Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition o è critico sul genere, nato maschio e oggi identificato come uomo, con una laurea in biologia, che ha pubblicato soprattutto consigli e commenti più che la mia cronologia di transizione. In questo materiale non ho descritto alcuna disforia personale, passaggi di transizione o date di detransition, quindi la mia cronologia medica e identitaria non è documentata qui. Mi sono sempre opposto alla medicalizzazione automatica, al DSM-5 usato come sostituto della conoscenza di sé e all'uso di vecchie ricerche sul cervello per giustificare affermazioni generalizzate a favore della transizione, pur sostenendo l'accesso individuale a opzioni reversibili e a una buona terapia. Mi sono confrontato con le crisi altrui legate all'odio per sé e al rifiuto del testosterone incoraggiando l'aiuto professionale e ampliando il loro senso delle possibili espressioni di sé. In questo racconto non sono descritti ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo né tentativi di suicidio.
Storia completa
I am a man — born male — and I've spent a lot of time in these detransition and gender-questioning spaces, mostly offering practical and clinical-minded advice to other people rather than recounting my own transition story, because my own story is not what I've been posting about here.
A few things about me that do come through: I hold a B.S. in Biology focused on evolution, ecology, and zoology, with minors in Chemistry and Environmental Science, and I lean on that training when I weigh in on medical or biological questions. I'm 5'9". I'm a guy, and I've said plainly that I would never walk around the city alone at night — a friend of mine who's also a guy got mugged doing exactly that, and the mugger had a pistol, so physical strength was never part of the equation.
On the substance of what I've engaged with: I've thought a lot about the medical side of transition and detransition. I told someone considering stopping spironolactone that, given their young age, they should expect to develop normally as a male from that point on if they discontinue it, and I urged them to keep being monitored by their medical provider through that transition to make sure development stays normal and healthy. When they said they didn't want facial hair, I pointed to reversible options — prescription topical anti-androgens, eflornithine — that won't interfere with normal male development and can be stopped if they later change their mind, plus laser or electrolysis for permanence, and I suggested seeking a doctor who provides gender-affirming care if their current providers won't help. I've also noted that if someone ceases HRT, as a natal female they won't need finasteride for the hairline to recover — just time.
I've been blunt about the limits of the standard diagnostic apparatus. I told someone that laying everything at the feet of the DSM-5, its screening questionnaires, and the 'transwoman storyline' as a surrogate for doing the hard work of knowing your own mind and motivations is a good way to make the wrong decision for yourself. I've pushed back on the use of older brain-structure research — structural hermaphroditism in the brains of a small group of homosexual transsexuals — as a blanket justification for the modern transgender movement, arguing it doesn't speak to the great majority of currently transgender-identifying people with late-onset dysphoria post-puberty, and I asked pointedly whether we'd scan someone's brain before gender-affirming care, sending them to a surgeon for one result and a psychiatrist for another. I've also been careful with language and logic generally — I've explained the 'No true Scotsman' fallacy in detail, and I've commented on how little biology education the average American actually has.
I've given practical, non-judgmental support to people in the middle of it: I told one person in emotional crisis that cosmetic exogenous hormones don't lie on the path to optimal physical health, but also that they might hold limiting notions about self-expression — they could take feminizing therapies and present as a man, cease medicalization and present as a woman, or be androgynous — while acknowledging that biologically they are a man; I encouraged them to see a normal professional therapist to work through the crisis and eventually unpack self-hatred and hatred of testosterone. I've also commented on the physical side of vaginoplasty, saying I could never handle the daily or weekly dilating required because it closes up, which to me sounds like the biggest downside. On presentation, I've given straightforward style feedback — a sleek bob with bangs and eye makeup, or a hairstylist, clothes, makeup, and jewelry — and told people they look fine and I wouldn't clock them as a man.
I haven't described my own dysphoria, coming out, hormones, surgeries, or a detransition in any of this material, so I don't have a transition timeline of my own to give from these posts.