-T. I stopped T cold turkey after 9 months with very little noticeable negative effects, mostly just my hormones being imbalanced. My period came back after about a month and was back on track (it had been very consistent before HRT) after 5 months. I didn't do blood work at the time because I didn't have a doctor, though I acknowledged that would have been helpful. I had a very low libido before T, and it felt good to have a functioning libido while on it. Since stopping T I've had to accept a lower libido and that it's harder for me to get into a sexual headspace, and that's okay — losing my libido was a downside to detransitioning, but similarly to how it was a positive but not major factor in starting HRT. I was 19 when I realized I wasn't trans, after what I described as a horrible therapy experience. It punched me back into a reality I had never processed and made my panic disorder and PTSD unbearable, to the point where I didn't leave my house for months while still on HRT. When I started leaving the house again I was extremely uncomfortable passing as male, even though I had been passing in public for about 2 years. That made me rethink my whole identity, and I cold turkey stopped T. I then sought out a well-recommended, unbiased therapist for real psychological help, and I still saw her at the time of writing — over a year of therapy that had been extremely beneficial, with my dysphoria very much under control. I had been detransitioned for about a year by May 2019. I never posted on social media saying I was identifying as female again — I have severe anxiety and didn't see how drawing attention to my decision would benefit me. I just started posting more feminine pictures, and when I hung out with friends in person I would tell them; otherwise most people just caught the flow of things. Nobody has questioned my choice. My name is gender neutral, so I didn't change it back to my birth name — I've used my preferred name for over 4 years and everyone knows me by it. I didn't legally change my name; I use my preferred name socially and my birth name legally. I like my birth name but have always struggled to connect to it because people butcher it and often told me it was too girly for my personality. Everyone I've told has been accepting. I haven't told my trans friends why I detransitioned, nor have they asked. My mother is a physical therapist who was very against my transition for medical reasons; since detransitioning she's been extremely supportive and disappointed by the lack of research on female chest binding. My father's opinions were driven by religion. The religion I was raised in taught that being gay or any type of LGBT was a sin, and my parents believed that. When I came out as not being straight it ruined our relationship and I lost their support as a young teen, which is why I later dismissed their concerns about my being trans as religiously motivated. My identity was only questioned by my parents; everyone else in my life was supportive without concerns. I did research all the known effects of T before starting HRT, but noted we still don't know the long-term effects. I genuinely don't think anyone's opinion would have changed my mind besides the therapist I went to for help. If he had done his job properly and assessed why I was struggling with dysphoria and helped me figure out my root cause, I would never have been on HRT. All I got was a referral to an informed consent clinic because my dysphoria was so severe. I needed serious psychological help, not synthetic hormones that made me even more unstable. Because I was already unstable, I questioned how I was at 18 supposed to make an informed choice about the rest of my life — I wanted to kill myself, so I wasn't my best advocate, which is why I sought professional help. I was told the cure to my mental illness was transitioning, and I was sold that from age 13 by adults I looked up to. I've always been aware that gender dysphoria is a mental illness; I now say I needed psychological help, not hormones, and can say that now that I'm older and have figured out how to critically think — something I don't believe most teens can do about serious things. I've been in therapy for over a year with a very good, unbiased therapist and it has been extremely beneficial; my dysphoria is very much under control. I've been trying to process feelings I suppressed over the years. Talking with friends about how transitioning made me feel and affected me helped. Looking into research and facts about gender dysphoria and trans ideology also helped me come back to reality. I only recently was able to accept that I'm bi, most of that work done with my therapist. Figuring out what I'm really interested in has helped. I mostly drank, smoked, and partied while trans identified and didn't have a lot of genuine interests. Since detransitioning I've taken up scrapbooking — pictures and papers that mean things to me, pressed flowers I find, put together into books. I collect toys from my childhood, mainly Care Bears, and thrift them. I enjoy painting and customizing things, started photo albums, and have used film cameras for the past 3 years. Coloring or drawing helps when I feel really stressed. I try to go on daily walks. Finding a type of exercise I enjoyed is a big help because it's harder to think about your body when you're working out and having fun. As for self-confidence, my best advice is to care less about what other people think. I have more confidence now than I ever had, though I still have insecurities I try not to let stop me. I think most of the time gender dysphoria, like any form of dysphoria, has a "root." For me, my root was being sexually abused as a child, which led me to feel very disconnected from my body, especially my genitalia, which only worsened as I got older. I also developed an eating disorder when puberty started because I wanted to control my changing body and stay the same "stick"-like androgynous body type I had as a kid. Realizing my eating disorder and gender dysphoria were very intertwined has helped me. How I currently deal with my dysphoria is to dress how I like — fairly masculine — and try to cope with having breasts and hips as something it's okay to be uncomfortable with but that I don't need to change. I prefer having tried medical transition and then choosing to detransition, because it doesn't leave any thoughts of medical transition helping or curing my dysphoria, so I can focus on other ways to cope. I proposed a case study with my mom, a physical therapist, on physical therapy to help with damage from binding. I used an incentive deep breathing exerciser, tracked my progress, and did PT exercises, seeing positive changes in breathing and lung capacity in the first two weeks and reduced rib and back pain. We planned to publish it using only medical terminology, not trans or detrans related terms. I'm critical of trans ideology because, in my view, it messed up my life and health due to the recklessness of medical professionals and trans activists spreading false information. I don't want trans people to be mistreated — we were trans identified — but I'm worried about harm happening to dysphoric and gender non-conforming people and children. I believe therapists should evaluate mental health and help people cope, not push personal beliefs, and doctors should do what's best for patients. I don't blame others for what I did; I acknowledge I made decisions I wish I hadn't and I'm responsible for them. All I want is for young dysphoric people not to make the same decision I did when they could be helped by psychological intervention.