Tutte le storie

Una terapeuta ha detto che forse era trans: ne ha trovata un'altra

Femmina · Desistito/a163
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una professionista sanitaria donna che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma che si espone contro la transizione medica dei giovani e l'ideologia di genere nelle istituzioni. Descrivo lo scetticismo tra i clinici in sala relax, le politiche delle risorse umane che impongono i pronomi e il silenziamento dei medici che sollevano obiezioni. Una volta una terapeuta ha suggerito che potessi essere trans; ho rifiutato l'idea e l'ho lasciata. Sostengo che i detransizionati e i critici debbano continuare a parlare pubblicamente. Resto critica verso la transizione per i giovani e verso l'ideologia che la spinge.

Storia completa

I work in healthcare — my entire family does — and I've been in this field for years. I never wanted to be the one saying any of this publicly, but the pressure inside the system has gotten unbearable, so I started speaking out on Reddit in April 2020. I want to be clear about where I stand: none of us want to go along with what's happening except, in my view, the deluded leftists on the ideological fringe. When a young person gets dragged in for a transition evaluation, there's a lot of eye-rolling and break-room griping about giving drugs to kids. But if a clinician refuses, the consequences are immediate — the accusation of transphobia, being fired, being sued by the patient for discriminating against a protected class, and potentially losing our licenses. That's the reality we operate under. HR has made it worse. I tested this deliberately: I told an HR rep I identified as a "dragon queer" gender, as a point about how absurd the whole framework had become. He still calls me xiss/xir/xisself even after I told him I was joking. That's how deep this runs — an educated adult can be told someone thinks they're a gay dragon, and the response is "oh! Okay, so you need wing space for your desk?" It's insane. What hurts most is watching young kids. My family sees it constantly — a kid who obviously didn't come to the conclusion on their own, who's parroting what people on the internet said or what their parents pushed. We can't say or do a thing. It's like watching a car crash in slow motion. If you complain, you get some vague non-answer and two weeks of sensitivity training. I've also seen it from the therapy side personally. A therapist told me I might be trans. I dropped that therapist immediately because I know I'm not — sorry, but not every girl who's into woodworking and distilling needs to be a man. But I know plenty of others who would have let that poison drip into their ears. I've straight up seen doctors slip in little comments that can eat away at someone over time. On the cultural side, I've thought a lot about what transition narratives get used for. Watching Hedwig's story — it's very clear in the film that Hedwig is NOT trans, but a gay man mutilated to escape a communist hell. A very handsome man wanted to take Hedwig as a boyfriend, but due to rampant homophobia, if Hedwig wanted to leave communist Germany he'd have to do so as a wife, not a husband. He was basically railroaded into being trans. I always felt so sorry for him. That same forced-transition dynamic is still happening in Iran today, and it gets ignored because it doesn't fit the approved narrative. I've encouraged detransitioners and whistleblowers to keep speaking out — people NEED folks willing to tell the truth, sometimes to protect young people against their own parents. I don't come to these forums for trolls; Reddit is basically the only channel left where this can be said. I've also pushed back on the reflexive framing where everyone who disagrees gets labeled racist or "not real." I was never personally on hormones or had any procedures — my involvement is as a healthcare professional and observer, not as someone who transitioned. My concern is systemic: the medicalization of kids, the silencing of clinicians, and the ideological capture of HR and institutional policy.