Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha detransizionato (reidentificato): nato maschio, mi sono identificato come trans/genderqueer dai 20 ai 25 anni circa e ho fatto la TOS per almeno 4,5 anni. Ho scelto di reidentificarmi come maschio continuando gli ormoni e spesso presentandomi ancora al femminile, definendolo un'estetica da "trap medicalmente potenziato", e sono ancora per lo più contento dei cambiamenti medici del mio corpo e pianifico altri interventi estetici. Faccio risalire la mia disforia a traumi patriarcali e a una socializzazione sessuata, e scoprire il femminismo gender critical e l'abolizionismo del genere mi ha spinto verso la reidentificazione. Ho posizioni fortemente critiche sull'ideologia trans, che descrivo come un culto e una religione, e consiglio ad altri che detransizionano di accettare il proprio sesso e di essere contenti di come sono. Non ho riferito pensieri suicidi, autolesionismo né tentativi di suicidio.
Storia completa
I was born male, and I first identified as trans around age 20, after a short stint identifying as some pretentious personal variant of genderqueer. I was convinced by the spread of trans ideology that I was "really female," and I identified as female from about age 20 to 25. I started HRT and was on it 4.5 years by the time I was 25 (posting in May 2019). I socially transitioned, and I came to see social transition as far more dangerous than medical transition for males, because the constant mental game of invalidation and "passing" is traumatic and exacerbates dysphoria, creating it where it wasn't before.
What led me toward transition, in my own reading of it, was patriarchal trauma and sexed socialization: I was ashamed of manhood, and as a teen I had a principled stance against telling girls I liked my feelings because I felt that was in the realm of frat chads. I also had autogynephilic crossdressing, which I described as a component of "failed male" socialization. I now believe pretty much all my dysphoria, including the physical, was caused by patriarchy, and that if I'd interrogated the notion of dysphoria before transitioning I may not have felt the need to. I think realizing that helped me a lot.
My move toward detransition — which I call "reidentification" rather than medical detransition — came through finding gender critical feminism. I decided to re-identify as male while continuing hormones and often still presenting female (makeup, skirts, long hair). I described this as a "medically enhanced trap" aesthetic and called myself "a biological male, aesthetically a trap, and ideologically a gender abolitionist." This was working out well for my self-esteem. I said I feel happier with my body now than I literally ever have, apart from putting on a little weight. I planned to keep going with light face and body work (not breast augmentation) to round out my femininity, and I acknowledged I'd exploit the medical-necessity framing for coverage. I also noted health concerns like possible DVT and hoped to get an orchiectomy or lower my dose.
I described myself as a "desister" or "reidentified," mostly happy with how medical transition changed my body, and I questioned why medical detransition is seen as so necessary for others. I said my experience of detransition is that gender isn't real, and that my desire for womanhood is faulty — because it's a sex I'll never be that's unfairly expected to be feminine — not my personal desire for femininity. I have a political stake in this because I was hurt mostly by social detransition and its basis in gender ideology. I described myself as an agp, and said that status evaporated with transition like usual and I didn't mind that; I was upset at being "invalidated" over it. I also expressed interest in hearing from an HSTS detrans person.
In January 2021 I commented: "I'm desisted and still medically transitioning including surgeries. You should do what you want, just be emotionally prepared to deal with potential regret. Thinking about what could've been is its own regret and worse imo." I also advised someone considering further surgery to "remain content as you are now," warning against chasing "a warped version of [the natural] further down the rabbit hole of physicalized identity," and said that given a lack of natural testosterone and male genitalia, such a step "would not be a detransition, it'd be a double transition." I told another person to "Stand pat the way we all should've to begin with" and to embark on a normal life.
I hold strongly critical views of trans ideology: I've called it "a cult, a pyramid scheme of validation," said "Being trans is just that, an ideology; basically a religion," and described "cis" as not real either. I've said gender dysphoria is experienced by countless never-transitioned people and that its definition is extremely vague. I've criticized misandrist feminists who preface all male desire to transition on fetishism, arguing that paraphilic arousal and a broader yearning for feminine things come from the same place — some failure to attach oneself to masculinity — which is normal for youth today given that the function of masculinity has been obscured. I've advocated gender abolition and separating sex from gender, and I said I feel a lot happier since finding gender critical feminism. I did not describe any specific therapy, formal advocacy, or organized activism beyond posting and commenting in these communities. I did not mention family, partners, friendships, career, education, or current relationship status. I did not describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.