Tutte le storie

Cresciuta tra donne trans, poi ha iniziato a scrivere contro la transizione

Femmina · Desistito/a171
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition e vive in Canada, e scrivo in modo critico su transizione, stereotipi di genere e sul modo in cui le donne vengono giudicate. Lotto con la dismorfia corporea e la tocofobia, e trovo profondamente angoscianti i commenti legati alla gravidanza. Sono cresciuta attorno a un gruppo giovanile con donne trans e da tempo sono scettica verso le dichiarazioni di disforia di genere che vedo come infondate. In questo materiale non ho descritto un evento specifico di detransition, un intervento né un rimpianto. Al momento mi identifico come donna e sostengo una visione critica della transizione.

Storia completa

I have been active in detransition spaces through late 2025 and 2026, mostly offering blunt, sometimes combative advice to others. I was born female and I currently identify as a woman; I live in Canada. I don't lay out a full transition timeline in these comments, but several things about my own experience come through. I have dealt with body dysmorphia and what I call tokophobia — a dread of pregnancy. When people tell me my body is 'made for pregnancy,' I feel 'all sorts of horrid' and 'the dread is surreal,' and even typing it out feels unpleasant. I relate to viewing myself as 'simply an animal' rather than as a vessel for reproduction. I also note that I know testosterone 'can affect people harshly and severely long term,' which suggests familiarity with or close observation of masculinising hormones, though I don't state that I took them myself. I grew up in what I call my 'LTBG youth group' — I write it that way — where I had a 'banana mouth lesson' involving adults holding bananas 'where a dick would be' and racing to put condoms on. I found it 'so fucking weird,' especially since I was under the impression most attendees were lesbian and bi women; only later did I realise 'they had dicks.' This points to my being around trans women in a youth/community setting and to my own orientation being toward women. On mental health and adversity, I don't name diagnoses beyond dysmorphia and tokophobia. I discuss Freud critically, arguing he abandoned his seduction theory — that mental illness stems from childhood sexual abuse — under Victorian pressure and instead blamed children for 'wanting' molestation. I clearly take childhood sexual abuse seriously as a real phenomenon. I've thought a lot about how women are judged. I say I have 'high expectations' of myself as a woman: work full time, provide a stable loving home, be emotionally and physically supportive, and eventually be a mother — and if I don't do these well, I'm 'judged very harshly.' I don't know any women who aren't judged on productivity. I also critique trans women's presentation as 'the most sexist caricature of a woman,' while saying I don't see the same caricature in FTM people, who 'just go to work, work extra hard to prove themselves worthy.' I'm skeptical of gender dysphoria claims that I think have 'no foundation,' telling one person they'd have the same issues as a woman and that 'the expectations don't go away.' I push back hard on the idea that only women can improve their looks, and I'm blunt to the point of hostility with people I think argue in bad faith. I also counsel a young person that they're 'not a girly boy, you're just a boy,' and that identity can be 'day and night' different at 30. I don't describe a specific detransition event, surgery, regret, or current mental-health outcome in this transcript. My stance overall is critical of transition as a solution, grounded in my own dysmorphia, tokophobia, and feminist analysis of how women are judged.