Tutte le storie

Un chirurgo le ha chiesto perché voleva essere un ragazzo

Femmina · Desistito/a245
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: una lesbica mascolina che si è identificata come trans e ha usato i pronomi he/him per quasi tre anni prima di fermarsi prima di ormoni e chirurgia. Un chirurgo plastico, non la terapeuta che mi dava il via libera, mi ha chiesto perché volessi essere un ragazzo e mi ha aiutata a capire che non avevo mai avuto disforia prima che la società mi spingesse fuori dalla mia identità da «maschiaccio». Ho ripreso la mia identità di lesbica mascolina e sono grata di aver evitato cambiamenti medici permanenti. Oggi sostengo una migliore comprensione dei rischi della transizione, continuando a sostenere l'accesso per le persone davvero trans, e considero omofobo spingere le donne mascoline verso la transizione. Resto politicamente moderata/indipendente e racconto attivamente la mia storia per aiutare gli altri.

Storia completa

I am a woman who was born female and who identified as a masculine lesbian for a long time before I was pushed toward identifying as trans. I never had dysphoria as a child — I was a tomboy, and I was comfortable being a masculine woman who is attracted to women. What changed was the social pressure around me: people in society took away my 'tomboy' status and gave me the status of 'trans.' Because I am masculine and I like girls, people around me insisted I must actually be a boy — a straight man born in a woman's body. I felt pressured by people for being a masc lesbian to be a boy, and it was unnerving how much force was put into making me feel like I, as a masc lesbian, was not right in my body. For almost three years I called myself by he/him pronouns and identified as trans. During that time I got very close to actually taking medication and having life-altering surgery. A therapist had already approved the path, saying 'Yeah go for it.' I attended a meet-up with a plastic surgeon about having my breasts removed. It was the surgeon, not the therapist, who stopped and asked, 'Wait a minute, why do you want to be a boy?' I told him my friends said I'm a boy and I like girls and I'm masculine. He asked me if I ever had dysphoria before people started to question my identity, and I said no. He told me that society made me lose my identity. I reacted badly at first — I got so angry, I yelled at him, I was mean to the doctor and said 'how dare you question my gender,' and I stormed out. But it got me thinking, and I thank god it did. I never took hormones and never had the surgery. I sent the doctor a thank-you card afterward; I wasn't able to go back in person because the drive was long, but he knows he changed my life. Slowly I have been gaining my identity back as a tomboy. I'm a lesbian, I'm into women, I love other masc lesbian women, and I feel better now saying that. I still feel for everyone who was pushed farther than I was. I know detransitioners face a stigma — being called fake, or hurt, or attacked by people you used to love and look up to — and I have felt ostracized, like I don't belong. What I regret is not a medical change, since I stopped short of hormones and surgery, but the three years of lost identity and the near-miss of permanent alterations. I am thankful every day that I stopped before medication or a mastectomy. My anger at the doctor turned into gratitude. I think about transition for other people in a conditional way: I want people who are genuinely positive about it to still have access, but I want to help those who are lost, confused, or unstable avoid making decisions they will someday regret. I see a real problem with masc women and 'girly-boys' being forced into a gender stereotype, which I consider very homophobic — the erasure of lesbian women because they are 'too masc' gets to me. I have done informal advocacy by sharing my story, offering my DMs to others who are struggling, and telling people not to let society tell them what they want to be. I describe myself as Moderate / Independent politically; cancel culture and hate attacks don't work on me — I'm 'too old to care.' I believe trans people deserve rights but shouldn't erase the rights of others to exist, and I think internet forums and groups have led some people down a dark road they never would otherwise have gone down. I also worry about friends who say anyone with dysphoria should just 'go on T for a year,' because hormone therapy can't simply be undone — it's permanent. I have encouraged others to come off hormones and resume their lives, and I congratulate people on figuring themselves out rather than falling prey to social constructs pushed by social media. I hold some strong views about gender and society: I feel women are told by society we're wrong and should just become men to fix our problems, and I argue that men control and own everything and make women's lives difficult. I don't fully understand why men would want to become women, since they wouldn't be gaining power by doing so. I don't think detransitioners are 'winning' for conservatives — rather, detransitioning has let me see the bigger picture and recognize that some conservative critiques have merit without agreeing with all of them. I believe most people in the trans movement have good intentions, but the movement has gotten mean and hateful toward the people who helped it. I also feel that being a detransitioner doesn't mean you're anti-trans, and the stigma needs to go away.